Genetics and racism
Socialist Organiser1992 1992-08-13Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 11 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 11
pieces" of the Balkan Peninsula have served and continue to serve as levers for European diplomatic intrigues. And this entire mechanism, founded on violence and perfidy, constitutes a huge burden weighing upon the Balkan peoples, holding back their economic and cultural development.
Thus, the Serbs are forcibly partitioned between five states: they form one small "kingdom" and one tiny "principality," namely, Serbia and Montenegro, separated from each other by the sanjak of Novibazar, which, though inhabited by Serbs, belongs to Turkey; many Serbs live in the Macedonian districts subject to Turkey; finally, a large proportion of the Serbs are included within the frontiers of Austria-Hungary. A similar picture is offered by all the other Balkan nationalities.
This peninsula, richly endowed by nature, is senselessly split up into little bits; people and goods moving about in it constantly come up against the prickly hedges of state frontiers, and this cutting of nations and states into many strips renders impossible the formation of a single Balkan market, which could provide the basis for a great development of Balkan industry and culture.
On top of all this is the exhausting militarism that has come into being in order to keep the Balkans divided, and which has given rise to the danger of wars fatal to the peninsula's economic progress - wars between Greece and Turkey, Turkey and Bulgaria, Romania and Greece, Bulgaria and Serbia...
The only way out of the national and state chaos and the bloody confusion of Balkan life is a union of all the peoples of the peninsula in a single economic and political entity, on the basis of national autonomy of the constituent parts. Only within the framework of a single Balkan state can the Serbs of Macedonia, the sanjak, Serbia, and" Montenegro be united in a single national-cultural community, enjoying at the same time the advantages of a Balkan common market. Only the united Balkan peoples can give a real rebuff to the shameless pretensions of tsarism and European imperialism.
State unity of the Balkan Peninsula can be achieved in two ways: either from above, by expanding one Balkan state, whichever proves strongest, at the expense of the weaker ones - this is the road of wars of extermination and oppression of weak nations, a road that consolidates monarchism and militarism; or from below, through the peoples themselves coming together - this is the road of revolution, the road that means overthrowing the Balkan dynasties and unfurling the banner of a Balkan federal republic.
The policy followed by each of these pint-sized Balkan monarchs, with their ministers and ruling parties, has as its ostensible aim the unification of the greater part of the Balkan Peninsula under one king.
"Greater Bulgaria," "Greater Serbia," "Greater Greece," are the slogans of this policy.
Actually, though, nobody takes such slogans seriously. They are semiofficial lies put out to win popularity among the people. The Balkan dynasties, artificially installed by European diplomacy and lacking any sorts of roots in history, are too insignificant and too insecure on their thrones to venture upon a "broad" policy such as Bismarck's when he united Germany by blood and iron. The first serious shock could sweep away for good the Karageorgeviches, Coburgs, and other crowned Lilliputians of the Balkans. road of capitalist development, is politically sterile, cowardly, talentless, and rotten through and through with chauvinism. It is utterly beyond its power to take on the unification of the Balkans. The peasant masses are too scattered, ignorant, and indifferent to politics for any political initiative to be looked for from them. Accordingly, the task of creating normal conditions of national and state existence The Balkan bourgeoisie, as in countries that hai come late to the of capitalist development, is politically sterile, cowardly, talentle. and rotten througl and through with chauvinism."
in the Balkans falls with all its historical weight upon the shoulders of the Balkan proletariat.
This class is as yet small in numbers for Balkan capitalism is everywhere still hardly out of swaddling clothes. But every step forward along the road of economic development, every additional mile of railway line, every new factory chimney that arises in the Balkans, increases and rallies the ranks of the revolutionary class. Alien to every kind of ecclesiastical and monarchical superstition and to all bourgeois-democratic and nationalistic prejudices, the young Balkan proletariat, filled with vigor and enthusiasm, is utilising, in the first steps that it takes on its historic road, the rich experience of its elder brothers in Europe.
The Social Democratic parties of Bulgaria and Serbia, the most mature representatives of the labor movement in the Balkans, are fighting tirelessly on two fronts: against their own dynastic-chauvinist cliques and against the imperialist plans of tsarism and the Europe of the stock exchanges.
A federal republic in the Balkans, as the positive program of this struggle, has become the banner of the entire conscious proletariat of the Balkans without distinction of race nationality, or state frontiers.
The Balkan conference held last winter in Belgrade, which was attended by representatives of the Serbian, Bulgarian, and Romanian Social Democratic parties, of the Social Democratic groups in Macedonia, Turkey, and Montenegro, and also of the Serbian Social Democratic proletarArchduke Franz Ferdinand of Austro-Hungary general principles of the Balkan policy of the proletariat, directed towards the abolition of Balkan particularism and militarism, national conflict, and foreign oppression.
The second Balkan conference, which is to be held this winter, will have the task of forming close organizational links and indicating the forms to be taken by joint political actions on the part of all the Social Democratic parties in the Balkans. In this way there is arising before our eyes, out of the chaos and darkness of the Balkans, a united section of the Socialist This fact is extremely important for the workers of Russia. From now on not a single attempt by tsarism to interfere in the fate of the long-suffering peninsula will take place without a firm rebuff from Balkan Social Democracy. To the lies of the bourgeois parties about Slav brotherhood, accusing us of betraying the interests of the Balkan Slavs, we can now counterpose an incontrovertible fact: the proletariat of the Balkans is not with them but with us. Along with us it is fighting against tsarism, which has now, through the RussoJapanese agreement, freed its thieving hands for brigandage in Persia and intrigue in the Balkans. Along with us it has declared ruthless war upon Pan-Slavism, both the crudely Asiatic variety and the liberal Cadet one.
