Why 30 million are jobless - and how new jobs can be created The roots of depression SUPPORT US!
Socialist Organiser1992 1992-09-03Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 12 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 12
For a generation Keynesianism was triumphant, managing to support a half-decent welfare state. Ultimately, though, it failed. Healthworkers at Charing Cross hospital on strike this year. Photo: John Harris In the second of articles Peter Kenway argues that the key to solving the present cri is the social control of investment.
That has led to thirty million people being unem ployed across the advanced capitalist countries? Capitalism - and, in particular, the way in which capitalism has operated since the second world war.
In this article and the next 1 am going to suggest what can be done about it: social control over investment and higher public spending on infrastructure, education, social services and benefits. This should be financed through higher taxation, especially (although not only) on high incomes and incomes from profits. In one sense, these are no more than the common currency of almost any socialist, or even social-democrat who is not wholly seduced by the supposed superiority of 'the My purpose here is not therefore to say something new about what should be done, but rather to explain why these are the things which need to be done; to try to show that these are logical responses to the manifest shortcomings of the world we find ourselves in; to try to show why socialism, far from being dead, is instead vital for the future.
This is not a slump - yet Some have called the present economic situation a slump, but I would not do so, for two reasons.
A slump — a sudden, steep and profound collapse in the level of economic activity, by say 20 percent or more - is certainly a possibility. The most likely cause of it would be a collapse in international trade such as happened in the 1930s.
I think we should save the word *slump' to describe what would happen then, not least because "the remedies being offered by nationalists within both major parties are the very things which could turn what we have today into a slump."
We have now suffered nearly twenty years of slow growth and high and rising unemployment in Britain, as elsewhere. During that time we have witnessed three recessions: 1974/5, 1980/1 and 1990 till now. The present recession is now the longest of those three, and although neither 1991 nor 1992 will have been as bad as 1980 when output fell by 4 per cent, the length of today's recession means that it will turn out to have the worst of them all. It is, I think, quite properly called a "depression"
The real point about all this talk of percentages and names is to emphasise that today's crisis is not just a recent thing. It cannot all be blamed on wrong policies pursued today (as Labour critics of the government suggest); nor on Chancellor Lawson's "boom' of 1987-8 (what Tory critics of the government say; nor even on the last thirteen years of Tory waste and mis-management (Labour critics again).
Instead, the roots can be traced all the way back to the manner in which capitalism has been run in countries such as Britain and the US since the second world war. The ultimate fault is the failure of Keynesianism. The success of Keynesianism Keynesianism — named after John Maynard Keynes, a scion of the British establishment who was born in the year Marx died and who died at the end of the Second World War - was a doctrine for the management of the economy by the bourgeois state. There was absolutely no suggestion that any of the fundamental institutions of society should be altered, but the state, and states working together, were instead to act to overcome the inherent shortcomings of capitalism, shortcomings which had been revealed in the starkest possible terms in the slump of the 1930s.
The basic idea of Keynesianism as it became capitalist conventional wisdom after 1945, was that the government should act to maintain a certain level of effective demand (expenditure) in the economy. When it appeared that the economy was slowing down, the government was supposed to boost demand. Contrariwise, the government was supposed to damp down demand when the economy appeared to be growing too strongly.
within both major parties are the very things which could turn what we have today into a slump".
For nearly thirty years Keynesianism appeared to be spectacularly successful, not only in smoothing out the natural cycle of capitalism but also in maintaining a satisfactory, if not spectacular, rate of growth.
In those years, unemployment was on average less than half a million, and the rise in unemployment experienced as boom turned to recession was a mere three hundred thousand. At the time, such a rise was held to be something shocking, not just by Labour but by Conservatives too.
For a generation, Keynesianism was triumphant, combining what was best about capitalism (innovation, growth, rising standards of living sufficient to support a half decent welfare state) while eliminating its worst features.
But since we are, as it were, once more on the brink of the 1930s, it is evident that the triumphant tone of the Keynesians was premature.
How the government controls demand The failure of Keynesianism has both economic and political dimensions. The economic failure goes back to the difficulties faced in accomplishing its basic task, namely that of controlling the overall level of expenditure.
Economists divide the nation's total expenditure into a small number of categories: public expenditure (that is, money spent directly by central and local government), personal consumption (that is, spending by individuals on everything from milk to cars), investment (expenditure on machinery, buildings, equipment, that is, means of production) and exports (purchases made abroad of goods and services supplied from the UK).
Some categories can be influenced by the government much more easily than others. This is obviously true of public expenditure, which the government can control directly (although it always has trouble with local authorities spending too much or too little), but it is also true of consumption by individuals, the level of which can be directly and quickly altered by raising or lowering taxes.
Investment and exports on the other hand are not directly under government control. But investment is the most important category of all! Investment must continue at a steady and sufficient rate if the economy is to remain capable of producing a sufficient quantity of goods and services at a price which makes them attractive and of a quality which is good enough to rank with similar goods available from producers abroad. This is not all that it takes for a country to remain 'competitive' on world markets, but it is an crucial part of it.
Without adequate investment the quality of the product suffers: the up-to-date competitor can produce something better and often cheaper. Firms which do not invest find that in due course they are unable to sell all that they produce and they are obliged to cut back.
Investment, then, is the key, but in a mixed economy, in which the means of production and decisions over them remain in private hands, the government cannot control either the amount or type of investment directly. Indirect control, Keynesians thought, came through the direct control of public expenditure and private consumption.
social control of investment does not automatically mean socialism, but the nee for it puts socialism back on the agenda".
The best inducement to persuade firms to invest was the prospect of a strong and steadily rising market for the goods which would be produced with that new investment. The way to stimulate investment was to stimulate consumption.
This worked, but only at a cost, because to provoke consumption first meant that society consumed more before it produced more. The rise in consumption unmatched by production simply sucked in imports (goods and services produced overseas and the need to finance that burgeoning deficit in foreign trade (imports exceeding exports) obliged the government to raise the rate of interest (to get foreigners to lend British capitalists money). This choked off consumption, and the new investment brought little benefit since the extra demand which firms had anticipated simply failed to materialise.
What really mattered was steady investment over a long period of time in order to ensure a gradual expansion of the means of production. Marx's word for this process -"accumulation', suggestive of the careful acquisitiveness of the squirrel garnering stocks for the winter - is so appropriate here.
What we are suffering from today is the consequence of some two decades of accumulation which has been both insufficient and intermittent. The stock of up-to-date machines, factories and so on, is insufficient. Jobs when they come, as in the boom which occured between 1986 and 1989, are for the most part private sector service jobs, whether in fast food outlets, domestic service, estate agencies or the City of London, the call for which can (and did) vanish as rapidly as it appears.
Social control investment The deep and prolonged recession which we are now suffering is a result of the necessary belt-tightening following the burst of gluttony in the late 1980s. The tightening is made far worse by the recessions in Germany and the US and the financial contraction in Japan. But its severity is home-grown.
The root of the problem and therefore, in my view, the root cause of the eventual failure of Keynesianism, les precisely in the lact that the means of production and investment decisions are for the most part in private hands. A sustainable recovery from not only this depression, but also the two decades of slow growth, requires sustained accumulation.
The 'arms length" relationship between the state and firms which is to be found in the UK and US (Canada and Australia too) has failed to work: much more direct social control over the means of production and its accumulation is essential.
"Social control by no means necessarily means socialism. It is no coincidence that the countries which have continued to thrive economically in the last two decades have been the former West Germany and Japan. In both of these, investment decisions are far more subject to social control (of a non-socialist sort).
In Germany, banks play a central role within the industrial structure, making long-term finance available for long-term benefit. In Japan, the dense interweaving of many big corporations, including with banks, means that there too, decision making is essentially socialised, albeit by and for the bourgeoisie.
The key to a sustained recovery is to be found in a sustained spell of accumulation, and the key to that is the social control of investment. That is the lesson to be drawn from the failure of Keynesianism. The social control of investment does not automatically mean socialism, but the need for it puts socialism back on the agenda.
Scan page 13
Organiser
----- pull-quotes -----
"The remedies being offered by nationalist