Alas, po Norman
Socialist Organiser1992 1992-09-03Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 4
TUC Deputy General Secretary John Monks will be busy tying up any remaining loose ends that might impede his smooth In the unlikely event of Willis refusing to go quietly, he will Resolutions to this year's Congress from the TGWU and the engineering section of the AEU call on the TUC to "refocus" and "radically reassess" its future role. They do not, of course, mention Willis by name. But the implication is clear: the big guns of the movement want big changes at Congress House and Our Norman is definitely not the man to carry them out.
If proof of a plot were needed, it is the noticeable failure of any leading trade union figure to jump in to damp down the anti-Willis speculation. The nearest thing to support that Willis has received in recent weeks was Bill Morris's statemen "We have to work with the leadership we have got" - someWith the leaders of the TGWU on the "left", the AEU/EEPTU on the "right" and the GMB in the "centre" all busy whispering against him, Willis stands as much chance of survival as a crate of Newcastle Brown at the end of Congress You can't help feeling just a bit sorry for Our Norman: he took over from the broken and demoralised Len Murray in 1984, by which time the leaders of the main unions had already hauled up the white flag in the face of the Tories' anti-union legislation. The GCHQ unions had just been de-recognised without a serious response from the rest of the movement and unemployment was touching 3 million. The miners' strike offered an opportunity to tun the tide, but it was clear that the leaders of the TUC's main constituents had no intention of organising the solidarity action demanded by the 1984 TUC Congress. Willis, whose instinct and training inclined him to fudge rather than lead, attempted to negotiate between the miners and the Thatcher government without avail and without thanks from either side. He played precisely the same role during the 1986-7 Wapping dispute, with the same disastrous results. His desperate efforts to keep the EETPU within the TUC fold were equally unsuccessful, culminating in the 1988 expulsion of the electricians, not for their scabbing at Wapping but over relatively trivial breaches of the Bridlington Agreement elsewhere. No one — on the left, right, or centre — had a good word for poor old Norman. But could he really have been expected to do any better given the unwillingness of the main union leaderships to co-ordinate any serious opposition to the Tories? We can quibble about this or that particular detail, but essentially the die had been set by the likes of Jordan, Todd and Edmonds. Willis could The truth is that while the left had many understandable grievances against Willis, it was the hard right of the movement that was most dissatisfied with him. The Jordan/Hammond axis wanted (and still want) a full-scale commitment to out-and-out business unionism from the TUC. Norman Willis (who still on occasions sings "The Internationale" at social functions) could not and would not deliver this. But he had no alternative beyond fairly incompetent fudging, mudging and backroom compromise. He satisfier no-one and has now been made the scapegoat for the continuing decline of the British trade union movement. Willis was hoping that, if Labour won the last election, his old friend Neil Kinnock would offer him the chair of the conciliation service, ACAS. Like so much else in his career, it was Norman Willis was an ineffectual, gutless, bureaucratic buffoon. But if you think he was bad, just wait for John Monks...
he word is that Norman Wits has trailly decided to call it a day. At next SNOWIN week's TUC he will announce his intention of standing down From page 3 and take the credit for setting up a "root and branch" review of the future functioning and Turkish, the Austrostructure of the TUC. The Hungarian, the Tsarist union leaders who have been Russian, the Nazi, the orchestrating the whispering Stalinist Russian... campaign against him will There are four main relilook very solemn and make speeches saying what a fine fel- By Sleeper gious groups, 22 ethnic low he is, what a great loss it groups, and even two alphawill be, etc etc. Meanwhile, bets. The different nationalities crisscross and intermingle in many areas. succession to the top job. Peace is achievable only through consistent democrabe bundled out shortly after Congress. cy, guaranteeing the rights of every community and every minority. The only other way peace could be achieved is by a massively strong state holdStalinist state held down all the nationalities of the former USSR. But, as the ex-USSR itself shows, that what less than a fulsome endorsement. would only "freeze" the conflicts temporarily, and would involve terrible damage in the meantime. social. And would an intervention by the big powers establish consistent democracy? It would not. The Financial Times (27 August) reports that the London conference ran into difficulty when it discussed a declaration about the rights of minorities in ex-Yugoslavia because "France, Spain, Russia and Turkey, among others, are increasingly concerned that if a blueprint for ethnic minorities of the former Yugoslavia is agreed... those principles could eventually be applied to other countries". They are content that Eastern Europe's "minority problems" should be settled - if only peace and stability are restored - as they were settled long ago in their own states: by the domination of only work with the material available to him.
the most powerful groups, in the "Yugoslav" case Serbia.
Thus they let Serbia keep what it has murderously grabbed, and 'cleansed'.
