Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

52 years after Trotsky's murder Does Trotskyism have a future?

Socialist Organiser no. 531, 13 August 1992 · scan pp. 3–4 · about 1,100 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 3 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 3

Trotsky helped lead the the Russian revolution of 1917 and then fought the Stalinist counter-revolution. This photo was taken in the last week of his life cist dictator Hitler had a last meeting with the French ambassador Coulondre.

Soon, for the second time in a quarter-century, France and Germany would be tearing each other to pieces in war. Coulondre remonstrated with Hitler about the deal with Stalin under which Germany and the USSR had invaded Poland. It would mean war.

He conjured up for Hitler the memory of what had happened at the end of the last world war. Working-class revolt had swept across Europe. The revolutionary workers took and held power in Russia; they took power and were overthrown in Hungary and in Bavaria.

Europe was swept by strikes, factory seizures, and great mass movements of workers determined not to go on in the old way and desperately looking for a way to win socialism.

That, said Coulondre, is what you risk unleashing once again. To dramatise his point, and to evoke as vividly as he could for Hitler the horrors he was conjuring up, Coulondre pronounced the name under which he, and the European bourgeoisie, thought of the socialist revolution.

"The real victor (in case of war) will be Trotsky. Have you thought this over?"

Trotsky! Together with Lenin, Trotsky had led the Russian workers' revolution in 1917. He had opposed the tyrannical Stalin regime in the USSR. Now a hunted exile, he preached the need for socialist revolution as the only alternative to the barbarism into which capitalism and Stalinism were plunging the world. For the bourgeoisie of the world and for the Stalinists who ruled the USSR he personified the threat of working class revolution. Less than a "The emancipation of thiel workingıclass is also thei ependation of Whauman weings without distinction of sex or race.

Karl Marx Socialist Organiser RU Ber REMLondro SELS 4NA Nemsdesk: 07i 658 7965 Latest date for reports: Monday Published by: WL Publications Ltd, PO Box 823 London SE15 4NA Printed by Tridant Press, Edenbridge Registered as a newspaper at the Post Office • Me views Nocalst Organisen Lie viewsior and are in a personal capacity unless otherwise stated. year after that conversation, Trotsky was strick down by an assassin sent by Stalin, the gravedigger of the Russian workers' revolution. -On 20 August 1940, in Coyocoan, a suburb of Mexico City, the Spanish Stalinist Ramon Mercader, posing as a co-thinker of Trotsky in order to get close to him, smashed Trotsky's skull with an ice-pick. Trotsky died the following day.

He left behind him a weak and tiny movement. That movement was a small splinter from the gigantic world communist movement, made up of those who had rallied to the Russian Revolution, and stayed with those - like Stalin - who controlled the "Soviet" state because they did not understand that a political and social counterrevolution had taken place within the collectivist property forms that continued to exist in the Soviet Union.

"If those who call themselves Trotskyists worthy of the great socialist fighter who died a footnote in socialist history and an incidental casualty in the final collapse of bureaucratic Stalinism, will be able shape the future.

Trotsky's movement held to the original perspectives and programme of the Communist International, the world-wide party of socialist revolution that Lenin set up in 1919 - to the goal of winning working-class power in the advanced capitalist countries. But that programme could only be fought for effectively by a mass movement; those perspectives depended for their realisation on the living activity of millions of revolutionary workers. And the millions-strong world-wide army of "communism" was in the grip of the delusion that Stalinism was communism; organisationally it was in the grip of the Stalinist bureaucracy, which used lies, corruption, and secret police gangsterism to keep its hold. W War Two, the great wave hen, at the end of World of working-class revolt Coulondre had threatened Hitler with did sweep Europe, it was controlled or repressed by the Stalinist apparatus. In Eastern Europe and China systems like that of the USSR were created; in the West the Stalinist movement helped the bourgeoisies, Stalin's then allies, rebuild their states - in France and Italy for example.

Stalinism expanded into new areas, covering one third of the world. Capitalism, which had seemed almost on its last legs in 1940, entered a post-war boom. The mass labour movements of the advanced countries settled in to live with capitalism. Capitalism experienced such lightning-flash revolts as the seizure of the factories in France by nine million workers in May 1968, but easily survived them.

The majority of the forces making up post-Trotsky Trotskyism continued to see the Stalinist states as degenerated or deformed "workers' states", socially in advance of and superior to capitalism. Russia, Eastern Europe, and China were, they believed, "post-capitalist" ', in transition between capitalism and socialism.

Trotskyism thus seemed to be the embodiment of an idea whose time had come - and somehow passed it by; a movement whose programme, or the fundamentals of it, had been made reality by its enemies, and grotesquely twisted into horrible shapes in the process.

The majority of the movement adapted itself to Stalinism, especially to the new Stalinist formations like Maoism and Castroism. This was never uncritical adaptation - those who ceased to be critical ceased to be even nominally Trotskyist - never a surrender of the idea that the Stalinist states had to be democratised and transformed. But it was adaptation. It meant adopting the role of ideological satellites of the Stalinist states which embodied. by their existence in "transition" from capitalism to socialism, an expanding post-capitalist world revolution.

Strictly speaking this was not «Trotskyism" . At the time of his death Trotsky laid down different guidelines. At the time of his death he was close to identifying the Stalinist states as a new form of collectivist class society, and said explicitly that if certain things happened - which did in fact happen with the survival and expansion of Stalinism - then there was no alternative but to redefine Stalinism that way (see the articles collected in In Defence of Marxism). If Trotsky had lived and stuck to what he was saying in 1940, he would not have done what the mainstream "Trotskyists" did in the late '40s and after, Trotsky would not have been a post war "Trotskyist" Trotsky's heroic rearguard struggle against continued on page 4

Scan page 4

e slump and fighting bac Socialist Organi VS

----- pull-quotes -----

in August 1940, then Trotskyism, far from bein!

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 531

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →