Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

The Balkan question and Social Democracy

Socialist Organiser no. 531, 13 August 1992 · scan pp. 10–11 · about 972 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

Mass murder, the driving out of whole populations and all the other horrors that now in Bosnia go by the name of "ethnic cleansing" have a long history in the Balkans. There, many peoples and fragments of peoples have been thrown together and mixed by centuries of conflict, For more than a century socialists - in the first place the socialists o the Balkans - have discussed what to do, how best to resolve these conflicts. The Russian socialists, who faced similar problems of ethnic and national conflicts in parts of the Tsar's empire took part in that discussion. The following article by Leon Trotsky appeared in the paper Trotsky published in Vienna in August 1910. conquest and counter-conquest.

It the end of June 1910] there was held in Bulgaria's capital, Sofia, the second "All-Slav" congress. The significance of this event may be summarised as follows: Political bankrupts from various Slavonic countries gathered together in order to proclaim their bankruptcy to the world at large.

In meetings held in St. Petersburg and then at the Prague congress of 1908 the new "Pan-Slavist" movement took the stage to the sound of drums and trumpets: it undertook to reconcile Poles and Russians. Ruthenians and Poles, Serbs and Bulgars, to put an end to friction and enmity between the bourgeois classes of all the Slavonic nations and to set the edifice of the new Slavdom upon a foundation of liberty, equality, and fraternity Since then two years have gone by; and very poor results had to be reported to the congress held in Sofia. During this period all the contradictions within Slavdom succeeded in attaining unprecedented acuteness. In "Slavonic" Russia the counterrevolution put persecution of Poles and Ukrainians on the order of the day: the new western zemstvo and the scheme to cut off the district of Chelm are the final word of the Polish policy of constitutional tsarism. In Galicia the oppression of the Ruthenian nationality by the Polish gentry and bourgeoisie led, almost on the very eve of the Sofia congress, to a bloody battle inside the walls of Lvov University. If relations between Bulgaria and Serbia have not worsened in this period. they have certainly not improved In view of these facts, the speeches delivered in Sofia about the solidarity of all Slavs did not even sound hypocritical, so openly was mutual hostility and barefaced insolence expressed in them. The Cadets, who until recently were leading the All-Slav choir, drew back in dismay and bewilderment, making room for more direct and immediate servants of tsarism. Miliukov and Maklakov stayed at home. Guchkov, Count Bobrinsky, and Cherep-Spiridovich attended as Russia's representatives. Kramar. the leader of the Young Czechs, bustled about trying to improve outlets in the Balkans for the products of Czech industry. All touchy questions - concerning Poland, the Ukraine, the South Slavs, the Balkans - were hushed up by mutual agreement: this was more convenient for all participants in the All-Slav comedy.

Outside the congress, however, in the streets and squares of Sofia, all the questions of international politics, and first and foremost the Balkan Question, were presented clearly, openly, and honestly. This was done by the Bulgarian Social Democrats.

At a mass meeting conducted by Blagoev and Kirkov a resolution was adopted on June 20, before the Slavonic congress met, which tore the mask from the speculators in Pan-Slavism. Not content with this, the Bulgarian Social Democrats invited to their annual congress at the beginning of July representatives of the Slavonic Social Democratic parties, so as to show the Balkan masses in a striking way that there are two Bulgarias, Iwo Serbias, two Russias - in each case a reactionary-dynastic one and a revolutionary-proletarian one.

In this way the regular congress of the Bulgarian Workers" Party was this time transformed into a splendid demonstration of international solidarity of the proletariat. which found expression not only in fervent ovations and reciprocal greetings. but above all in the fact that the delegates of all the parties represented in Sofia - Bulgarian. Serbian. Russian, Czech, and Ruthenian - proceeded from the same premises and arrived at the same conclusions in deciding how to settle the Balkan (Eastern) Question.

Ewo aspects need to be distinguished in what is known as the Eastern Question: first, it is a question of the relations between the nations and states of the Balkan Peninsula: second, it is a question of the conflicting interests and intrigues of the European capitalist powers in the Balkans. These Iwo questions are not at all identical. On the contrary: the real solution of the purely Balkan Question runs entirely counter to the interests of the European dynasties and stock exchanges.

The Balkan Peninsula, which is approximately as big as Germany but has only about one-third as many inhabitants (22 million), is divided between six independent states: Greece. Turkey, Romania, Bulgaria. Serbia, and Montenegro, logether with the Austro-Hungarian provinces of Dalmatia. Bosnia, and Herzegovina. In the six independent states, each of which has its own dynasty, army, currency, and customs system, there live many nations and races, divided into separate fragments: Greeks, Turks. Romanians, Bulgars. Serbs, Albanians, Jews, Armenians. Gypsies... The frontiers between the dwarf states of the Balkan Peninsula were drawn not in accordance with national conditions or national demands, but as a result of wars, diplomatic intrigues, and dynastic interests.

The Great Powers - in the first place, Russia and Austria - have always had a direct interest in setting the Balkan peoples and states. against each other and then, when they have weakened one another, subjecting them to their economic

Scan page 11

and political influence. The petty dynasties ruling in these "broken The Balkan bourgeoisie, as in all countries that have come late to the lans of the southern provinces of Austria-Hungary, worked out the Socialist Organiser No. 531 page 11

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 531

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →