Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

[faction/organisation matters, will say that the right to…]

Socialist Organiser no. 530, 31 July 1992 · scan pp. 8–9 · about 1,567 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 8

faction/organisation matters, will say that the right to self-defence can come before the duty to fight the class struggle honestly and seriously. That, among other things, means not to suppress or distort the truth about incidents and episodes in that struggle, even and especially when you have to be silent about it for a while.

The Underground workers now have to fight the Company Plan. To do so they need clear criticism of the coverups of the District Council leadership. Outlook's attitude amounts to saying that they will go along with it - cover up the cover-up - for the sake of factionalism against SO.

It is a blow against the immediate trade union struggle as well as against Marxist clarity among socialists - clarity without which, as this affair proves once again, the trade union struggle must flounder blindly. They say no news is good news - which might be true about some things, but it's certainly not true about the Company Plan. Just because everything's gone quiet again, it doesn't mean that it's gone away. In fact, rest assured that it's still very much here. Our unions, both RMT and ASLEF, have been meeting with management over the pas: few weeks getting presentations of management's detailed proposals and starting negotiations. We've had the Company Plan hanging over our heads now since inst November. Because of that, there is a danger that "familiarity breeds contempt" - we've all heard how bad the Plan is, what it's going to mean in terms of job cuts, conditions etc etc., but. everything seems to be carrying on as normal. So what's all the fuss about? That's like sieepwalking towards the edge of a Mi?! We need to stay wide awake! We also need to remind ourseives of a few things First off, we need to remind ourselves how Bala bain ubeworker': telling the truth wallowing this book).

A figure of 25 grand for drivers is often shrown about. Two things about this: first, a similar thing happened on British Rail where they've got a "Driver restructuring initiative"

big changes in conditions and agreements un return for a salary increase - the rumour was 20 grand, in fact it tured out to be 13 and a half! The point being. there's no sense, from management's point of view, in saving loads of money in productivity if you just hand it straight back to the same people in big salary The second thing is this: say management offer 25 grand for selling ail our condition would it be worth it? The answer has to be NO! The average driver is on 21 or 22 grand now. For a few grand more. we'd be selling our souls to the Company The Company Plan needs "Company Men" and "Company Women". We've got lives and families and interests outside of the joh b

Scan page 9

in the Underground dispute Tubeworkers have tremendous power: 1989 strikes paralysed London "How Socialist Organiser attacked our trade union work and the Political Committee supported them" up the trut [A discussion document circulated among Socialist Outlook supporters!

Only after Socialist Organiser Tried a major article attacking the orientation of the LUL RMT District Council in the current dispute against the Company Plan, did the PC challenge either the articles carried in our paper or the report made by Cde Westland to the PC itself.

The PC minutes for 26.5.1992 indicate that there was no alternative position put to Cde Westland's report and no resolutions challenging the line or facts of the articles carried in our press. Our concluding piece on the current round of the dispute was in Socialist Outlook No. 21 dated 16 May 1992.

Then without any contact being made with Cde Westland the National Secretary [Alan Thornett, it seems: SO] placed an item on the shop with their screamed abuse just outside the door; disrupted and effectively wrecked our end of NALGO conference contact meeting attended by 30 people and have circulated in the CPSA left a leaflet attacking Cde Jamieson for alleged "undemocratic practices" in the SMTUC and "Unshackle the Unions" Campaign.

These activities cross the bounds of debate and are contrary to the norms of the workers' and socialist movement. They are in the rotten sectarian tradition of Healyism. This campaign will continue up to and including the SMTUC Conference because the Socialist Organiser want to wreck this most successful of all the projects of our organisation. This project gives us a firm base in the mass organisations of the working class - the trade unions. We achieved this because the trade union cdes ignored the "let's be nice

N DEPTH

no longer part of the solution."

This is a severe problem for the organisation because in this period revolutionaries who want to build a base for class struggle in the working class mass organisation - the trade unions - have to both build and strengthen the unions as well as introducing socialist politics. This is contrary to the overwhelming majority traditions of the British far-left which solely concentrate on programmatic interventionism and on denouncing all those who get leadership positions. This will be the subject of a further document for the pre-conference discussion. Initially it was decided at the full PC (8.6.1992) that in order to address the attack on our name as well as continue the debate with Socialist Organiser that Cde Clarke draft a response for inclusion in their press.

Cde Westland discussed the relehas not been achieved by knee-jerk "more-militant-than-thou" policies. I agreed with this.

At the PC on 15.6.1992 the National Secretary announced that the second passage had been withdrawn as a result of a phone call to Paris and a discussion with Cde Clarke. The first passage could stand and individuals would be free to defend themselves personally in a letter to Socialist Organiser. So the terrain was settled. The content of the Socialist Organiser attacks was agreed - only the method was objectionable.

At no point during the rest of the debate did anyone in the PC majority question the underlying assumption and content of the Socialist Organiser attacks ie that we had a case to answer.

The reason is self-evident. If you agree with Clarke's initial position,then there is no case against us and we made no "mistakes". Only if you agree with the deletion, and therefore with Davies' position have we a case to answer because supporters of this position believe that principles were at stake, were breached and that the Socialist Organiser attacks outlined in Socialist Organiser 525 were valid...

Cde Gill [Another Outlook member who works on the Underground and produced an alternative document on the episode] wants to have it both ways. He wants to get the facts right because he has to talk to the serious militants on LUL. But he restates principles in a similar way to someone reminding themselves of the true faith as they pass the church each morning:

"For the record, however, in my view it was probably a wrong tactical decision not to go ahead with a one day strike" and a few lines later:

"It was risky, but the union should have said to the membership - The Company plan is make or break, you voted two to one, result, let's go for it! Even if we lost, as we probably would have, we would have taken the chance to have a go at the Plan and we would have strengthened Organiser democracy For sure we fight for democracy and accountability in the union. For sure we have advocated strike action in the LTDC against every single one of the attacks from management over the last 13 years.

But the demands of this situation are that Cde W is being accused by Socialist Organiser of crossing class lines and selling out.

The demand of this discussion is does Cde W have a case to answer? If he does then there is only one course that is suspension pending a hearing for expulsion.

The case can't be fudged by voting for the general line of Cde Gill's whole assessment and then for each of the individual statements of principle at the end.

The case can only be met by either voting for the assessment which clears Cde W of all the attacks made by Socialist Organiser and then defending him unreservedly as in the original Clarke draft, or voting against the line of Cde Gill's assessment and saying that a strike should have been called because there had been no satisfactory fresh mandate and Cde W was a party to a breach of proletarian principle.

What Cde Davis did was vote for the assessment and then state in his resolution that there has been no proper fresh mandate and therefore a principle had been broken.

It can't be met by voting for the assessment and then voting down the following resolution put by Cde W to the PC.

"No serious militant thought the proposed strike on LUL could have been won in the post election situation."

"Whether to go ahead with it was an entirely tactical question in which the militants had to weight the balance of forces".

The vote was 2 for, 3 against, 5 abstentions, 1 no vote.

Is it credible that six people on the leadership (the majority) were unwilling to come to an assessment?

The position must be reversed. Westland 25.6.92.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 530

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →