Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

[He plays the bigoted, wealthy, folk-singing candidate, Bob…]

Socialist Organiser no. 534, 17 September 1992 · scan p. 13 · about 848 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 13 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 13

He plays the bigoted, wealthy, folk-singing candidate, Bob Roberts, but he's too likeable for the part. Roberts should be frightBelinda Weaver ening; he should - on some level -Bob Roberts convey menace. Robbins can't pull •Bim sting American ob Roberts" suffers from it off.

Of course, that's partly his mesfilm satirising American sage - that Bob Roberts has politics - how do you caricature a appeal, that people like him and caricature? follow him - but his performance The film is good on the increasing pulls the punch. He can't put over emptying out of all content from the right wing politics. American politics, and its replace- Bob Roberts also doesn't seem so ment with images and icons, with different from the people who do soundbites and presentations and get elected to Congress. The place staged events. But it isn't sharp is awash with rednecks and holy enough; it isn't angry enough. rollers; Roberts would fit right in.

Another weakness is the star (and He's not as far right as he needs to writer and director) Tim Robbins. be to be any kind of threat to democracy. Buchanan, is worse.

"What threatens American democrat What threatens American democracy is not people like Roberts, but the system as a whole. The government is in hock to big business, the military, the CIA, and the rest. It governs in the interests of a powerful, wealthy ruling class.

Democrat or Republican, it makes no difference. They serve the same master.

In the film, Roberts is contrasted with the incumbent, the liberal Brinkley Paiste. Paiste is played by Gore Vidal, and he's not bad - full of fine words that you know don't mean a damn. He pays lip service to the homeless, the jobless, but he's done nothing, and he'll do You can see why people, after twenty years of that stuff, go for Roberts - the way some people went for Ross Perot. They want change - any change. They'll risk a leap of faith.

Faith, unswerving faith, is what it's all about for many of Roberts's followers. They're fanatics. so rational argument is lost on them. It doesn't matter that Roberts is dirty, that his campaign manager has dabbled in drugs and guns -they simply close their ears and cling blindly to their faith.

The media too connive to whitewash Roberts, by accepting his reinvention at face value. Yes, Roberts is a phony and a hypocrite and probably a crook, but his emptiness matches theirs. They won't expose him. They're part of the same system that produced him.

One person who does want to expose Koberts (apart from Paiste, who really only wants to beat him is Bugs Raplin, a journalist who produces a radical paper called Troubled Times. Unlike any of the official media, Raplin has done his homework, painstakingly uncovering Roberts's links to gunrunning, drug dealing, a failed Savings & Loan.

Like Paiste, who willingly concedes the country is run by the National Security Council, along with the military and the CIA, Raplin can see through the charade of Senate politicking. The difference is Raplin cares about it, and wants to change it. He's prepared to publish, only the mainstream media don't want to know. It's part of Raplin's conspiracy theory that the truth always gets ignored.

What's missing from his tirades is why this happens; why the people behind the scenes are pulling the levers. To Raplin (and to Paiste), it's about power, when really it's about money. Power is simply the means to get money; having money gives you more power.

Because money talks. As Roberts shows, Americans can forgive milThe fifth episode of this six-part series looks at the relationship between the monarchy and elected politicians.

Previous episodes have been very bland, but will this one tackle the Why should an unelected dimwit parasite have the right to vet all legislation before it goes through Parliament, to veto it afterwards and make and unmake governments?

lionaires anything; "self-made" millionaires are the American Dream. Money doesn't stink.

Raplin's may be the voice Tim Robbins wants heard, Raplin's rather than Paiste's. Paiste doesn't offer anything; Raplin has passion and conviction. But Robbins sets Raplin up to seem a crazy, a monomaniac, a pest. He's always hyper, and sweating, and he's disabled; Robbins couldn't have hampered him more.

Of course we do empathise with Raplin. After all the smooth empty faces we've seen, his is at least alive, but Robbins sacrifices him for effect. And there's no knowing where Raplin comes from, whether he's part of a movement. Like Bob Roberts, he comes out of nowhere.

The character of Bob Roberts began as a satire, and that may be the problem. Robbins may think he's a bit of a laugh, when really he's appalling. In sending up people like Roberts, Robbins may have got even, but he forgot to get mad.

----- pull-quotes -----

is not people like Roberts, but the system as a whole. The government is in hock to big business, the military, the CIA, and the rest."

10.20pm Sunday 20 September. The Monarchy

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 534

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →