John Heartfield: revolutionary artist & The camera tells
Socialist Organiser1992 1992-09-03Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 10
"War and Corpses - the last hope for the rich". From AIZ, 1932 Alan Johnson reviews the exhibition of the work of John Heartfield, currently at the Barbican Art Gallery, London (until 18 October).
During the First World War a Berlin painter, Helmut Herzteld, anglicised his name to John Heartfield.
He was in revolt against a Germany where friends would greet each other with, "God Punish England". Heartfield went on to develop a new art based upon the manipulation of form and content t: make a political point - photomontage.
This exhibition, on the centenary of his birth, is accompanied by a collection of contemporary British political cartoons, animation, puppetry and caricature, featuring Steve Bell, Jacky Fleming, Ralph Steadman, Spitting Image, and the excellent photomontages of Peter Kennard.
Initially photomontage was seen by Heartfield and his friends in the Berlin "Dada" movement as a gesture against the art establishment.
Dada lasted from about 1916 to the early twenties. Repelled by the collapse of European society into the carnage of the first world war, Dadaists expressed total rejection of the capitalist society which had, produced the war and the safe, institutionalised art of capitalist "high culture"
They sought not lofty elevation from, or a passive depiction of, society but an anarchic, wild and explosive presence which might ignite revolt.
Dada became more explicitly political in the starving and revolutionary Germany of the post war years. Heartfield was a founder member of the Communist Party. "Dada stands on the side of the revolutionary proletariat", read the poster at the one and only "Dada Fair" in Berlin in 1920. -The current exhibition reconstructs the room in which Heartfield and Grosz exhibited at the Fair and it alone is worth the admission price. A Prussian military figure hangs from the ceiling with the head of a pig. Otto Dix's disturbing painting "45% employable" depicts demobbed and crippled "Where this sower goes through the land, he reaps hunger, war and fire". From AIZ, March 1937 LUND ICHE N workers. The titles of the works give the flavour: "It's Time You Opened Your Mind.
Clear It For The Claims Of Our Times".
"Cut With the Kitchen Knife Dada Through the Last Weimar Beer Belly". "Dada is the Wilful Subversion of the Bourgeois World of Concepts".
In the 1920s and 1930s Heartfield introduced photomontage into the Communist Party's press and publicity. It became more than an anti-art joke. The CP critic Louis Aragon wrote of this transformation: "As he was playing with the fire of appearances, reality took fire around him.. John Heartfield was no longer playing. The scraps of paper that he formerly manoeuvred for the pleasure of stupefaction, under his fingers began to signify".
Week after week he produced razor-sharp anti-Nazi images for the Communist magazine Arbeiter Illustrierte Zeitung (Workers' Illustrated Paper or AIZ). The AIZ reflected a movement of worker-photographers two and a half thousand strong by 1930, and based on the idea that "you need the eye of a certain class" to use the new cameras and lenses and printing techniques for social depiction.
One of Heartfield's photomontages shows Hitler giving the Nazi salute and in the same motion accepting a wad of bills from a giant, anonymous and suited figure with the caption "Millions Stand Behind Us". The montage, referring to a claim Hitler had made days before about the Nazis' popular support, presents the viewer with "a critical narrative presented visually". A new perspective has been created, a vantage point from which the view can feel emboldened and the enemy diminished.
After Hitler's victory in 1933 Heartfield fled to Prague, then in 1938 to London. The victory of the Nazis was the result of the criminal policy of Moscow which depicted the Socialists as "social Fascists" and blocked the Communist-Socialist alliance which could have defeated Hitler. Heartfield had followed this policy, and produced photomontages, for example, depicting the SPD as tigers.
In England he did work for Picture Post, but found nothing in the B ritish labour interned briefly in 1940. movement to compare to AIZ. He was even He returned to East Berlin in 1950. Initially he was out of favour - in the years of FEN UN G R R EICHE "Socialist Realism", photomontage was defined as "bourgeois" - but later he became an "official" artist of the Stalinist dictatorship, until his death in 1968.
According to a friend (writing in the Guardian, 24 August), in private Heartfield made "frequent and loud" criticisms of the Stalinist regime. In public he made none.
He remained silent during the Berlin Rising of 1953 and the Hungarian Revolution of 1956. He seemed happiest working on stage sets with Berthold Brecht but he would turn in the propaganda when the regime requested it.
The fearsome clarity of his earlier work was replaced by tired images of Western imperialism or Soviet achievement.
The video which accompanies the exhibition is a disgrace. "Going home to the Germany he had worked for", his work is portrayed as having a "continuity" and we are asked to mourn the fall of the Berlin Wall and to view sympathetically a work Heartfield produced in 1959 portraying an East German frog leaping over a barrier only to be eaten by "a capitalist snake" , as showing his "prophetic awareness"
The fact that a tyrannical state shot any "frog" which tried to jump is ignored. The earlier work depicts the truth and exposes tyranny. The later work is in the service of a tyranny, and is itself ideology, masking the truth.
This assumption of a continuity in Heartfield's work, from the revolutionary work of the 1920s to the Stalinist pieces of the 1950s, is only another version of "Marx led to Lenin led to Stalin", of course. The exhibition guide tells us that, "His
Scan page 11
artist-revolutionary a different truth you may resume normal activities TO FIND OUT MORE ON WHY THE OL'S VIEW ON CIVIL DEFENCE DIFFERS FROM THE GOVERNMENT'S, WRITE TO:Peter Kennard's anti-nuclear poster produced for the GLC in 1985. The Barbican itics now appear historically specific (19171991), linked to the utopian promise of the Russian Revolution. Yet the way he expressed his politics - the fearless embrace of montage based machine art, and his explorations of dangerous outlets that lacked the safety of the gallery or museum - still present a challenge".
This view seeks to gut the politics from Heartfield's art, leaving only the forms by which that art was carried. But form and content cannot be so easily separated here, and the political grounding of his art cannot be pushed aside. the sneer of the cynical individual, and not the confident, puncturing wit and anger of the agent of revolutionary change.
The political context in which Heartfield worked - the wave of hope created by the October Revolution - has long disappeared. Today, the backwash from the collapse of Stalinism has pushed perspectives of radical social change to the margins.
So Peter Kennard's work is often stranded in the Guardian, accompanying clearly unsympathetic articles. Even when his work is publicising a campaign, the targets of his work can seem so stupid, but so monumentally powerful, that today's audience is likely to retreat to the "sanity" of their private "On hearing the all-clear.
Socialist Organiser No. 532 page 24, 'Protect & Survive: The Home Offic
----- pull-quotes -----
"Dadaists expressed total rejection of the capitalist society which had produced the war and the safe, institutionalised capitalist high culture'."