Revolt of the underclass?
Socialist Organiser1992 1992-09-03Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 8
Marx urged unity of workers and the unemployed Martin Thomas argues that "underclass" revol shows us that capitalisi is decaying - and that the labour movement is failing its duty.
he word "underclass". , much used in comment on recent upheavals in American and British cities, was coined by rightwing American writers.
For them, the "underclass" are people who are too restless, undisciplined, disaffected, ill-educated or dissolute to hold down regular jobs. They feel no stake in, and no responsibility towards, society; they have unstable families, and bring up children to be "underclass" ", too.
These traits and attitudes, so the right-wingers say, determine the economic situation of the "underclass" . If "underclass" people really wanted to make a living in the regular free-enterprise economy, then they could, but they give up and depend on state welfare, begging, or crime.
The answer is to combat "underclass" traits and attitudes, and force the "underclass" into regular economic activity, by cuts in state welfare payments and drastic repression of begging and crime.
This right-wing view is elitist -and racist, too, identifying the "underclass" as it does with black people. It is an upside-down view, offering no explanation of why the US, with more meagre welfare and heavier policing than Western Europe, has a much bigger "underclass"
Nevertheless, the right-wing view is an upside-down view of something in reality. Capitalism does create a class "below" the working class, a class of people who not only are jobless, but have lost hope of a regular job.
Some people on the left -Socialist Worker, for example -make it a point of honour to deny that aaything exists which could be called an "underclass". Yet the reality is there.
his class used to be called the "lumpenproletariat". It is not new. In fact, it is older than the working class. When, in the 16th century and after, vast numbers of people were deprived of their livelihoods by the landlords land-grabbing and by the break-up of the feudal lords' armies of dependents, most of them could not find jobs in the few emerging capitalist industrial workplaces. "They were turned en masse" wrote Marx, "into beggars, robbers, vagabonds, partly from inclination, in most cases from stress of circumstances" . The governments had the same attitude as the present-day American right wing, passing "bloody legislation against vagabondage... Legislation treated them as 'voluntary' criminals, and assumed that it depended on their own good will to go on working under the old conditions that no longer existed".
A class of people who have to resort to begging or crime is also constantly created and recreated by the most advanced industrial capitalism. -Capital needs a "reserve army of labour" ", a pool of unemployed workers to draw on. It maintains that pool by constant pressure to cut jobs - through new technology in times of boom, through work speed-up imposed by fear in times of slump.
"The working class, in Marxist theory, is a revolutionary class not only because it suffers poverty and alienation. It is a revolutionary class because its place in the capitalist collectively in an everyday class struggle".
Most unemployed workers do not become part of the "lumpenproletariat" or "underclass" . They remain workers, seeking jobs, often being supported by the wages of other members of their families. They are drawn into jobs and pushed out of them as the capitalist business cycle drains and then refills the pool of unemployed.
But the pool is never drained completely. The capitalist cycle leaves a minority behind who can never get jobs, or who give up: that minority has no choice but to collapse into helpless poverty, or turn instead to begging or petty crime of various sorts. Boredom, frustration and nothing The minority may be made small, in many West European states until recently, where there were relatively good welfare provisions and chances for retraining and education; or it may be larger, as in the more untrammelled capitalist society of the US; but capitalism always produces it.
t is generally worse off than the working class, and that fact has made various socialists and revolutionaries look to the "lumpenproletariat" as a more radical and subversive class than the relatively stolid and staid working class. Thus the 19th century anarchist Mikhail Bakunin looked especially to the sections of the "lumpenproletariat" who had been recruited from the middle class by economic ruin.
"There exists in Italy what is lacking in other countries: a youth which is ardent, energetic, completely displaced, without a career, without a way out..."
In the 1960s the academic Marxist Herbert Marcuse wrote: "Underneath the conservative popular base [i.e. the working class] is the substratum of the outcasts and outsiders... the unemployed and unemployable... their opposition is revolutionary even if their consciousness is not"
And indeed, that "substratum" is usually more ready to rebel spectacularly, to riot and to loot, than the working class. Many European cities in the 18th and 19th centuries saw frequent upheavals of that sort. The Bank of England, in the centre of the City of London, look forward to fuel youth revolt on Brit is surrounded by blank, prison-like tur walls because when it was rebuilt, Th in 1792-1827, anything less would theo have led to the "underclass" ranonly sacking the building site and then suft smashing all the windows when is a the construction was complete.
plac Yet Marx and Engels, in the syst "Communist Manifesto" , argued driv that while the "substratum" "may, an t here and there, be swept into the movement by a proletarian [work- labo ing-class] revolution; its conditions coll of life, however, prepare it far more for the part of a bribed tool of reactionary intrigue" gle.
and That does not mean that socialists er cl It is side with the class capitalist it pr the Establishmem shar against it". conc vidul orga In fact fascist and right-wing attra nationalist movements have often mer found an important base in the "qui unemployed, organising them Th alongside the middle class as a desc force against the working class. Rioting may be a protest against by th intolerable conditions, but it does not necessarily help win better the conditions: it is almost always purely negative, and may even be whit
Scan page 9
Anti-semitic academic speaks in Laude
----- pull-quotes -----
economic system drives it to organ
"To hope that the 'underclass' will lead a revolution is false.