Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

The real fingerman

Socialist Organiser no. 530, 31 July 1992 · scan pp. 9–10 · about 1,135 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 9

PC dated 8.6. 1992 on the London Underground dispute and the debate with Socialist Organiser (SO). Nothing wrong in placing any item on a proposed agenda. But as the SO had the "decency" to phone our national office to warn them of the fact they were going to publish an attack, it would not have been amiss for our National Secretary to discuss this not unimportant development with me.

The Socialist Organiser's rapidly accelerating political degeneration is well known. Our press has correctly noted this and has had a political debate on the issues. In the face of irrefutable facts Socialist Organiser could not effectively defend themselves with the usual bluster and abuse. To insulate their cdes from facts and the real world a counter-attack was necessary.

As a result the Socialist Organiser have launched a systematic campaign of harassment, abuse, personal attacks and physical disruption of our organisation and in particular its trade union work.

In addition to the articles on the LUL dispute, which amount to personalised red-baiting which fingers a well known militant and could materially assist in his victimisation, the Socialist Organiser physically prevented one of our cdes attending a workshop at the recent Socialist Campaign Group Conference and disrupted the business of that workto everybody" approach and fought tooth and nail, together with key independents, to get and keep control of the SMTUC, so as to defeat and marginalise the left-sectarian and propagandistic politics of the Socialist Organiser, We must now ask why our leadership, instead of seeing this factional attack as one from an organisation seeking to smash up our work in the trade unions, wanted to continue to debate with these people and not defend our cdes from this attack in our press.

We must further ask why, having supported the content of the attacks on Cde Westland our leadership then voted to close the debate with the Socialist Organiser in our press but at the same time accept an invitation from them to debate them at their Summer Public Event.

Not only has our press failed to defend our trade union cdes and their work in the class struggle, our leadership has now effectively endorsed the content of the attacks by going to their public event. The attacks on our LUL cdes will continue, because they will know that the official position of our organisation is to agree with them. Why? Because we'll say "don't be so nasty in the way you put it but seeing as you've touched all the right nerve endings of the British far-left, yes we agree he is part of the problem of the historic crisis of leadership and vant passages with Cde Clarke. They were: "The attacks on us in Socialist Organiser No. 525 raise a much more serious issue. A member of the LUL London Transport District Council of the RMT is named as a supporter of Socialist Outlook. The author of this article knows full well that this is tantamount to denouncing this person to management since the author signs her/himself as a "Central Line Guard". And for good reason. In the present atmosphere open identification of alleged political loyalties of militants can have sérious consequences. Socialist Organiser should stop such witch-hunting attacks, and repudiate the "Central Line Guard" for this fingering operation." And:

"Lack of seriousness on trade union issues is reflected in the position taken by Socialist Organiser on the recent Underground dispute. No serious militant thought the proposed strike could have been won in the post-election situation. Whether or not to go ahead with it was an entirely tactical question. For head bangers of the SWP type the issue was simple; for serious militants the balance of forces had to be weighed. Despite all the attacks, the rank and file leadership on LUL has a remarkable record of defending the workforce; only a couple of hundred jobs have gone out of a workforce of more than 20,000 since 1979. This In the dispute on trade union policy on the London Underground, the leaders of Socialist Outlook could agree on nothing except the need for a common front against Socialist Some, like Alan Thornett, agreed with us. Others disagreed with us. All of them hated us. So they took refuge in the smear about us "fingering" Patrick Sikorski.

This reminds me of a little bit of "fingering" - deliberate, spiteful, peevish, real fingering - a few years ago. With the Labour Party witch-hunt in full swing, in 1984, Alan Thornett publicly identified the editor of Socialist Giganiser, John O"Mahony, as "Thomas Carolan", a leading member of the Workers' Socialist League. He thereby identified Socialist Organiser, which was then still a paper of Labour's dwindling hard pressed left wing, as a paper really run by a Trotskyist group.

Naming O'Mahony as Carolan served no purpose for Thornett except "fingering". The impulse was to "expose", "identify" and scandalise O'Mahony as the villain who had opposed Thorett, the self-proclaimed worker leac er" inside the WSL, and to smea SO as widely as possible on the left as the paper of the "bureaucrats" and other villians he was then insisting we were.

As 1 wrote to Thomett in a letti then: "You are a subjective man Mr Thornett, as I learned unplea antly during your period as a contributor to Socialist Organiser.

"Your self-indulgence has turned you into an ammunition boy for the right wing and the Kinnockites as they embark on new drive to witch-hunt the Marxists out of the Labour Party. For example, at the Labour Party conference no less a personage than the [right-wing witch-hunting NEC member] John Golding sidled up to John Bloxam and asked him gleefully, and perhaps threateningly, if he had 'seen Socialist Viewpoint'. "As Trotsky once told another malice-driven man, Martin Abern, personal hatred plays a diabolical role in politics. Or would you, Mr Thornett, dispute that it is 'diabolical' for a supposed Marxist to act the fingerman for the right wing and help them, on the eve of a new round of witch-hunting, to frame up Socialist Organiser and brand it as a publication put out by a democratic-centralist revolutionary organisation? | emphatically protest!"

Matgamna

Scan page 10

Socialist Organiser No. 530 page causi Television A the Armenians"? nd who remembers asked Adolf Hitler, discussing his plans to massacre the Jews of Europe. It was a rhetorical question. He knew the answer.

A mere 20 years after 1915, when the Turks had massacred one and a half million Armenians, there were few who "remembered the Armenians". Hidden History, (BBC, 27 July) did.

The bourgeois revolutionary "Young Turk" reformers decided to wipe out all the Armenian people under Turkish rule so as to make their state "pure" in race ¿ nd secure from disruption by Armenian demands for national rights.

They did not, like Hitler,

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 530

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →