Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

French Marxists say: neither Maastricht nor "national sovereignty"! Yes to workers' unity! NON NONT

Socialist Organiser no. 534, 17 September 1992 · scan p. 3 · about 621 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 3 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 3

Cuts, unemployment, despair uts, unemployment, despair and racism - that's the and racism that's the future offered to us by Europe's bosses and capitalist politicians, both the pro-Maastricht ones like John Major and Helmut Kohl and the antiMaastricht ones like Margaret Thatcher and Jean-Marie le Pen.

The answer to both capitalist factions, the Euro-bosses and the nationalists, is for workers to unite across Europe.

That is why most of the Marxist left in France will be campaigning for workers to abstain in the Maastricht referendum on Sunday 20 September. "Neither yes with Chirac, nor no with Le Pen". , says the Marxist weekly Lutte Ouvrière — and its arguments should guide the left in Britain, too.

The main forces for a no vote in France are right-wing — Gaullists and the fascist National Front. The Communist Party also says The CP's arguments, like those of the Labour Left in Britain, mix anti-capitalist feelings with nationalism: Maastricht, the CP says, is a conspiracy by the Euro-bosses to take away democracy and French sovereignty, and to impose austerity.

Lutte Ouvrière replies: "Whatever ¡Humanité [the CP paper] says, a no vote is not the way to block attacks on social conditions. To suggest that is to demobilise the workers and, once again, to channel their bitterness and their legitimate worries into a blind alley.

The CP says again and again that Maastricht means worse austerity, unemployment, and social welfare cuts, that, more of what is underway in France, and in other European countries too, in order to allow the capitalists to continue to make profits... on the back of the workers and the people.

That is true, but we will get all that Maastricht or no Maastricht.

The problem for the workers is precisely to block such policies, and not to be diverted from the real issues by electoralist traps...

The CP, by calling for a no vote...

Boand Graham Bash Vladimir Derer Terry Eagleton Jatin Haria (Labour Party Black Sections)

Dorothy Macedo Joe Marino John Mcllroy John Nicholson Peter Tatchell Membersipr the Fr ommneeere sawo sroer UIET ldss cenqounpr ne leg ePeSeCOT Trewabpur ch-iuntia0 IST ASOCI ditorial Board. Le rens no campaign: mucn o and making itself the champion of "French sovereignty' , does nothing to prepare a counter-offensive by labour. On the contrary. On the terrain of nationalism and xenophobia, it links up with anti-working-class forces. It gives grist to Le Pen's mill. It plays on the same sentiments as Le Pen, and Le Pen is likely to be the one who gains most from this de facto unity...

The CP says that 'the yes vote plays into the hands of the right wing'. But we put this question to all communist militants: doesn't the no vote play even more into the hands of Le Pen?...

There is only one way of not falling into a trap... that is to abstain..."

Lutte Ouvrière also explains why socialists cannot vote yes to Maastricht. "This conglomerate called the 'Europe of 12' is obviously not made in the interests of the workers, but in the interest of the possessing classes.

That is why, as communists and therefore internationalists and Europeans, we think we must not say yes in this referendum, where we get only a rigged choice."

A similar view is argued by a minority on another of France's Marxist weeklies, Rouge: "Of course we condemn the Maastricht treaty. It is a treaty of commitment to the market economy and to capitalism...

But... there is no frontier between the current pro- and antiMaastricht camps. The bourgeoisie is on both sides. And [by voting no] we are objectively taking the side of HA THẤNG!

----- pull-quotes -----

ganiser. NeWs cadte Seutu horssand nguwr the Allidbrly

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 534

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →