Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Russia: threat from the "anti-capitalist" Right

Socialist Organiser no. 531, 13 August 1992 · scan pp. 12–13 · about 1,620 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 12 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 12

Demonstration of anti-Yeltsin "anti-capitalist" reaction in Moscow, February 1992 Stan Crooke surveys the growth of extreme nationalism in Russia According to Sterligov, one of the leaders of the growing "national-patriot" movement in Russia, Mikhail Gorbachev betrayed Russia, and the entire USSR, at the behest of the American government: "The CIA said: It must be so'; the Soviet Union (under Gorbachev) replied: "It will be so"* Sterligov's allegations are supported by Pravda, which recently claimed that resolutions adopted by the 28th congress of the Soviet Communist Party were based upon recommendations from American politicians.

The Organisation of Communists of the Republic of Tatarstan - one of the many local Stalinist parties still in existence after the official banning of the Soviet Communist Party - has likewise blamed the collapse of Russia on "reactionary forces in the West, and their agents Gorbachev and Yeltsin"

In the national-patriotic paper, Dyen, Shurygin lists some of the betrayals of Shaposhnikov, head of the Russian armed forces and a hate-ligure for the nationalpatriots. In the aftermath of last year's attempted putsch, he sacked dozens of officers who "unlike himself, honourably carried out their orders during the days of the Committee of the State of Emergency"; and he has "surrendered without a fight millions of people and tens of thousands of kilometres of land".

The Russian minority populations in the ex-USSR republics have been left "one after another to face animal-like nationalists of all varieties. Our people are abandoned as hostages, they are surrendered to occupying forces"

The national-patriots try to build on resentment against Boris Yeltsin and his government - otherwise known as "the provisional government of occupation" , the "Yeltsin band" or "the ruling Moscow mafia"

According to Vlasov, a regular contributor to Pravda, the Yeltsin government has "subordinated the country to the interests of the Western "market", it has destroyed the state, it has criminally weakened the army, and delivered a cruel blow to national culture, which forms the essence of the Russians as a nation".

And, as a result of "the unconditional subordination of the partyocrat-democrats to instructions from Washington". . Yeltsin supports UN sanctions against Serbia - "an act of betrayal of a people which historical fate has linked with Russia and the Orthodox Church™.

The pan-Slavism of the most extreme wing of the national-patriots knows no limits. According to Vasilyev, apparently working on the principle that any people presumed hostile to Jews merits membership of the Slay nation, even Palestinian have Slav blood in their veins.

Yeltsin's policies, claim the national-patriots, also allow national minorities within the country's borders greater influence on Russian affairs. According to Sterligov, 90% of Germans and 76% of Jews in Russia support the privatisation of land as against only 21% of Russians. *It is understandable that Germans and Jews above all are interested in the purchase of Russian soil. But Russians should not forget certain historical facts." comments Sterligov, referring to Jewish land-ownership and control of commerce -in pre-war Galicia.

Growing Western influences are also held responsible for the legeneration of Russian cultural standards. The Russian sculptor Klykov applauded a national-patriot picket of a TV station on the grounds that it showed that the Russian people had "found within itself the strength to challenge the truly satanic dogmatism which floods out from television screens"

According to the national-patriot Zyuganov: "Out of 150 cinemas in Moscow, only three were showing Russian films this week. I call this an 'intellectual and cultural concentration camp' for the Russian people"

Russians, complains Vlasov, are also turning their backs on their own literature: "No-one reads Tolstoy, Gogol or Chekhov any more. The classics of our native literature have not been re-published for between five and seven years. There is no demand for them".

"The attacks on the Russian Orthodox Church, the faith of our fathers, are increasing," writes Klykov. "Just look at how our towns are full of foreign and other missionaries. The prophetic words of Jesus Christ, *They will come in my name and deceive the people' ', have come true. They have arrived - these fake prophets"

The national-patriots oppose the capitalist market from the. standpoint of Russian nationalism. Echoing the Russian populists, and anarchists of the nineteenth-century, they reject the "free market" as something alien to Russian national traditions.

*The (Russian) people and society could not accept the market as other peoples have accepted it... For the majority of the indigenous population of Russia, the market appears as something alien... The country has ended up under the economic power of non-national forces, alien to and, if not hostile, then at least indifferent to the idea of Russia", writes Vlasov.

As Volodin puts it in Dyen: *In this (i.e. introducing market reforms) the liberals have adopted a revolutionary and extremely rapid pace, just as their communist predecessors, especially those like Trotsky, did so in the implementation of their programmes. The national-patriots have always warned that Russia today requires not revolution but gradual reforms".

The national-patriots advocate a "Third Way" - a rejection of "naked capitalism" and "utopian socialism", whilst at the same time "going beyond the limits of these two discredited models, taking from each of them only their positive aspects".

The national-patriots reject bourgeois democracy, too, as non-Russian. To quote Vlasov again:

*Democratic government, by virtue of its ideology, is non-national in its entirety and, consequently, amoral. It is outside of Russian history... The democrats cannot achieve a consciousness of national pride. The path followed by the democrats will destroy Russia".

Moscow - the Third Moscow - the Third Rome."

Against "this background of disintegration, collapse and treachery", however, the "national forces which promise a resurrection of the mother-country" are gaining in strength. Their starting point is the belief that Russia, and even the Soviet Union, can never be truly destroyed.

According to Gusov, for example, "the geopolitical space which was Russia and the Soviet Union" continues to exist as an "inner form". That "geopolitical space" existed not for 75 years but for "several centuries in the field of activity of a cosmic experiment which we are unable to perceive"

For the writer Rasputin, the concept of Russia likewise possesses a cosmic quality: "The truly Russian person is inseparable from his mother country. For him, Russia is not simply a place of residence, it is the total sum of his essence - physical, moral, spiritual and psychic, it is the total cosmic fullness of his existence. If we mean anything in this world, then it is only through fulfilling and giving expression to Russia.

The paper Russkoye Voskryesyenive expresses the issue even more crudely:

"Russians must rule Russians! I can assure you that this is not fascism or racism but common sense. You can establish whatever system you want... and call it whatever you want - Leninism, Stalinism, socialism, communism or KGBism. Provided that it is free of Yids".

The new national Russian state will be a unitary one - according to Sterligov, the idea of republican autonomy was invented by Trotsky in 1912 as a way to attack the Russian nation - but where its borders will lie is open to debate.

As far as General Makashov is concerned, for example: "For me, Russia is the successor of the USSR from the Baltic to the Kurile Islands, where all peoples live in friendship and respect for one another. If this is an empire - then I'm for such an empire!"

Such imperial thinking is also apparent in the national-patriots' slogan of "Moscow -the Third Rome": after the Rome of the Roman Empire, and then Constantinople of the Byzantine Empire (the second "Rome"), the "Third Rome" will be Moscow, capital of a "Euro-Asian" Empire lasting for all eternity - "The Third Rome exists, there will not be a fourth".

The national-patriots are becoming an increasingly well-organised and increasingly violent force in Russian society.

Sterligov has appealed for "all patriots to form cells in their enterprises and in the areas where they live.. all officers of the army to remember the traditions and honour of Russian officers"

The officially-banned "Plenum of the Central Committee of the Soviet Communist Party" has appealed for "communists to work together with healthy social and patriotic forces to oppose any further collapse of the economy and worsening of people's lives". . The Ostankino TV station picket was one result of such joint work by Stalinists and national-patriots.

The national-patriot organisations have also begun to establish squads of stormtroopers. The National Republican Army has its "Volunteer" brigades, the Russian Communist Workers' Party has its "workers' militias" and the Russian People's Assembly has its "Cossack"

Whilst Dyen carries appeals from Russian politicians advocating a struggle for power through extra-parliamentary and illegal means, including the use of violence, Pravda carries articles declaring that "the battle for power is inevitable, its hour is close... We will not spare our enemies. And the Russian-Orthodox saints will not condemn us for this"

The national-patriots" ideas are a continuation of a well-established tradition -Russian-nationalist opposition to Western capitalism dates back to the nineteenth century, the idea of a "Third Rome" dates back, to the sixteenth.

Their anti-capitalist rhetoric and calls for a strong state provide a basis for joint work with Stalinist forces, foreshadowing their role as the footsoldiers of an attempted coup by sections of the armed forces and the ex-KGB in Russia at some point in the future.

The forces of socialism in Russia remain weak and disorganised. But either they rally substantial sections of the working class behind the banner of socialist class struggle, or Russia will continue to march towards a dictatorship of the military and the national-patriots.

Scan page 13

THE CULTURAL FRONT Organiser

----- pull-quotes -----

"Imperial thinking is apparent in the national- patriots' slogan of

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 531

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →