Work of folly
Socialist Organiser1992 1992-08-13Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 13 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 13
Joseph Stan Crooke reviews Stan Crooke reviews "Legion oley's "Legion of the Rearguard (state is a very uneven book.
- the IRA and the modern Irish The first twenty years of the IRA's existence are dealt with in 200 pages. The last fifty are skipped through in just 15. I don't know whether Conor Foley got bored writing the book. But I certainly got bored reading it. More substantial histories Coogan's and Bowyer Bell's - have long been available; and entire books written on episodes Foley rushes through in a single chapter. The lack of originality of Foley's book is confirmed by a perusal of the footnote references: most of them refer to secondary literature, rather than to original and previously unused source material.
Nor does the book live up to its claim to be an account of the IRA's "internal ideological dynamic". It is a poor potted history of Southern Ireland and of Southern Irish political parties, mixed up with the standard IRA hagiography.
As history, the book is lightweight and superficial. But that does not save the author from trapping himself in some typically Foleyesque contradictions.
Foley calls his book a riposte to the "effete assault" of the revisionist school of Irish history. Meantime, he endorses arguments advanced by the self-same revisionist school.
He rejects, for example, the idea that Southern Ireland is a "neo-colony of Britain" and, even more heretically, suggests that "the main obstacle to (British) disengagement would be Unionist opposition".
Foley defines republicanism as standing not just for Irish unity but also for "a different political and social order" and describes the IRA as "republicanism's most uncompromising defenders".
But in his brief treatment of the IRA in the 1950s, he sums up the IRA's politics as idealistic, socially conservative, and devoutly Catholic". What happened to the "different political and social order" which the IRA supposedly stood for?
The author regards the IRA of roday as continuing the tradition of Wolfe Tone. But Tone stood for the unity of "Catholic, Protestant and Dissenter". The fact that today's IRA does not is simply ignored by Foley.
Other arguments often only half spelt-out and never argued for with any intellectual rigour - which Foley puts forward are, at best, pretty dubious.
Is it really true, for example, that Sinn Fein in Southern Ireland is *competing for the left-wing vote with both Labour and the Workers' Party"? Or is it rather the case that Sinn Fein is competing with Fianna Fail for the traditional republican rote?
Ind. however accommodating James Connolly may have been towards Irish nationalism, it is surely going too far to claim that he argued *socialism in the Irish context could be described as a form of advanced nationalism".
Running true to form. Foley attempts to face two ways at the same time in his book.
On the one hand, are glimpses of reality, such as the politically independent nature of Southern Ireland. or the problem of communal divisions in Northern Ireland as an obstacle to Irish unity. On the other. pro-Republican cheerleading, the suggestion that socialism is a form of nationalism, and the dewy-eyed portrayal of an Ireland still haunted by the ghosts of the soldiers of the Legion of the Rearguard".
All in all, this is not so much a book of Foley as a work of folly.
----- pull-quotes -----
of the Rearguard" by of the Rearquard" by Conor Foley (Pluto Press).