Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Dead end factionalism and the class struggle

Socialist Organiser no. 530, 31 July 1992 · scan p. 8 · Sean Matgamna · about 1,620 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 8

why, regular readers Socialist Organiser may (like me) have been wondering, did Socialist Outlook recently take to publishing Gerry Healy level smear attacks on us?

In the ridiculous piece by "Ben Wolfe" (another pseudonym of brave Phil Hearse, I think) in Outlook no.25, for example, to which I replied in the last SO, they accused us of "fingering" a full-time elected union official, Patrick Sikorski, to the bosses of the London Underground.

Unhappy members of Outlook have explained to us exactly what has been going on. In fact, that "fingeing" article was written to paper over major differences inside Outlook about their trade union work, and specifically about recent events on the London Tube.

It seems that the majority of Outlook's Political Committee -including Phil Hearse! - now agree with what SO has been saying about the Tube dispute. A division, and by all accounts a quite bitter one, has developed. On one side are the friends of Carolyn Sikorski, who is secretary of the Socialist Movement Trade Union Committee and also runs Outlook's trade union work. On the other is the majority of the Political Committee.

Carolyn Sikorski was accused by the PC of abusing her powers as Outlook trade union organiser for factional ends after she and others had circulated a document critical of the PC - "How Socialist Organiser attacked our trade union work and the Political Committee supported them" - to Outlook trade union activists.

The document's title tells the story. It accuses the PC of having adopted a critical attitude to Outlook's work on the Tube and in the RMT only after Socialist Organiser had publicly criticised that work. It complains bitterly that the PC merely took up our criticisms.

To placate Carolyn Sikorski and her friends, and to differentiate the PC majority from SO, the Outlook PC decided that they would publish a "reply" to Socialist Organiser's criticisms of what Outlook had done and said on the London Tube.

Given that Outlook were themselves split on the issue, writing a reply to Socialist Organiser would be a tricky job, calling for a literary miracle worker able to make bricks without straw - to find and proclaim distinctions where there are no differences, to discuss without discussing, and to polemicise in such a way that none of the real differences are dealt with.

Phil Hearse knows how to do these things! He, you will recall, wrote a memorable piece on SO a couple of months ago, in which, as I proved in SO, he used invented quotations and lyingly attributed them to SO Hearse went about his work in grim earnest. He had written the earlier piece under a weak and weedy, nontotemic, pseudonym, "Paul Clarke", and had been called a wimp for it. The first thing to do was to get rid of that and - like a Red Indian brave preparing for the warpath - put on a new pseudonym, one fitting the grim earnestness of his task.

Paul Clarke? Bah! Too soft! Not fierce enough! "Ben Wolfe" - son of the wolf - that's better!

Wolf? But wouldn't Leopard or Lion be even better - stronger, braver? "Ubermensch Leopardi"? "Desperate Dan de Leon"? He toys with the possibilities, but finally decides: no, moderation in all things. "Ben Wolfe" it is. That'll teach them to call me a peaceful, plodding, pompous herbivore!

But now he must perform! The first thing is to pack the article with abuse and repetitions of stuff we had answered already, like the nonsense about SO supporting Boris Yeltsin and positively wanting capitalism in Russia. He can fill much of the page with this dialogue-of-the-dead jeering and heresy-hunting. But, after all, he must eventually cover the London Underground affair. What can he say about that?

At first he wrote a piece which tried to defend Outlook's real line on the Underground. After objections from, it seems, Alan Thornett, and phone calls "to Paris", the paragraph defending the real line was cut from Hearse's article. Now what can he do?

He can't just go straight down the line and flatly deny the facts of what happened on the Underground, can he? At best he can try to confuse things a little by telling the reader that District Council secretary Patrick Sikorski advocated strike action at an early stage in the affair, and accusing SO of suppressing the fact. That was at a small committee meeting, and at the bigger, later, decisive meeting of the District Council on 28 May, Patrick Sikorski did the opposite.* Hearse makes the best of that, lying by omission. But the advocate is in an impossible position. He dare not tell the truth about what happened, or express his own opinion. He must brand the truth - what he knows to be true, and what he assesses as we assess it - as lies. Going on about Yeltsin is no solution.

But now Philip Ben Wolfe, master of the vulpine philippic, has a brain wave, or rather a flash of memory. He remembers the days when hordes of young Healyites would corner an IMGer like himself and demand "answers" about the latest pseudoscandal that Healy had concocted. Why, they would ask, did Ernest Mandel back the Stalinists in Hungary in 1956? Why did Joe Hansen help poison Trotsky and then hide his death-mask for 30 years?

Why did Livio Maitan kick an inoffensive French poodle off the sidewalk last time he was in Montreal? Why did Tariq Ali give such miserable tips to the hard-pressed waiters at the Ritz?

Those were the "burning questions of the hour". We want answers, comrade! Philip, when he was a wolf cub, might have wanted to discuss Cuba, or the Healyites' sources of money, or their attitude to the British labour movement. Some hope, in face of the dozens of charges the Healyite youth would parrot at him: scab, capitulator to imperialism, anti-communist, agent of capitalism, and, yes, fingerman for the right wing!

That's it! SO fingered Patrick Sikorski! Of course they did. They mentioned him, didn't they?

That's the way to stop discussion about what the RMT District Council leadership did! That's the way to unite Outlook, those who agree with SO and those who support the District Council leadership. The issue, comrades, is not the strike, it is "fingering". Gerry Healy knew a thing or two!

But he did not, comrades of Socialist Outlook, know how to build a serious Marxist organisation.

Of course, the big scandal in this. affair, according to every key idea of Trotskyist politics, is the behaviour of the Outlook majority leadership. They would have a right to keep silent about the Underground affair for the moment, provided they set about sorting it out internally. They would, I suppose, have had a right to express their general solidarity with their RMT fraction by praising them in general.

But they do not have the right - not while politics is something higher than the noise made by grunting supporters of competing rugby teams - to cover for their mistakes in the RMT. They do not have the right to publicly misrepresent the issues. They do not have the right to lyingly, or half-lyingly, misrepresent their own opinion on the matter in the way that Phil Hearse, writing on behalf of the PC, does.

They do not have the right to abuse, misrepresent, and try to smear SO for saying things which they themselves believe to be true about the Underground dispute.

Nobody but a political child or a hypocrite will say they do not have the right to defend themselves against the criticisms of a competing organisation; and nobody but a hopeless dead-end factionalist, for whom nothing but the one majority for strike action against the devastating "Company Plan", is therefore very important.

Yet we have found ourselves involved in the very worst sort of controversy - one with disloyal and unserious opponents.

We criticised what some of their trade union comrades did and said during an important class struggle experience. They might have replied by telling us that we had got these or those facts wrong and therefore had misreported or misrepresented what they did and said. They might - admitting that our reports were true - have "Instead of eliscussing the roasons why their comrades did what they did, the leaders of Outlook tried - to put it in blum English - to lie, or half-lie, abor what hapesred. They did not deny it boldly. They quibbled."

do what some of them did. also refused to defend them. Nor selves in the pages of Outlook.

No. 5 17 July 1992 their performance - was what worried them then they would not have drawn extra attention to it, five weeks after our comments appeared. They would have told us of their concern, knowing we would try to respect their worries.

In fact Outlook's leaders behave like this because they agree with us on the issue! They go for the Healy-style pseudo scandal because the alternative is to say they share our viewpoint.

In all this nonsense the viewpoint of one group of Outlook supporters has gone unheard - those who aamır wnar nappened on tne Underground and want to defend what they did there. To get their viewpoint you have to go to bulletins given a limited circulation amongst Outlook supporters.

On this page you will find one such document, abridged.

In it things are said about "Organiser" supporters which are not true. Some of the things referred to are completely "wrecking" a meeting; a verbal is "politically correct", and ate to the point of lying with a Socialist Organiser's Central Line bulletin

----- pull-quotes -----

AGAINSIT THE TIDE

is bad news bad

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 530

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →