[Liz Millward takes iss hris Knight has let…]
Socialist Organiser1992 1992-09-10Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 7 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 7
Liz Millward takes iss hris Knight has let himself be carried away by his dies very that the menstrual cycles of women who live together slowly come to coincide. This discovery has led him to all sorts of fantastical conclusions. Unfortunately for Chris, he has not yet discovered enough about female physiology!
Chris must have noticed that breast-feeding women do not menstruate. Add a nine months' pregnancy to a year's breast-feeding, and you have a woman who does not menstruate for the best part of two years.
Our earliest ancestors knew noth ing about today's sophisticated methods of birth control; therefore it is likely that the onset of menstruation signalled a woman regaining fertility, rather than the reverse, as Chris would have it.
If I understand it, Chris's thesis i that the women of a primitive community simultaneously menstruated in order to send the men out hunting together, by removing the temptation to stay at home and canoodle. Chris extrapo lates from this and reads backwards to find a form of primitive physical solidarity in "the first class struggle"
Think about it from what we know today. Assume three women live in one flat. Over time - a period of perhaps six months or more — their menstrual cycles will tend to converge. But the synchro nisation will be disrupted.
Assume that one gets pregnant and gives birth. She stops bleeding for nine months, and then for another year afterwards, as she lactates. She then starts to bleed, no longer menstrually synchronised with the others.
The others continue together. Bul then one of them gets pregnant... You see it is a tendency to synchro nise, sometimes realised, but regularly disrupted. This could not be the basis for concerted and frequent sex strikes by women. Take a woman in the first period of preg nancy when she is not bleeding and continues — until taboos intervene at a later stage — to be sexually available to the husband: how would she exert pressure? The same goes for a lactating woman - and primitive peoples continue breastfeeding for a very long time. In our time, old wives' wisdom had it that you could not get pregnant if you were breastfeeding — though in fact you can — and until recently, at least, birth control handbooks warned of this popular fallacy. We can observe that when certain mammals come "into season", it is signalled by slight bleeding. So, I contend, the most likely significance of menstruation was to give a clear and unmistakable signal that fertility had returned.
How does Chris Knight Imagine that the tendency to synchronise menstrual cycles led in fact to a real and continual synchronisation of all the women in a community? The sex strike thesis must have it that somehow it did do that.
Even supposing that all the children of each generation of the community really were born in perfectly synchronised groups (which is an inescapable corollary of the thesis of menstruation in union), and all their mothers breastfed for an identical length of time, then the hunting parties would only go out once every two years. The women would have grown very hungry!
Karl Marx and Frederick Engels wrote in the Communist Manifesto that the class struggle ends either in the victory of the representatives of a higher order, or in the mutual ruination of the contending classes. Mutual ruin here, I think, and quickly!
"A tendency synchronise menstrual cycles, regularly disrupted, could not be the basis for concerted and frequent sex strikes by women."
Chris has only been able to make his discovery having met a group of women older than puberty who are neither pregnant, nor breastfeeding, nor post-menopausal. This has only been possible since the advent of widely available methods of birth control. Previous generations of women, including the primitive societies Chris is talking about, did practise birth control, but only in a haphazard fashion. The majority of women were slaves to fertility and produced children until they died at an early age. The chances of Chris's thesis of synchronised menstruation holding good for an entire community would be extremely remote.
To repeat: I think it far more likely that after a long break during pregnancy and breastfeeding, the return of bleeding indicated fertility, and that far from going hunting the men would most likely have been hanging around outside the caves and huts like bees round a honeypot.
Scan page 8
Organiser
----- pull-quotes -----
with Chris Knight's theories about how humankind developed apes (SO 531)