Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

The human revo ution

Socialist Organiser no. 531, 13 August 1992 · scan pp. 8–10 · about 3,238 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 8

Marxist anthropologist Chris Knight outlines the themes of his controversial new book, which argues that a women's "sex strike" was central in the transition from ape to human being.

Most anthropologists have tacitly assumed that human culture was established by men. The "Man the Hunter" myth has dominated palaeoanthropology, now, almost since the inception of the discipline. Through the 1960s and 1970s, it was taken as self-evident that the sexual division of labour, with males hunting and provisioning females, emerged at least three million years ago, in a process linked with the emergence of bipedalism, tool-making and the evolving brain.

In the past decade, there's been a revolution in archaeology and palaeontology, leading to the view that all this is nonsense, that the early hominids were ape-like creatures leading ape-like lives, and that it was only in an extremely recent *human revolution" that culture as we know it emerged. Leading archaeologists Lewis Binford and Olga Soffer are now showing that in Europe, at least, there is no evidence that males were hunting meat for females until at most 50,000 years ago. It seems that Neanderthal males did a bit of hunting, but tended to eat most of the meat themselves!

Leading palaeontologist Chris Stringer of the Natural History Museum and most up-to-date archaeologists are now agreed that the Neanderthals were not our been of labour ancestors and were not culturally "modern". The dominant view today is (a) that the human species emerged in a "revolutionary" way, (b) that this revolution began in Africa about 100,000 years and was consummated on a global level some 60,000-40,000 years ago, and (c) that only during this revolution did symbolic language and culture emerge. Those primatologists, sociobiologists and others attempting to work out the internal dynamics of this revolution, moreover, stress that women's interests and initiatives must have been paramount. This has little to do with feminist political thinking. The scientists' confidence on this score is rooted partly in standard sociobiological theory: among all primates, it's female reproductive strategies which tend to "drive" social-evolutionary change. "Women's power was based on their had the relations with any time.

The human revolution happened. The details of precisely how it happened have not yet been agreed. My work as a Marxist is essentially about the details - about the social and political dynamic of that revolution. When Chris Stringer and others talk about a "Human Revolution" it's little more than a formal term, which anyone can interpret pretty much as they like. Stringer himself relies mainly on bones and genes, and it's less easy to see the politics in those. Lots of people can talk about "the Human Revolution" without thinking things through as Marxists would do. They don't mind the concept because they don't see what it's got to do with politics.

But the moment Marxists start trying to think about a "revolution" in the Ice Age - they are bound to start wondering about the social dynamics, the conflicts, the struggles of conflicting forces. And for some Marxists, this is a problem. For it can't possibly be "class" that was at issue at this early stage. So what can it have been?

Well, the only theoretically possible answer is that of Engels' in The Origin of the Family, Private Property and the State. The dynamic can only have been sexual. There must have been a sexual revolution which led to what Engels termed the "primacy" of women in the *communistic household". And that's breathtaking in its implications. It means that if you accept the idea of a "Human Revolution" and then think it through, it has a logic of its own. You are taken straight to Engels' whole theory. Engels was right after all. This is how (quoting Arthur Wright), Engels described how communistically organised Iroquois women wielded their power: *Usually, the female portion ruled the house... The stores were held in common: but woe to the luckless husband or lover who was too shiftless to do his share of the providing. No matter how many children, or whatever goods he might have in the house, he might at any time be ordered to pick up his blanket and budge; and after such orders it would not be healthful for him to attempt to disobey. The house would be too hot for him and... he must retreat to his own clan..." (The Origin of the Family, Private Property and the Women's power, in this account, was based on their solidarity, and on the fact that they had the right to rupture their sexual relations with men at any time. None of this is new at all. It is just that the new palacoanthropology converges with sociobiological theory to suggest that Engels was more resoundingly and irrefutably right than he himself could possibly have known.