The historical guarantee of the independence of the Balkans and of the freedom of Russia lies in revolutionary collaboration between the workers of Petersburg and Warsaw and the workers of Belgrade and Sofia.
Pravda, [Viennal, No. 15, August 1(14), 1910 DItes:
Pan-Slavist: in the 19th and early 20th centuries, the idea of unity of ailSlav peowiess(hossmwszsepbs.
Poles etc.j мивиморіо Resstan npera smein seta us. toI wan pminetionin iasterm burppe mnn prio downei suriyalçmn that asee lemiecayıngı Tänkı şi menepae нем EMAusina ungariam Cadmire.
Kjets «thesowqcná bembpadin RUSISM.
spismassieowos mdkeneuirl •I SETOT eMpEI.
himaticoee neesa Croatia.
ismarg m Chinteneteecea 1866 of Prussia, the biggest of the then-divided German states, he led russie bator twownade wu weth Де n CEtIOnONGemenn 1871. -SCIENCELCOLUMN (Continuing an occasional series on genetics inspired by the 1991 Reith Lectures of Professor Steve Jones)
n his fifth lecture, Steve Jones directed his gaze to the past of genetics, a rather disreputable past in which people's prejudices were cloaked in "scientific" justifications.
A common misunderstanding of evolution was that there was a "great chain of being" or a ladder of ascent. Living things started off simple and got more complex and therefore better. It was perhaps an answer to those who objected to being descended from apes - yes, we were descended from apes but we were more evolved than them.
Unfortunately (but inevitably, since racism seizes on anything available to justify itself this idea intruded into the study of humans and of human "races". Humans themselves were in groups at different stages of evolution, with the Africans at the bottom of the ladder and the (north!) Europeans at the top.
This reasoning is behind the naming of the condition now known as Down's syndrome as "Mongolism". Children with this condition were thought to have slipped back down the ladder of human evolution to the "level" of the mongoloid people (ie the east Asiatic people). The fact that all human groups can have children with Down's syndrome did not interfere with this belief (in Japan, Jones tells us, Down's syndrome is referred to as "englishism").
In the pre-Darwinian world, the races were thought to be distinct because they were descended from different ancestors - according to the Bible, for instance, the sons of Noah. The theory of evolution was seized on to argue that the "races"
were biologically distinct human groups that had perhaps evolved to fit best in their specific environments. Anthropologists sought to identify physical traits that were associated with particular races, such as skull shape. They tried to identify the homelands and trace the routes of migration of the hypothetical "pure" races that had mixed to produce the modern groups of people.
As Jones points out, it is a small step from classifying people to judging them. The early anthropologists predictably found that people like themselves were at the top of the evolutionary tree. This is not because they were particularly bad people: primitive peoples have often called themselves "the men", "the only men", "the best men" or "us". Other peoples were therefore "them" or "not men" etc.
It is an interesting example of this that the Welsh word for Wales, Cymru, means "us" or "ourselves"
while the English word ("Wales")
means "foreigners".
Undoubtedly, the views of some biologists provided ammunition for racists. Imprisoned after the "beerhall putsch", Hitler read the standard German textbook of genetics which contained the phrase "The question of the quality of our hereditary endowment is a hundred times more important than the dispute over capitalism or socialism". Hitler took this to its logical conclusion by sterilising or killing those considered unfit to breed, though of the "Aryan race" and exterminating tens of millions of Jews, Romanies and Slavs. Genetic arguments were also to the fore in the free, democratic and egalitarian lands of the USA. Advice from biologists led President Coolidge to say *Biological laws tell us that certain divergent people will not mix or blend. The Nordics propagate themselves successfully. With other races, the outcome shows deterioration on both sides?. The first Immigration Act passed in 1923 was designed to keep the racial composition of the USA the same as it had been in the late 19th century, when most immigrants were from the British Isles, Germany and Scandinavia. It was particularly used to keep East European immigrants out, leaving them in the hands of the Nazis. The Act was not repealed until 1966.
The science of genetics has however provided no support for and much evidence against racial prejudice. If true races existed, matching perhaps differences in skin colour, then a genetic atlas of the world should show a pattern in the distribution not only of the ten or so skin colour genes but also of at least some of the other 50,000 genes operation in a human being.
Now, patterns in the distribution of skin colour genes are clearly linked to the intensity of sunlight; the major factor in the evolution of paler skins being the need of the body to make its own Vitamin D. This requires ultra-violet light which is less available in the colder north.
A theory of human races could just as easily be based on, say, blood group. But what are we to make of the fact that less than 10% of the English are group B while up to a third of central Russians and West Africans have the B gene?
Another gene with a global pattern is that for alcohol tolerance.
There is a trend in its frequency from east to west, with many Japanese people unable to tolerate alcohol.
The evidence from the study of human gene distribution gives no biological justification for the concept of race. The overall genetic difference between "races", say, Africans and Europeans, 1s no greater than that between different countries in Europe or Africa.
Africans as a whole are more genetically diverse than are the rest of the peoples of the world, but that reflects the greater time that they have been in their continent. The rest of the world's people are descended from a small group of emigrants who left Africa fairly late on in the history of humankind.
Despite long-seated prejudices, we are more closely related to each other than most other populations of animals.
Scan page 12
Socialist Organiser No. 531 page 12 El