Genetic mix and match
Socialist Organiser1992 1992-09-03Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 14 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 14
to death - it is officially admitted by the government! - of its employees by advanced Japanese capitalism; and also the economic neglect and virtual abandonment to ruin and starvation of "unprofitable" areas like Bangladesh and parts of Africa.
rom that comes the cultural blight and barbarism of a society force-fed on profitable pap.
From it come products with "built-in obsolescence" and a society orientated to the grossly wasteful production and reproduction of shoddy goods, not to the development of leisure and culture.
From it come mass unemploymen the development of a vast and grow ing underclass, living in ghettos and the recreation in some American cities of the worst Third World conditions.
From it comes the unfolding ecological disaster of a world crying ou for planning and the rational use of resources, but which is, tragically, organised by the ruling classes around the principles of anarchy and the barbarous worship of blind and humanly irrational market forces.
From it come wars and genocides; two times this century capitalist gangs possessing worldwide power have fallen on each other in quarrel over the division of the spoils, and wrecked the world economy, killing many tens of millions. From it com racism, imperialism, and fascism.
The capitalist cult of icy egotism and the "cash nexus" as the decisivi social tie produces societies like Britain now where vast numbers of young people are condemned to livi in the streets, and societies like that of Brazil, where homeless children are hunted and killed on the streets like rodents.
From the exploitation of wage-labour comes our society in which the rich, who with their servants an agents hold state power, fight a relentless class struggle to maintair the people in a condition to accept their own exploitation and abuse. To join the Workers' L to PO Box I SE15 4NA. economy under workers' control. The working class can win reforms within capitalism, but we can only win socialism by overthrowing capitalism and by breaking the state power - that is, the monopoly of violence and reserve violence - now held by the capitalist class. We want a democracy much fuller than the present Westminster system - a workers' democracy, with elected representatives recallable at any time, and an end to bureaucrats' and managers' privileges.
Socialism can never be built in one country alone. The workers in every country have more in common with workers in other countries than with their own capitalist or Stalinist rulers. We support national liberation struggles and workers' struggles worldwide, including the struggles of workers and oppressed nationalities in the ex-Stalinist states of Eastern Europe and in still-Stalinist What are the alternatives now? We may face new wars as European and Japanese capitalism confronts the US. Fascism is rising. Poverty, inequality and misery are growing.
Face the bitter truth: either we build a new, decent, sane, democratic world or, finally, the capitalists will ruin us all - we will be dragged down by the fascist barbarians or new massive wars. Civilisation will be eclipsed by a new dark age. The choice is socialism or barbarism.
Socialists work in the trade unions and the Labour Party to win the existing labour movement to socialism. We work with presently unorganised workers and youth.
To do that work the Marxists organise themselves in a democratic association, the Alliance for Workers' Liberty. (Concluding an occasional series inspired by Dr Steve Jones' 1991 Reith Lectures on genetics)
n his final lecture, Steve Jones Looked at the history of human interference in human genes. Sometimes, this has had the aim of "improving" humanity in some way. Nowadays, it is more likely to be intended to benefit. individuals.
Jones points out that most common has been a crude attempt to favour the Y over the X gene. Thus in Inuit sociely a century ago, there were twice as many boys as girls. This was because girls were killed at birth or allowed to starve when food was scarce. Something similar is happening in modern China, where state pressure to have one child per couple conflicts with the desire to have a son. Undoubtedly, many girls are killed at birth.
But there are other reasons for favouring fetuses of one sex. Many genetic diseases are caused by faulty genes on the X chromosome. Some males have no compensating spare X. Those with one copy of the gene suffer the full effects (of haemophilia, Duchenne muscular dystrophy or whatever) while their female siblings are healthy. Few would blame parents of one affected child opting for abortion of further male fetuses.
Back in the 19th century, armed with the insights of the Darwinian theory of evolution, scientists and others claimed a spurious scientific justification of their chauvinistic prejudices. Jones refers wryly to the founder of his place of work, the Department of Genetics at University College, London as a particular culprit. This man, Francis Galton, Darwin's cousin, argued in his 1869 book "Hereditary Genius" that ability, even genius, was inborn and that families with a high concentration of "Genetic depends being between people as little related as geniuses tended to have fewer children. Hence, the quality of future generations would inevitably fall.
This led Galton to found the "science" of eugenics whose aim was "to check the birth-rate of the unfit and improve the race by furthering the productivity of the fit by early marriages of the best stock". This, incidentally, was largely the aim of the birth control pioneer Marie Stopes.
An early eugenic experiment was the foundation by the poisonous antisemite Elisabeth Nietszche of a colony on matings of "pure" Germans in Paraguay (on the suggestion of Wagner). Hitler himself wept at her funeral in 1935.
The colony, Neue Germania, still exists, featuring in a TV documentary recently. It sheltered several fugitive Nazis after 1945. Blond, blue-eyed and convinced of their superiority, the inhabitants are nevertheless poor, inbred and diseased. This is because genetic health depends on matings being between people as little related as possible.
Even the "land of the free" had its eugenics programme, with some 25,000 Americans sterilised to prevent their passing on feeble-mindedness or criminality! Recent US presidents are living testimony to the ineffectiveness of this movement.
The number of defective genes in circulation is astronomical. About 250 million people worldwide carry a gene for a serious blood disorder (thalassaemia or sickle-cell anaemia). In Britain, some 2 million carry a gene for cystic fibrosis. However, only about 1 in 2,500 babies are born with CF. This is because they need to receive a CF gene from both parents, who must therefore be carriers.
Genetic diseases can be very common in some areas. In Cyprus, so many have thalassaemia that proper treatment would consume half the health budget.
There are several responses to the problem of genetic diseases. One is to screen fetuses for defective genes.
Perhaps 100 genes will be capable of identification within a few years so. the problems associated with screening will have to be confronted soon. One problem is with the reliability of the tests. Few tests are 100% accurate and lives could be blighted by incorrect information.
Such information is capable of misuse too. Screening for sickle-cell anaemia genes in Americans of African origin often compounded the racism to which they were already subject. Carriers found themselves further discriminated against in jobs and insurance, though they had no extra health risks.
Nevertheless, many find knowledge of their genetic states valuable.
Screening of the new born will increase as treatments for genetic diseases are developed. Already, babies with phenylketonuria, which leads to severe mental retardation, can be treated by the simple expedient of eliminating the amino acid phenylalanine from the diet. Perhaps CF will soon be treated by "infecting" the sufferer with viruses carrying the healthy gene.
Jones is optimistic that the burden of genetic disease will decline naturally as human societies intermingle more. Many faulty genes spread because single copies conferred protection against diseases such as malaria. The victims with a double dose paid the price for this protection. With modern medicine and hygiene, the diseases are dying out but the genes remain.
If carriers tend to marry outside their home communities, offspring with genetic diseases will quickly become very tare indeed.
Scan page 15
Jrganiser No. 532 pag
----- pull-quotes -----
iberty, w B23, Lon SCIENCE COLUMI