Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

The death of a dream

Socialist Organiser no. 531, 13 August 1992 · scan p. 13 · about 561 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 13 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 13

making-good sagas, but its darker but disappointment awaits. Far and Away far and Away" is not exactsounds like are of era te sounds like one of those American Dream, Irish-immigrantand bleaker than that. Even the umphal ending feels ambivalent. Set in the 1870s, it's the story of Joseph, an Irish peasant, who flees to America with Shannon, the daughter of the landlord who has bled his family white. Joseph is slow and uneducated, and unwilling at first to leave his homeland. It's Shannon who has the spark and the fire. America is not the Promised Land; it's hell, a place where immigrants are first fleeced, then exploited, and, finally, left to starve.

"Disappointment awaits. America i not the Promised fleeced, then exploited, and, finally, left to starve.

Fresh off the boat, Joseph amd Shannon fall into the hands of a crafty Boston-Irish ward boss, who houses them in a brothel, gets them work plucking chickens, then prods Joseph into bare-knuckle fighting. While he's winning, life is good; when he loses, out they go, on to the streets, destitute.

Shannon's dream is to grab some land in the Oklahoma land race, and she infects Joseph, the landless peasant, with the same wish. Quite why a wealthy landlord's daughter would want to swap luxury in Ireland for a life of sweat and toil in America is never explained. Shannon wants to be modern. that's all.

They get their land, but at what a price! The trials they have suflered hardly make it worth it. Of course. we've seen Joseph go all mistyeyed about the wor ders of land the way Scarlett's Iris a father did in "Gone with the wind", but that was a huge plantation with slaves, to boot, not some puny small-holding. It doesn't add up.

Tom Cruise isn't bad as Joseph. He shows us the ferocious urge to rise from his class that is at the heart of all these mythmaking American sagas. Shannon is less Joseph, The movie wobbles a bit from farce to tragedy, from realism to romance, with quite a few stops in between. The fight scenes are horrific. The camera swoops and weaves until you feel vertiginous and punch drunk and menaced, the way the fighters must have felt as their faces and bodies were smashed to pulp.

The movie strives for authenticity by showing how really rough it was for immigrants, but that undercuts the romantic stuff about making good, fresh starts, and all the rest. It turns the American Dream inside out.

In the land race scenes, we see family after family drop out through accident or injury. We see stony-faced American Indians watch the Palefaces grab their land. We hear cynical voices saying only one in ten will get anything; the others are dopes, dupes.

In the face of that, the Dream dies. It's simply too late to make inspirational, courage-of-immigrants sagas. It's too late for the myths of the West now we know they are myths. When we see America now, when we see how many are excluded from any kind of dream, we can't cheer on Mr. Everyman, even in a historical film. We know he isn't Everyman, he's one of the chosen few.

----- pull-quotes -----

Land; it's hell, a place where immigrants are

clear. She's feisty, but we can't see into her, the way we can see into

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 531

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →