[The French left were divided over Maastricht with…]
Socialist Organiser1992 1992-09-23Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 4
The French left were divided over Maastricht with Rouge arguing not very elegantly (and appearing very nationalistic) "Non" and Lutte Ouvriere taking an independent working class position.
HAPPENED TO THE -pockets of the currency EXCHANGE RATE? can't change thet E10 BILLION THE BANK pounds on that scale would •LAST FEW HOURS some time, but then in the deutschmarks, dollars, and sitting down with a stack of so on, to buy pounds, and paper and a pen and Now the Bank of England Bundesbank. has E10 billion in pounds. It Billions have been paid deutschmarks or whatever, speculators, and even more at a loss. If the pound goes billions have been made England loses E1 billion on 150,000 new council billion from the pockets of hospitals/ was the equivalent of about Anatole Kaletsky, in the £I0. If the pound goes Times, declares that down to 2.40 marks, then "Happy days are here that 28-mark item will cost again". He predicts rapid £11.70. Its price will go up growth resulting from cuts happening, but only part. 17 per cent. in interest rates in the fol.
Since imports are about lowing scenario: one-third of the British "Never in the last 30 years economy, prices on average has Britain faced less of a will increase about 6%. threat of inflation than it They are increasing at does today. Union militancy about 4% a year already. is non-existent and wage third explanation. Add 6% to 4%, and that rises are at record lows...
makes 10% inflation. The collapse of ERM • Cuts in real wages, and membership offers the government a once-in-a-lifetime WHAT HAS the taxpayers into the speculators. On top of that, E7 BILLION THE the taxpayers have to pay GOVERNMENT about E700 million a year in interest on the E7 billion break the party/trade union connection" BORROWED TO the Government offered.
"That's capitalism" , as TRY TO KEEP UP Norman Lamont said!
THE POUND'S But it's worse than that. In fact the Bank of England AND TO THE E10 billion back into marks now, because selling OF ENGLAND crash the exchange ratel In the long term, it can SPENT IN THE change the money back union link.
long term it can just print BEFORE THE more pound notes anyway.
POUND LEFT THE A pound note is just an IOU from the Bank of EXCHANGE RATE England. The Bank of MECHANISM? England does not become and trade unions. richer by holding more The Bank of England pounds, any more than you spent E10 billion in would become richer by - thus, it hoped, through writing millions of IOUs. It force of supply-and- does become poorer by demand, to keep up the holding fewer marks, i.e.
National Executive... pound's value. fewer IOUs from the movement in Britain at risk. could change it back into out to banks and down 10%, to about DM unusable. Ten billion 2.50, then the Bank of pounds would pay for same class politics.
the whole business - E1 houses or 300 new chance. The nation's desire for low interest rates is now so intense that an extremely tough public spending round would readily be accepted as a quid pro quo.
Even such previously unthinkable ideas as freezing public sector wages and suspending the indexation of non-means-tested social security benefits and pensions would surely be acceptable in exchange for a cut of 3 or 4 per cent in interest rates".
There are several things wrong with this right-wing argument in its own terms. For a start, a cut in interest rates is not a magic recipe for growth. Look at the US now, with 3% interest rates!
But anyway, Mr Kaletsky's "happy days" will certainly not be happy for the working class!
What the Labour leftists say is mindless blather. They have just seized on devaluation because it looks like a "popular" "winnable" cause against the Tory Government. WHAT DETERMINES EXCHANGE RATES?
If capitalists are exporting from Germany to Britain -so their costs are in marks and their receipts are in pounds - or from Britain to Germany, so their costs are in pounds and their receipts in marks, they need some way of changing their receipts into their home currency, and some agreed rate: so many marks to the pound A baseline for that rate is set by the ratio of the different money-units to an objective standard. If widgets are produced in both Germany and in Britain with the same technology, and cost f1 in Britain and DM 3 in Germany, then the rate should be f1 = DM 3.
Today less than one-tenth of foreig exchange dealing i directly connected with trade."
SO WHY DO EXCHANGE RATES VARY SO MUCH? People change pounds and marks, and other currencies, not just for trade, but also for investment, and, increasingly, for speculation. Today less than one-tenth of foreignexchange dealing is directly connected with trade.
Exchange rates vary a lot from the baseline, depending on interest rates and expectations. If you have $1 million earning 3% interest, then you gain by converting it to DM 1.5 million earnisn't working
Scan page 5
CRISISE especially international they make do with what cripm tor preateproil. jects, like London's dswing. financial empires, like machine-making indusIvan Boesky's, Michael tries are hit doubly hard.
Savings and Loans com- ruined business-people, pames, were DunE ornat more pressure to keep EBROGUCTOP CACHE credit. wages down - which in The bubble was bound turn means lower sales, це wI by the US government's Ther P le attempts to put right the starter li -00 Teatedio perance on share of the expanding est trad ayinte Si delicit forcer profits. The expansion is pungeu menutoble Run milow or chediti is limited increase there is capitalist cities are full of is likely to continue excess offices and half- dong I demar a Panes time yet.
"good ing 9% interest, even though that DM 1.5 million will not buy nearly as much as the $1 million. If you have £1 million and you reckon that the pound's value will drop, then you gain by converting it to DM 2.8 million (and being able to change it back into £1.17 million or so after the pound has dropped), even if the interest rate on pounds is 15%.
WHAT IS THE EFFECT OF VARYING EXCHANGE RATES? AND ARE GOVERNMENTS SO WORRIED ABOUT THEM?
According to free-market dogma, all the to-ing and fro-ing should produce a harmonious self-regulating system. In fact it tends to divide countries into a few with "strong" currencies and many with "weak" currencies.
The "weak" countries have chronic difficulty in exporting enough to match their imports. They suffer a "flight of capital" (rich people moving their wealth to "stronger" economies). They have big foreign debts; high inflation; currencies which keep on losing value relative to the "stronger" ones; inadequate investment; and low industrial productivity.
There is a vicious circle -not unbreakable, and not without exceptions and counter-tendencies - in which all the elements of the "weak" economy reinforce each other.
The exports of the "strong" countries become more expensive in the "weak" currencies, but generally the "strong" country's productivity advantage is enough to overcome that problem. A country which tries to make its currency "strong" without having a "strong" productive base behind it will be in trouble - like Britain under the Tories! WHAT MAKES INTEREST RATES GO UP AND DOWN? AND WHAT IS THE EFFECT OF HIGH OR LOW INTEREST RATES? Interest is the slice that money-lending capitalists take out of the surplus value produced by workers. The size of the slice depends on the balance of forces between money-lending capitalists and industrial capitalists: it tends to be lower in booms and higher in slumps.
There are many complications. Just as interest rates affect exchange rates, so also exchange rates can affect interest rates; and a government can manipulate interest rates by setting the rate which its central bank lends money to commercial banks.
High interest rates tend to depress industry by taking a big slice out of its profits. Low interest rates sometimes lead to inflation, by letting credit expand out of proportion to production. WHY ARE THE TORIES PREPARED TO SACRIFICE SO Often, "the fight against inflation" is just code for "the fight against wage rises" . But there is more to it than that.
In the 1950s and 1960s inflation averaged a bit over 3%, and capitalism thrived on it.
"Such inflation means that worker are bound to be constantly pushing for wage rises.
Such inflation means that workers are bound to be constantly pushing for wage rises. That was not a big problem in the booming 1950s and '60s, but it is nowWorse, in the 1970s bosses discovered that g tle inflation could rapi spiral out of control slumps. They resolved try to suppress it.
WHY DOES THE CAPITALIST CLASS LET THE SPECULATORS GET AWAY WITH IT?
Because they are the speculators themselves! The young men and women seen on our TVs peering into computer screens deal WHY ISiTHE ECONOMIE Slumps aren antonline credit apitalistsysurm every capitalist one of the mid-1980s, "overshoots". It leaves masses of poverty and even unemployment the buil ding new offices, factories, overshootsithe not in their own money but in that of big capitalist companies and banks. They, and their bosses, get a handsome commission on the deals, but the big winners are multinational companies, banks, pension funds, and so on.
Governments and central banks lose. Until the 1980s, they used to impose "exchange controls" to limit buying and selling of currencies. It would take a much worse crisis to make them reimpose those exchange controls, because lots of multinational companies and big businesses The mid Boy ypturn WE pushed along ty staceyng organ Vast speculative proDocklands, and sleazy Millken's, Robert Maxwell's, Alan Bond's, the BCCI, or the US to burst. It was pricked an Now, from Canary Wharf to Tokyo, the big Socialist Organiser No. 535 page 5 have a powerful interest i today's deregulated interna tional finance markets. IS THE BASIC PROBLEM THAT BRITAIN ENTERED THE EXCHANGE RATE MECHANISM TOO HIGH A LEVEL?
"Capitalism in crisis world-wide in Germany, Japan and the US as well as Britain."
No. The pound has been slipping relative to the mark for many years (it was over 11 marks to the pound as recently as 1967). As long as it keeps slipping, any fixed rate would become "too high". . Now it looks as if any rate above DM 2.50 is "too high"; and if Britain had entered the ERM with the pound at DM 2.50, then the resulting inflation would have soon made DM 2.50 "too high" IS JOHN SMITH RIGHT TO SAY THAT THE BASIC PROBLEM IS MISMANAGEME OF THE "REAL ECONOMY", I.E. INDUSTRY?
Yes. But the problem is not just the Tory being bad managers of British capitalism. Capitalism is in crisis world-wide - in Germany, Japan and the US as well as Britain. And, sadly, John Smith has no proposals to do anything more about capitalism than tinker with details.
Few capitalists are buymachinery oi buddhant sales tom they have, and maybe even try to sell off some of their assets. Thus the construction and All that means more people out of work, more ed only late last year in Germany and Japan, and
Scan page 6
er
----- pull-quotes -----
MUCH FOR "ZERO INFLATION"?