Marxism lives!
Socialist Organiser1992 1992-09-17Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 12 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 12
Marx's theory of capitalist development and production is still an essential starting ›oint for anyone who wants to fight oppression and exploitation. Chris Arthur has prepared for Lawrence and Wishart an abridged edition of Marx's Capital, to appear shortly. Here he explains why we still need it. W is that Karl hy Capital! Why now? The truth Marx's masterpiece is as germane today as when it first appeared in 1867.
All those who are not taken in by the current triumphalist discourse of capitalist apologetic, and who want to understand the world in order to change it, will find that in the end the inescapable starting point for all social criticism is Marx's Capital. Trade Unionists, socialists, feminists, ecologists, anti-imperialists, all those who find themselves in opposition to the existing order, need to grasp Marx's theory because even where it does not address their immediate concerns, it marks out the parameters within which their problems arise.
This is because today, as yesterday, the single most important determinant of social development is the ruthless drive of capital accumulation and its inexorable penetration into all corners of the world (the last frontier, the Amazon, has just fallen) and all aspects of our lives.
What is most remarkable is that Marx himself had in front of him only the beginnings of the story. Yet only his book makes any sort of sense of the last one hundred and fifty years, of industrialisation and urbanisation, of slumps and booms, of imperialism and multinational companies, of hunger in the midst of plenty. With tremendous intellectual power he cut through to the essentials of the capitalist mode of production and elaborated a theory of its development which remains the fundamental starting point for understanding new phenomena as they arise and offer themselves for Marx foresaw the increasing power of the forces of production; the increasing socialisation of the labour process; the transformation of the great majority of people into employees; the application of science to industry and agriculture; the transformation of the instruments of production into instruments only usable in common; mechanisation and automation; increasing productivity of labour; the creation of a world market; the erosion of national boundaries; the concentration and centralisation of capital; recurrent recessions; a declining rate of profit; strikes and revolutions.
Of course the twentieth century brought new phenomena - imperialist wars, fascism, Stalinism, and so on - but again the only people with any grip on events were the Marxists: Luxemburg, Lenin, and Trotsky, for example. Trotsky predicted that the twentieth century would be a century of wars and revolutions. The bourgeois apologists fantasied about universal harmony based on the mutual advantages of trade. And if there were still slumps they were teething troubles in "the system of natural liberty' (Adam Smith).
At the time of writing we are in the middle of a slump. The explanation offered in the financial press is that there is a lack of "consumer confidence" . What a circular argument! Because the explanation for this lack of confidence is precisely the current crisis. Compared with the poverty of this philosophy, we might be forgiven for preferring Marx's investigation of the underlying laws of capitalist development with its recurrent crises.
Marx's remarkable achievement in this respect is ignored by critics whose sole concern is to refute a prediction he did not make, namely a supposed law of "With tremendous intellectual the fundamental starting offer themselves for immiserisation of the working class. In truth, Marx's assumptions of capital growth through increasing productivity implicitly points to an increase in real wages. (A firm cannot profit from massproducing TVs unless there is a mass market for them.
Marx himself points out that the real wage and the value of labour-power can vary in opposite directions, given improvements in productivity Examination of the 'increasing misery' passage reveals that it relates to the semipermanently unemployed.
Certainly Marx held that capitalism constantly reproduces a 'reserve of army of labour'. For Marxism it was the postwar boom that was exceptional, not mass unemployment. Thus it was no surprise when large-scale unemployment reappeared in the eighties.
It might be said that however many people live on the poverty-line the welfare system stops them dying in the street. True - for what is worth.
But capitalism is a world system. To cushion the proletarians at the core it exported misery to the huddled masses of the periphery. What about the workless inhabitants of Third World shanty-towns? For that matter what about the people there who actually find work? Next time you eat a banana try to guess the wage of the person who picked it. Next time you open a tin, try and guess the life expectancy of a Bolivian tinminer.
Then ask yourself how many centuries it will take until the fantastic wealth evident in the imperialist megalopolises 'trickles down' to them! Nor do higher wages than in Marx's day, or the shareholdings that some better-off workers currently possess, directly or indirectly, mean Marx's perspectives are to be abandoned. The key question is who holds power in society. Who can give or withhold a livelihood for someone else, and who has to beg for employment.
Marx points out that possession ings, even of investments, does not make someone a capitalist unless the returns are sufficient to live off. The truth is that the big companies are still controlled by a handful of people no matter how many small shareholders get a few crumbs off the table.
Of course Marx did not get everything right. He would be surprised that capitalism is still 'alive and kicking'. This is partly a matter of a telescoped time-scale. Partly it relates to deeper problems, of which the most important is that Marx over-estimated the unity of the working The fragmentation of the class by nation, race, religion, sex, occupation, industry, skill, and culture, together with the uneven global development of capitalism itself, has meant that the shortcomings of the system have always been experienced differentially, and the slogan of the Manifesto "Workers of the World Unite!" has remained almost a dead letter. Conversely, the lack of united opposition promoted accommodation and incorporation, partial perspectives, or unrealistic attempts at short-cuts. History will have the last word. As always..
Nonetheless, for those today who need to situate their oppositional practice theoretically Marxism remains, as Sartre pointed out, "the inescapable philosophy of our time" . This is not to say it has always been understood. The tidal wave of student protest and not only students in fact) in 1968 affiliated, in its bulk, to Marxism. Capital reading groups abounded in the universities throughout the seventies. Yet it has to be said that most activists lacked the patience to come to terms with its weight.
But Marxism without Capital is a nonsense. This is the work for which Marx sacrificed his health, his family, and the best years of his life. This is the very centre of his thought. According to his materialist conception of history it is the way society organises its system of production that provides the key to understanding social and political struggles. It is the economic structure that divides society into classes, and quarrels over the disposition of the wealth created that set them against one another. It is economic crisis that is the most potent source of revolutionary changes in the entire social order (although the specific modalities of class struggle determine whether and how change occurs).
Hence Marx devoted his life to studying that mode of production which dominates the modern epoch, namely capitalism; the result he hoped would aid the working-class movement he believed would overthrow it. Without a firm grasp of Capital radical social criticism can only be partial and impressionistic, unable to grasp the underlying unity behind apparently independent problems, and issuing in well-intentioned proposals that are in fact utopian, because they do not go to the roots of the problem, the nature of capitalism itself which will negate their effect one way or another.
Not only does Capital remain relevant in the West; but, paradoxically perhaps, if the East goes capitalist unpleasant realities will force them to turn back to it also. In short, anyone who takes Marxism seriously and wishes to further their own political education must come to terms with Capital.
Scan page 13
THE CULTURAL FRON Tim Robbins plays Bob Roberts, a self-styled " reactionary rebel" DON'T GET CAUGH miser
----- pull-quotes -----
power he cut through to the essentials of the capitalist mode of production and elaborated a theory of its development which remains
point for understanding new phenomena as they arise an