Acting out fantasy
Socialist Organiser1992 1992-09-03Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 13 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 13
motion i also lens and workers were harassed for in th id un dis pa Belinda Weaver Belle de Jour uis Bunuel's Belle de Jour, made in 1967, and recently are-released, is the story of a wealthy, middle-class housewife who works afternoons in a Paris brothel.
Severine, who's called Belle de Jour in the brothel, has a handsome doctor husband, a smart flat and a maid, but she's miserable. She's like a child with her husband, and their sex life is nil. Severine rebuffs him, settling down alone at night in her narrow bed with relief.
BBC 2, 8.10 pm.
Wednesday, September The In-Americans -Partı2 of a three-part documentary on rhe Mccarthyntenwich huntin The LiSA.
The persecutipn anecter writers but also tens of Beneath her mask-like calm, Severine is constantly on the boil, however - anxious, restless, and tormented by sexual fantasies of degradation and punishment.
So strong do her desires become that she seeks out a brothel, and starts to work there by day. She finds there the release she needs to get on with her life.
If it were a man's story, it wouldn't be remarkable. Married men use prostitutes for sex all the time. But in making a 'nice', middle class woman like Severine take to whoring, and by casting icy, beautiful Catherine Deneuve in the role, Bunuel guaranteed his film shock value.
thousands of workers.
Trotskyist workers in car factories had to run out of the premises after work to avoid being beaten up by the employer's thugs.
Blacklisted for one joke, an electrician couldn't get work for 20 years. Other decades by the FBI. It doesn't seem so shocking today. Severine's surrender to her fantasies, her acting out of imaginary scenarios of humiliation and rape, seem - and are -a release to her. After a few sessions with her customers, criminals among them, she can finally cosy up to hubby, and the stage is set for a happy ending.
"Making a 'nice middle-class woman take to whoring, Bunuel guaranteed his film shock value".
It's not exploitative. Were it a Hollywood film, we'd see every detail of Severine's days in the brothel; we'd actually see her pawed and subjugated by men. But Bunuel keeps the door closed. When it opens, the camera focuses on Severine's well-being. She seems happy, released, not oppressed.
This may seem unsound to some, but fantasies generally are unsound. Rape fantasies are top of the charts for many women, which doesn't mean those women want to be raped. There is a huge and fact.
Severine goes further than fantasy, but it helps her. It liberates her. Far from being degraded, she ends up fulfilled, able to climb out of the trap her fantasies had built around her. Whatever she's up to, she is doing it on her own terms.
Of course, her wanting to be degraded is a sign of her oppression; she finds it incomprehensible - and repellent - when a male client at the brothel seeks humiliation and domination. But Bunuel isn't interested in why Severine turned out that way; he just wants to show it.
And to shock. Shocking the bourgeoisie was always one of Bunuel's favourite games; it's the theme of many of his movies. Belle de Jour is about all the smutty thoughts behind the respectable faces of the bourgeoisie. It's about the corruption lurking behind beauty and glamour and righteousness.
Severine doesn't just work in a brothel. As a child, she turned her nose up at Communion too. She's a secret rebel, masquerading as a frosty, middle class saint. Shocking the Church was also one of Bunuel's games. In Belle de Jour, he got to do both. of both the leaders of the slave revolt and the rich and powerful of Rome. He captures the horror of slavery so that you understand the slaves' passion for freedom.
The slave army holds its property in common. They fight to end all oppresion. This communist army inflicted many great defeats on the mighty Roman army. This hotch potch of ex-slaves ranging from cooks to gladiators won because of their training and leadership — but most of all they won because they fought as a class for a better world.
It took three years to defeat the rising. The Roman ruling class, terrified by the revolt, had to destroy the memory of the revolt. They poured out vitriolic propaganda, they crucified over 6,000 captured slaves in a double line running many miles along the Rome-Capua road. There remains no full history of Spartacus for, unlike Rome's imperial wars, this class war was too dangerous to remember. The victors write history.
The tragedy of the Spartacus revolt was that it could not win its utopian aims. Spartacus wants to destroy Rome and return to the Golden Age of Greek myth. But itis not possible to turn the tide of history back to primitive communism.
History is class struggle, the exploited continually fight exploitation but, until the industrial revolution, the resources did not allow for the possibility of material equality.
Where Spartacus could not turn history back, we face a world rotten ripe for socialism. For the first time in history the revolution of the exploited, the modern wage slaves of capitalism, can force history forward to a real golden age of equality based on abundance and liberation.
The exploited have a rich hidden history of struggle. Socialists should never forget the magnificent Spartacus revolt. The novel is out print. Get it from your library.
Scan page 14
Organiser