A big-power intervention would be concerned not about democracy but about re-establishing trade and investment at minimum cost.
It would ride roughshod over any minority demand that seemed too costly to grant or not to be. weak enough to be suppressed.
The record of the big powers so far confirms that.
When the aggressively Serbdominated government in Belgrade took dictatorial direct rule over the previously autonomous regions of Kosovo and Vojvodina, the Western governments were silent.
When Serb imperialism began to break up the mixedcommunity republic of ilya Lau Bosnia, the EC suggested that Bosnia be divided into Serb, Muslim, and Croat "cantons" (like Switzerland!)
That only encouraged the Norman to give up not biting yer legs chauvinists on all sides to grab and "ethnically cleanse" as much territory they could.
Now, as Kosovo — which is about 90% Albanian - moves towards war, Tory foreign secretary Douglas Hurd denies its right to self-determination, and insists it must remain under the Serbian authorities who are currently imposing police-state terror there, and may tomorrow decide to "cleanse" the territory of most of its present population.
At each stage the blunderings and the cynical interventions by Western governments have probably made things worse. If they did intervene massively they might save some lives in the short term, but in the notvery-long term they would probably make things worse again.
In any case, we can't trust them. We can't make calling on these cynical, self-serving governments our answer.
Others on the left denounce big-power military intervention as an imperialist ploy to establish a sort of colony. Are they right?
No, they are not right! Which state do they think wants a colony? Why would the other states agree to help it? Why would they want to bear all the heavy costs of colonial administration when they can make just as much profit by free trade?
This line implies support for the Serb chauvinists as representing "national liberation" or "anti-imperialism" against any big-power intervention - in other words, support for Serb imperialism in the name of anti-imperialism!
What about Western military protection for aid convoys, and sanctions against Serbia. Shouldn't we denounce them as imperialist?
No. We have no confidence in the big powers. But it is utterly false and irresponsible to go from insisting on this to the view that letting the conflict rip in ex-Yugoslavia is preferable to any outside -"imperialist" - intervention.
Aid is better than starvation. Aid convoys made safe by military protection are better than aid convoys destroyed. Socialists cannot positively support or call for sanctions, because we cannot place any trust in the big capitalist governments, and because we do not favour punishing the whole Serb people for the crimes of their leaders.
But if sanctions, diplomacy, and big-power pressure can help end the war - and they might, though we cannot and should not rely on it - then mindless shouting about "imperialism" does no-one any good. There are no answers in the So is Socialist Worker right? It writes (15 August) that: "The solution to the horror of Bosnia-Herzegovina will only come when ordinary people on both sides see through the lies of their rulers..."
Yes, up to a point. The socialist answer is for the working class in the various conflicting peoples to come together, settle accounts with their own chauvinists tinpot imperialists, restore a federation, this time with consistent and thor ough democracy and under • the control of the workers.
But SW's position is falsified and turned into something akin to the idiot "anti-imperialist" line by its pretence that the socialist solution, through action from below, is immediately, or almost immediately, available.
"This is not an impossible dream, despite the bloodshed and misery... In the late 1980s Yugoslav workers, of all ethnic groups, took part in massive strikes... Just last year Serbia's leader Milosevic was reeling under the weight of anti-government demonstrations..."
Working-class unity is indeed not an impossible dream. But it is not quite as easy as SW pretends! If workers strike, it does not automatically give them an internationalist outlook. The anti-Milosevic movement in Serbia is big - but it is hardly less chauvinist than Milosevic himself.
Then what can we do? What can the labo ur loveshort-term in "Yugoslavia"
ment do practically?
We can help refugees and argue for their rights. We can support sending aid. We can argue for the principles of consistent democracy as the only solution to the horrors. We can give aid to peace movements and independent workers' movements.
All that is limited. But it is real. It is foolish and disorienting for the left to imagine that we can be "inspectorsgeneral of history". We can, if we do our work right, put forward a coherent and scientific programme for action by the working class. We can not undertake to provide quick-fix solutions for all the horrors and atrocities generated by the capitalist powers-that-be while they remain the powers-that-be.
But the big capitalist governments are the only forces powerful enough to bring any sort of short-term solution. Surely we must either rely on them or condemn ourselves to irrelevance?
No: such "realism" would convert us from socialist advocates into advisers for bourgeois governments, in the illusory hope of being more practical and effective (illusory, because the governments won't listen to our advice). It would sacrifice the long-term work which we can and must do, for naive hopes of short-term advantage.
It is as destructive as the idiotic rhetorical anti-imperialism" which would turn us into mindless sloganshouters.
----- pull-quotes -----
ing down all the nationalities equally, in the way that the