A mode dispute
Socialist Organiser1992 1992-08-13Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 4
moment, so perhaps it's worth spending some time looking at this one. The first thing that struck everyone who visited the strike was how well organised it was: 24-hour picket rotas, regular mass meetings, a well-pro duced bulletin, a caravan for the pickets. Small things, The other obvious factor was the high level of rank and file involvement and the democratic structure of the mass meetings. Every Wednesday, in the function room of a pub near the factory (the bar was closed!) the strikers heard report-backs from the full timers and the senior stewards. Then the meeting was thrown open to the floor for questions, suggestions, whinges and the occasional stream of consciousness. Wives and partners were encouraged to attend and a women's support committee was being talked about by the time the disThere was none of the usual arrogant "we know best" condescension from either the officials or the senior stewards. All contacts with management were faithfully reported back to the meetings. Even hardened rightwing AEEU officials checked their every move with the And the stewards welcomed "outside" help and support (even from the much-reviled "paper sellers"). The convenor and the senior stewards were all fairly new to their positions and had only limited knowledge of the local labour movement. Early on in the dispute they made contact with the Birmingham Trades Council and the local Labour Party. As a result, a dispute which (for all its importance) could have remained an obscure, isolated struggle became a well-known cause celebre in Birmingham and beyond. The Trades Council connertion was particularly important, resulting in a regular bulletin, invitations to branches and a healthy income Even so, the victory, when it came, took everyone by surprise. One minute management was toughing it out, showing no sign of making the slightest concession, the next, they'd given way on virtually all the unions"
Maybe the Alcan national bosses realised they'd bitten off more than they could chew and started leaning on the local management. Certainly, the strike happened at a good time, when order books were full and business was experiencing a minor "blip" just after the election. But fundamentally, the Aican workers won because they were solid, well organised and had a plant leaderometimes it's a plea- MISDETHE sure to be proved wrong. In the previous UNIONS column I wrote about the Alcan dispute, predicting a "long, bitter road" unless the action was spread to th company's other plants.
Within a day of those words appearing in print, the Alcan strikers had won a famous victory.
Clear cut victories By Sleeper this are few and far between just at the perhaps, but vital for morale. pute ended.
rank and file every Wednesday. for the strike fund.
demands.
ship they could trust.
I hope I'm wrong about a lot SURPRISE YESUL STRIKE BULLETIN OF THE ALCAN PLATE Shop Stewards Ther teards and the vowel The financial empires bui on the credit wave of the 1980s are also suffering especially.
All that means more people out of work, more ruini business-people, more pres sure to keep wages down -which in turn means lower sales, and a worse slump.
The present downturn started early in Britain, when a big balance of payments deficit forced the Government to block the flow of credit. It started on late last year in Germany and Japan, and is likely to continue world-wide for a long time yet.
It is worse in Britain because of Tory Government policies. The Tories deliberately used the slump of the early '80s to make mass unemployment a bludgeon against the trade unions - at the cost of ruining manufacturing industry.
By contracting-out, privatisation, and cuts, the Tory Government is trying to reduce that core section of the working class who have stable jobs in boom or slump.
Decades of struggle by the labour movement forced the capitalist state to put health care, education, and other services on the basis of provision according to need, nol according to what is profitable.
That not only guarantees health care and education continued from page 3 the Stalinist counter-revolution and the corruption of the world communist movement was the historic "Trotskyism". PostTrotsky Trotskyism is something else again.
But that is now beside the point. For 43 or 44 years, from the late 1940s, the majority of the Trotskyist movement did not follow the course for those who would otherwise be too poor to pay hospital or school bills; it makes jobs in the public services safer.
The public service trade unions have survived the 13 years of Tory rule so far better, on the whole, than those in manufacturing industry. The Tories are determined that they should not survive the next 13 years!
The labour movement should use the base and the strength that it has in the public services to resist con tracting-out and privatisation.
The Tories can be and have been pushed back by trade union action. Public service workers on the rail and Underground, in the civil service, and even in local authorities, have tremendous strategic power if only they take united action.
They can force the Tories to retain and even to expand public services.
We should fight for the present miserable cheaplabour Government "training" schemes to be replaced by genuine traini! and retraining, at trade union rates of pay, with training courses leading to recognised qualifications.
Both in the public and in the private sector, trade unions should also fight for a shorter working week.
This demand can be won. The engineering workers won a cut in their working is an idea whose time, though it never quite came, is now, nonetheless, irrevocably gone.
When the Trotskyist mainstream, in the late 1940s, turned towards a more "positive"
account of Stalinism, there was a mass exodus from its ranks.
Something similar is likely to happen as the implications of the fall of Stalinism percolate through, When Trotskyist groups such as Socialist Outlook are reduced to arguing for Stalinism in terms week, even under the unmilitant leadership of Bill Jordan. Where trade unio are weaker, in the US or Japan, work hours are longer; conversely, strong trade union action can cut hours.
Capitalism is crazy: it throws millions of people into enforced idleness, only to use the threat of the sack to force those who still have jobs to work harder, for longer hours. Instead, the work should be shared out equally among all those whe want jobs.
Such a campaign could unite the employed and unemployed. To organise the unemployed and save them from despair must b the labour movement's to priority.
The employers and the Government will say that they can't "afford" jobs, training, and public services. We should reply: open Trotskyists. We believe that the future of working-class politics lies with Trotsky, and with a cleansed and regenerate Trotskyism.
Trotskyism, which took over and fought for the ideas of the early Communist International, was no arbitrary or personal creation. The International itself inherited the progressive work and root ideas of the previously existing socialist movement.
The ideas of Trotskyism are the continuation and summathe books! If individual businesses really are bankrupt, open the books o the big wealth-holders in th banks and the City institutions!
Democratic debate, not a casino of competitive swindling, should decide where major credits and investments go.
"Only the expropriation the private banks and the concentration of the entire credit system in the hands of the state". , as Leon Trotsky wrote, "will provide the state with the necessary real material resources - and not merely paper and bureaucratic resources - for economic planning.
"However, the statisation of the banks will produce these favourable results onl if the state power itself pass es completely from the hands of the exploiters into the hands of the workers" labour movement politically, so that it can finally settle accounts with capitalism and begin to build a socialist world.
We appeal to those Trotskyists who believe that the now collapsed or collapsing Stalinist states betrayed the hope of socialist progress to stop identifying Trotskyism with the patently false ideas grafted on to it after Trotsky's death. PostTrotsky "Trotskyism" is dead?
Go back to Trotsky!
We appeal to all those who call themselves Trotskyists to