Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

The Tories, the ERM and the recession

Socialist Organiser no. 531, 13 August 1992 · scan pp. 5–6 · about 1,530 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 5 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 5

is very high: the priority of the government is to policy and at the alternativ Is far as economic policy is concerned, John Major's government is one which keeps its word. In spite of the fact that the often promised green shoots of recovery remain nowhere to be found, the government remains faithful to the economic policy with which it fought the election and which it had followed unswervingly for the previous eighteen months. This policy is pursued in the face of formidable critics, notable not only for their political range (stretching from Baroness Thatcher, through the CBI to the Guardian, Observer and New Statesman) but also for the unanimity with which these critics espouse an alternative: if Britain is to escape from recession, they tell us, interest rates must be lowered and the Pound must be devalued. Between this alternative and the government, the government is more correct!

The human cost of this recession, which is now the longest, and which will be the deepest experienced since the Second World War, is very high. From its low point in April 1990, unemployment in the UK has risen from 1.6 million to 2.7 million this June. By the end of next winter the number unemployed will. have passed three million (the previous post World War Two record set in 1986) and there is no reason to suppose that it will do anything except carry on rising.

To deal with the recession is not, however, an objective of this government's policy. Instead, it has as its priority the continuation of Britain's membership of the Exchange Rate Mechanism (ERM) of the European Monetary System. More specifically, it is determined to maintain the position of the Pound within the ERM.

How does the ERM work? At its heart lies an agreement between European governments to maintain the parities, or rates, at which the different European currencies exchange for one another. Some fluctuation in the rates of exchange is allowed and since the announcement of the general election in March, the Pound has fluctuated quite widely, initially falling to close to the bottom of its range (worries that Labour might win), then rising sharply (euphoria over the Tory victory, and then recently falling back again (the prospects are still dreadful). Although the ERM allows for some joint action by European central banks to 'defend' weak currencies by buying them in the market, the point comes when that is no longer judged to be feasible and the country with the weak currency is obliged to defend its value by raising interest rates.

Not only is this government committed to membership of the ERM, it is also committed to maintaining the rate at which the Pound exchanges for other currencies. If that means raising interest rates then this government gives the firm impression that it would not flinch from doing so. The government, no less than its critics, understands what this would mean: further falls in investment; further increases in debt and therefore bankruptcy; reduced demand and therefore production; yet more job losses; rising homelessness.

There should be no surprise at the singular resolution with which Major's government is pursuing this policy. Officially, the policy is pursued in the interests of defeating inflation; this, we are told, is the key

ECONOMY

to sound economic recovery. It is not so much that this argument is nonsense (which it is) but rather that it is not the real reason why the government sticks doggedly to the ERM. Major represents the interests of the institutions of finance capital: the banks, the insurance companies and pension funds, stockbrokers, securities houses etc. This group -the 'city' - is engaged in a fierce struggle to secure as large a slice as possible of the European business in financial services. In order to achieve this, a stable rate of exchange between the Pound and the other European currencies is essential with the ideal being a single European currency. The stability which the ERM affords is essential, if the institutions of British finance capital are to achieve their aim of securing a predominant position within Europe. It is the job of Major, the banker, to deliver this stability.

It goes without saying that these policies are vastly detrimental to the interests of the many millions who depend for their livelihood on their own labour. It must be understood, however, that the principal alternative which has been put forward is liable to be worse. This alternative is the complete opposite of the government's policy: instead of using high interest rates to maintain the value of the Pound, the government, we are told, should lower interest rates and devalue the Pound.

If these actions are to be anything more than merely cosmetic, they are likely to destroy the ERM or, at the very least, force Britain to leave it. Tory nationalists such as Thatcher would rejoice at this. For them, of course, a political blow struck against Europe and against the proEuropeans who ousted Thatcher from office is the real objective.

What of those, however, who put this policy forward sincerely as being an essential part of the strategy for recovery? There are two objections. Firstly, the alternative policy could not actually be realised. Undoubtedly, the government could determine that it was no longer going to defend the Pound's present exchange rates against other currencies. To announce this - even merely to hint at the possibility -would be sufficient for the financial markets immediately to mark the Pound down. Devaluation is therefore certainly possible. But would this allow lower interest rates? Historically, the evidence is consistent with the view that the UK is unable for any significant length of time to lower its rates below that of its main trading partner. These days, the single most important partner is Germany (accounting for some 16% of UK imports); the EC as a whole accounts for a little over half the UK's total trade. Inside or outside the ERM, the UK is obliged to follow Germany's lead, whether it wishes to or not.

Secondly, even if it were possible to achieve and sustain rates of interest lower than those in Germany, the UK is still in no position to recover from recession on its own. The reason for this is the deficit which the UK runs in its international trade, importing in 1991 some 8% more than it exports. Any sign of economic recovery in the UK would immediately worsen this position and any such worsening, particularly outside the ERM, is unlikely to be sustainable. Indeed, one of the remarkable aspects of the current recession is not its severity but rather how mild it has been in view of this continuing trade deficit. That the UK has been able to continue to finance this deficit (by attracting foreign capital is unprecedented and that it has been able so to do is intimately connected with the ERM. Far from making the recession worse than if "Britain had gone it alone' the ERM has, I think, ensured a less severe recession than would otherwise be the case. To leave it therefore could lead to quite the opposite results from those intended, making things worse and not better.

I must say that it is becoming increasingly likely that this alternative policy will eventually be forced upon the government, with perhaps massive political consequences. If it should happen, however, do not be misled by those who would herald it as the first step on the road to recovThe basic flaw in the critique of this government's policy is the belief that the UK is in reality in any position to take sustained action to ease and to end the recession on its own. Countries such as Germany, the USA, Japan and perhaps even Korea do enjoy a certain autonomy of action; countries such as the UK or France whose political economy is based upon levels of private consumption sustained by productive activity elsewhere do not. The only thing at the moment which can lead to a sustained increase in economic activity in this country and a fall in unemployment is a renewal of a vigorous growth in world trade.

All talk to the effect that the government has 'surrendered' control over this or that aspect of economic policy whether to the German Bundesbank or the Brussels bureaucrats is to miss the point: the efforts to construct supra-national institutions and to devise rules of conduct to restrain national governments are efforts born of this economic interdependence. In that sense, Major's government is far more realistic and sober in its appraisal of what is possible than most of the critics to its right and its left. For, so long as we continue to view matters in terms of the interests of nation-states, then we Will be obliged if we are serious to conclude that there is nothing that the individual nation-state alone can do. If there is to be progress, we must look elsewhere, both at more than Britain and less than Britain 10o.

Scan page 6

Socialist Organiser No. 531 page 6

----- pull-quotes -----

In the first of two articles, Peter Kenway looks at the government's economic

which is enjoying increasing popular

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 531

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →