Union leaders Union leaders gut
Socialist Organiser1992 1992-09-10Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 5 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 5
But, when members of the NALGO delegation arrived in Blackpool, they found that their original motion had been total ly gutted in the process of being 'composited" with another fron NALGO General Secretary, Alan Jinkinson, had been very In the original NALGO motion, there was a clear and unambiguous commitment to the right to strike. This was replaced with 'the right to strike supported by a ballot'. So workers could still, presumably, be sacked for 'unconstitutional' or The original also contained an unambiguous clause on solidarity action: 'the right to strike for all trade unionists in including secondary or solidarity action, without fear of dismissal, fines or sequestration...' This was replaced by the bizarre formula "The right to legal solidarity action'. The right to do what's legal — that's a daring demand!
"The right to picket effectively' became the right to picket peacefully', which is not quite the same thing! And the right to stop work wherever health and safety are threatened' was transformed into 'effective legislation to safeguard employees"
Jinkinson was able to get away with this because of the support he got from the NALGO delegation, many of whom were not too keen on being instructed by their own conference to move NALGO policy on the anti-union laws at the TUC A member of the NALGO delegation told Socialist In the delegation meeting, Jinkinson announced that the composite with the T&G contained the same approach as the original, but that's a load of rubbish. The only similarity was a call for legal rights. the substance of the rights was very differ*Really, our delegation should have voted against Jinkinson's composite, but it never got to the vote. Most of the executive weren't bothered about sticking up for NALGO's policy because they don't agree with it anyway! Others were far too NALGO to look 'silly' by voting against NALGO's composHaving done his wrecking job, Jinkinson then presented "Composite 2' to the annual congress. Most speakers in support then counterposed the NALGO/T&G composite to the NUM's The debate then started to take on a rather surreal quality as speaker after speaker in support of the composite devoted most of their time to impassioned speeches about the iniquity of the Tory laws - laws that the composite they supported would keep on the statute books. Bill Morris of the TGWU was the In the end, NALGO and the TGWU won overwhelmingly, while the NUM got just about 25% on a show of hands.
she other big debate at this year's TUC is likely to be over the EETU and its reaffiliation to the TUC. According to a rank and file member of the GPMU print union delegation, their leadership are coming under intense pressure from the General Council to accept a 'compromise.
*Dubbins has spent all the TUC so far in meetings. He's being squeezed to back down, but I can't see how he can come away *Time after time, the left wins the argument on the floor of congress, we convince a clear majority of lay delegates, we win the most applause and then the General Secretaries make sure That's how lan Cuthbert, chair of the NCU Broad Left, Dave Ayre, a member of the UCATT delegation, agreed with that assessment: "Scargill got the loudest cheers by far for his speech on the anti-union laws. He won the argument but lost Probably a quarter, at least, of the delegates in Blackpool oppose the direction the TUC is taking, but there is no unified left force at the Congress that can draw together that opposiThe NCU Broad Left held a fringe meeting at this year's Congress to raise the question of uniting the left across the The meeting attracted around 50 delegates and visitors.
Audrey Wise, President of USDAW, spoke for many when she said: "We've got to find ways of working together, of discussing a way forward and developing a strategy.
The Socialist Movement Trade Union Committee is planning a one-day conference early next year to help unite the trade union left. Contact STUC, c/o 53 Geere Road, London E15. left is doing to fight back.
he debate on the anti-union laws at this NISIDETHE year's TUC could have been both serious and fruit- UNIONIS ful. The original agenda included a clear call from the NUM for the repeal of By Sleeper all the Tory laws and a comprehensive motion from NALGO calling on the General Council Charter of positive legal rights.
the TGWU.
"flexible' with his own union policy.
'unofficial' action.