My book starts from the idea that to be fully-human is to be conscious, and that consciousness in any meaningful sense has something to do with the class struggle. What has that got to do with the Ice Age? The answer is that the class struggle as a determinant of "consciousness" didn't begin yesterday, or even a few hundred years ago. As both Marx and Engels fully realised, if our struggle is traced back far enough into the past, it will be found to take other forms, sexual contradictions being among the most central.

The contradictions which led to revolutionary transformation can be traced ultimately to the fact that complex learning depends on large brains. These need time to develop. Besides involving an unusual degree of infant helplessness following birth, such brains also need a prolonged childhood in which sufficient learning can take place. The evolution of large-brained Homo sapiens therefore brought with it dramatically intensified childcare burdens. If these were not to defeat the mothers who were primarily responsible, it was vital for evolving females to ensure that the opposite sex contributed more support than had ever been contributed by male primates, including hominids, before.

To understand this, you have to realise that male primates - for example gorillas and chimpanzees - don't provide food for their offspring. They leave that entirely to mothers. If we suppose that, initially, evolving human males were equally reluctant provisioners, and that human evolution involved contradictions and struggles around digni get such issues, then in my view the inte mysteries of human cultural origins sha begin to dissolve. beg If females needed to get males to whi hunt for them, they would have Nat had to link sex with success in the chase. To grasp the main logical possibilities, let's begin by review- fav ing the situation among tle chimpanzees. als Cent "Solidarity the enhanced women 74,0 consciousness, as afte Ins making them more ofis intelligent. The can evic solidarity stemming etc. from strike action SLU can enhanced women's on menstrual and they fora a source of for collective strength. mea thei quIt to a When a male chimp has caught a OUT small antelope, monkey or other det animal, a female will sometimes the rush up to him and sexually present her hindquarters. If the male is Th

Scan page 9

he greatndeas of the french evolution, which @pened in 1789, exploded across the world - the cry for liberty, equality, fraternity rang outsweryose. Irish Catholic peasants, Black Hartian slaves and Base indussial were alive responded to those ideas and took up arms to win them.

The worker dovelahem owe yersion of hese ideas ushen anew thre new howchenis ruling classes as well as agates- tags-m Landords. The indeendem werking class outlook on the varld - Narxism - would suentrod In-fracm, the ruling class respondanto the Revnlution with a savage renressie - The people. Heed mere s 6 гене, колони мете зн Solley believed i a pure, radical, Isola serration of the baken Raxolus ideas. With his friend Byron and others, he defended the workers and agitated against the Establishment. In the House of Lords, Lord Byron defended the primitive working class machine-breaking -"Luddite" - revolt, and wrote a Luddite anthem "And down with all kings save King Ludd!" Shelley wrote the "Masque of Anarchy" in response to a massacre of peaceful demonstrators in Manchester in 1879 ("Peerlon"). In short_ Stelloyanase-radic поте socialism had come into existence, and before the working class movement had He was accidentally drowned in 1822, not quite 30. His friend Byron died fighting "The real difference between Shelley and Byron lies in the following: Those who understand and cherish them, consider it fortunate that Byron died in his thirtysixth year; since if he had lived longer he would have become a reactionary bourgeois. On the other hand, they regret that Shelley died at twenty-nine, since he was a thoroughgoing revolutionary and would always have belonged to the power"' Women continue to find power today through anised ested, the female may obtain a = of his meat, which she will eating on the spot, perhaps copulation is still proceeding. rally, if a second female arrives e kill-site, she will be in comon with the first for the male's urs. This strategy generates litany interfemale solidarity; it prompts males to compete ist once another using meat to e females for sex. man females, I am arguing, did exact opposite. Following the t of the last Ice Age some O years ago, they did not chase meat-possessing males. ad, they stood firm with their ring and declined to move. We ell this from the archaeological ince of their home-bases, fires Unlike Neanderthal females, en of our species at this point red moving endlessly from • to camp. For much of the they doubtless relied partly eir own gathered food. But as when they needed meat - as emphatically did each winter y adopted a totally new strateead of endlessly travelling and ing, they made their menfolk such of the necessary travelling -tem. Instead of running to the they made the meat come to . The trick was in essence simple. They signalled "No!" -y male who approached withneat. Any male who tried to this resistance met with a wall lective hostility, generated by ogic of the situation. are would have been no point in signalling "No!" to a lazy or meatless male if the female concerned knew that her sister or female neighbour was going to signal "Yes!" at the same time. The male would just cheat and go to her rival. In other words, the strategy of signalling "No!" would have meant choosing the right moment, making sure that all females in the vicinity were in this together. The women's "No!", then, within this strategy, must have been a collective signal in order to be effective.

Women, as they became conscious and cultural, had a ready-made biological heritage for exactly such a strategy. The human female conceals her ovulation, so that no male can tell precisely when she's fertile. She loses more menstrual blood than any other primate, so that her main biological signal occurs at the point of nonfertility; she can have sex at any time in her cycle, or refuse sex at any time; and she tends to synchronise her cycle with all other females who are in close proximity.

Furthermore, the average length of the female menstrual cycle indicates an ancient tradition of synchronising using the moon as a clock: unlike a chimp cycle, which is on average 36 days in length, the human cycle averages 29.5 days -precisely the time it takes for the moon to pass through its phases as seen from the earth.

Solidarity enhanced women's consciousness, as if making them more intelligent. Biologically, the solidarity stemming from strike action would have enhanced women's menstrual synchrony enabling them to experience their body-clocks as a source of collective strength. "Females" in fact became "women" when they estaolished their own pride, their own dignity, their own power. Empowered by finding themselves* in solidarity with one another, women collectively drew on their own biological resources to give their menstrual blood a wholly new, collectively constructed meaning as a symbol of absolute inviolability. Women would undoubtedly have chosen each period of synchronised menstruation as the best moment to go collectively "on strike". Such a "sex-strike", timed according to the menstrual and lunar cycle, would have signalled the beginning of each month's preparation for collective big-game hunting.

Under such circumstances the flowing of the blood, far from symbolising weakness or disability, would have been felt as the symbolic expression of women's power and solidarity (including solidarity with men as sons and brothers) within each clan. And I should add that if such blood-solidarity or clansolidarity in some ways felt like modem class solidarity — as Engels certainly thought - then the blood of sisterhood may have prefigured the red banner of socialism today. Blood-redness in all cultures tends to symbolise defiance and power. The colour of our own flag - red with our own class blood - is no coincidence.

In the course of cultural origins, the rule against rape was to revolutionary womanhood what the inviolability of the picket-line is to revolutionary communism. It was the first cultural rule, the one to be established at all costs, and the foundation on which all other rules were to be built.

I make no apology for drawing on the findings of "right-wing sociobiology" in order to arrive at such conclusions. Marx did the same thing in his own time: he took classical political economic theory -which was clearly being used to justify the existing system of class oppression - and instead of ignoring it, looked into its internal contradictions. He was able to make revolutionary use of it. Sociobiology looks at human sociality in the pre-cultural period and sees parallel everywhere with bourgeois economics. It is powerful precisely because of this - because it claims to show that the predatory and competitive realities of contemporary society have parallel in "nature".

My view is that behaviour motivated by the requirements "selfish" genes really is what drives Darwinian natural evolution. There's no point in denying that. The important thing is that humans became human by overthrowing that logic of nature. We got into culture; which is different. Culture, based on solidarity, reconstructed our "nature" completely. That's what the human revolution was all about, and why it's so important to claim it as the beginning of our revolutionary heritage. We won the revolution once. We can do it again.

mergs-rom-vithin this current of ideas.

eing which Percy Byssa Shady ee 123188 1 НАЛДУ/ЯН 001-0 64 Greak insapondeney-son reported this as her father's opinion of Shelley:

Socialy капуника Freedom Men of England, heirs of Glory, Heroes of unwritten story, Nurslings of one mighty Mother, Hopes of her, and one another; Rise like Lions after slumber In unvanquishable number, Shake your chains to earth like de Which in sleep had fallen on you - Ye are many - they are few. What is Freedom? - ye can tell That which slavery is, too wellFor its very name has grown To an echo of your own. "Tis to work and have such pay As just keeps life from day to day In your limbs, as in a cell For the tyrant's use to dwell, 'Tis to see your children weak With their mothers pine and peak When the winter winds are bleak, They are dying whilst I speak. "Tis to hunger for such diet As the rich man in his riot Casts to the fat dogs that lie Surfeiting beneath his eye; Tis to let the Ghost of Gold Take from Toil a thousandfold More than e'er its substance ci In the tyrannies of old. 'Tis to be a slave in soul And to hold no strong control Over your own wills, but be All that others make of ye. And at length when ye complai With a murmur weak and vain Tis to see the Tyrant's crew Ride over your wives and youBlood is on the grass like dew. Then it is to feel revenge Fiercely thirsting to exchange Blood for blood - and wrong for wrong.

Do not thus when ye are strong. What art thou, Freedom? O! cou slaves Answer from their living graves This demand - tyrants would flee Like a dream's dim imagery: Thou art not, as imposters say. A shadow soon to pass away. A superstition, and a name Echoing from the cave of Fame For the labourer thou art bread And a comely table spread, From his daily labour come To a neat and happy home. Thou art clothes, and fire, and For the trampled multitude -No - in countries that are free Such starvation cannot be As in England now we see. Thou art Justice - ne'er for gold May thy righteous laws be sold As laws in England - thou Shield'st alike the high and low. Thou art Wisdom - Freemen never Dream that God will damn for ever All who think those things untrue Of which Priests make such ado. Thou art Peace - never by thee Would blood and treasure wasted b As tyrants wasted them, when all Leagued to quench thy flame in Ga 0. 48246later.

Sean:/Morganw Science, Poetry, and Thought Are thy lamps; they make the Of the dwellers in a cot So serene, they curse it not. (Excerpts from "The Masque Anarchy", 1819)

Men of England, wherefore plough For the lords who lay ye low? Wherefore weave with toil and care The rich robes your tyrants wear? Wherefore feed and clothe and save. From the cradle to the grave, Those ungrateful drones who would Drain your sweat - nay, drink your blood?

Wherefore, Bees of England, forge Many a weapon, chain, and scourge That these stingless drones may spoi The forced produce of your toil? Have ye leisure, comfort, calm, Shelter, food, love's gentle balm? Or what it is ye buy so dear With your pain and with your fear? The seed ye sow another reaps; The wealth ye find another keeps; The robes ye weave another wears; The arms ye forge another bears. Sow seed, - but let no tyrant reap; Find wealth, - let no imposter heap; Weave robes, - let not the idle wear; Forge arms, - in your defence to bear. Shrink to your cellars, holes, and cells In halls ye deck another dwells. Why shake the chains ye wrought? Ve see The steel ye tempered glance on ye. With plough and spade, and hoe and loom, Trace your grave, and build your tomb, And weave your winding-sheet, till England be your sepulchre.

Emmet's No trump tells thy virtues -where they rest With thy dust shall remain unpolluted by fame, Till thy foes, by the world and fortune caressed, Shall pass like a mist from the thy name.

When the storm-cloud that lowers the day-beam is gone.

Unchanged, unextinguished its lifespring will shine:

When Erin has ceased with their memory to groan.

She will smile through the tears of revival on thine. (22 year-old Robert Emmet organis an Irish uprising against British ruli in 1803. It went wrong and, captured, he was publicly hanged, cut down alive, disemboweled and then chopped into pieces. Shelley wrote this in 1812.)

Scan page 10

Socialist Organiser No. 531 page 10

----- pull-quotes -----

solidarity, and on the fact that they

right to rupture their sexua

synchrony, them to experience their body-clocks as

"Blood Relations" by Chris Knight is published by the Yale University Press, price £40.

to the Men of Engla Song

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 531

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →