Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Your worst fears

Socialist Organiser no. 530, 31 July 1992 · scan pp. 10–11 · Paul Cooper · about 748 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

build modern factories of death. Consistently more primitive, they buried people alive, threw them down ravines, drove them into the Syrian desert to die.

It was the first ethnic holocaust of the 20th century. It received amazingly little world attention. If it had receive the attention it deserved, then Hitler might have found it more difficult to mount his own mass slaughter a few years later in which 6 million Jews died.

To this day the Turkish state denies - despite massive evidence - the massacre ever happened!

Enver, a leader of the 'Young Turks'. The Young Turks ruthlessly oppressed minorities. They were responsible for the massacre of the Armenians. Enver proclaimed "We are all equal. We glory in being Ottoman"

Paul Cooper reviews Alien3 Officer: Sergeant! You'd better get down here. There's something in the dog compound.

Sergeant: What is it?

Officer: I don't know, but it's weird and it's pissed off!

That was a scene from John Carpenter's "The Thing", made in the early eighties and much quoted by David Fincher, the director of Alien 3.

Like Carpenter's film, Fincher's has a very weird and pissed-off monster that has a novel way of popping-out for lunch. It eats its way out of your stomach.

Both films use dry humour to contain and balance moments of terror. Fincher's scriptwriters have some perverse moments. Having collided, a child molester and a rapist being chased by the Alien have an argument over the safe way to hold a knife in such situations. It is symptomatic of the film that the humour doesn't really vork.

Alien unremittingly and morbid in its atmosphere.

Ripley (Sigourney Weaver) the heroine of Alien 1 and 2, escorts us through a penal colony composed of murderers, rapists and child molesters, who are only slightly less traumatised by the only woman on the planet than they are by the other Alien who has crashlanded.

Ripley, ignoring orders, goes into their canteen:

Ripley: Do you mind if I sit here?

Prisoner: Lady - I rape and kill women - you're a threat to the brothers... we don't want you here.

Ripley: I guess I must be making you nervous.

She calmly sits and eats. Ripley's character in Alien 3 is probably the strongest depiction of a woman as hero/leader in popular culture. Unlike Alien 2, it makes no concessions to surrogate family values (or does it?)

In the first five minutes of the film both her lover and her "adopted" child (Shrimp from Alien 2) are killed. It's the first of many "rules" that will be broken.

This film, after only two weeks, ha:

collapsed at the box office ir the America, and is not enjoying the success of Alien 1 and Like many sci-fi and horror "Like many sci-fi and horror films, Alien 3 mobilises in the audience deep-seated fears and anxieties about the world and ourselves. In Alien 3 they range across cancer, AIDS, death, science and very topically for Americans, Japan." films, Alien 3 mobilises in the audience deep-seated fears and anxieties about the world and ourselves. In Alien 3 they range across cancer, AIDS, death, science and very topically for Americans, Japan.

There is pleasure in doing this for an audience as long as the anxieties, once mobilised, can be safely resolved by the devices of the story and the fate of characters. Hollywood has strict "rules" about this. This what "formula film" really means.

Aliens 3 breaks and bends the rules too far. The fate of the characters, the ending of the story, the goodness and badness of people, are not resolved for the audience in the way popular film demands.

For example, I still can't make up my mind as to whether the ending was happy or not. I felt uncomfortable, I wanted things sorted out. I was left with something deeply ambiguous instead. Maybe that's good.

The film taps into another deep-rooted fear when it makes is the monster able to make men 'pregnant'. It deposits an egg in the abdomen, then the foetus erupts out of the body -erect and penis-like. Ouch! Films like this may be part of a large genre of horror and sci-fi films in which a patriarchal popular culture tried to find images, symbols and metaphors which help men deal with deep-rooted insecurities to do with masculinity and sexual difference.

Watch carefully the fate of Ripley and the alien in the last third of this film. Be scared!

Scan page 11

Socialist Organiser No. 530 page

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 530

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →