Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

The saving and improving of life

Socialist Organiser no. 530, 31 July 1992 · scan pp. 4–5 · Vicki Morris · about 521 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 4

'm uneasy about Rebecca Van Homan (Women's Eye, SO 529) upholding the right of a 16 year old to starve herself to death free from the interference of parents and state.

The right to kill yourself seems to me way down on the list of democratic freedoms still to be won in bourgeois society. It is a qualitatively different thing altogether, not in the realm of "rights" at all.

We would all intervene in someone's suicide to the extent of trying to change their mind by talking them out of it. Then, having failer how many of us would just sit on our hands while they flashed a broken bottle across their wrists?

Of course, it takes more than a well-intentioned indi vidual to force-feed an anorexic • health authoritie state, but here they do the "right" thing, even while they also, in other matters, do the bourgeoisie's dirty work.

There are many grey areas here. An anorexic falls into a coma at some point and the health service, if they can get there in time, rush them to "We need laws to help make the lives of 16 year olds freer and more enjoyable, regardless of the "imposition' of ne being allowed to kill yourself."

hospital and save thei The anorexic won't b friends, or the state for intervening to save their lives. Descending further down the slippery slope of authoritarianism? If you can make a law saying 16 year olds have no right to starve themselves, you can also make laws. which give 16 year olds more rights: the right to a decent wage if they work, a grant if they study, the vote, the righi to abortion and contraception etc. These are rights worth fighting for: if we win them there will be far fewer desperate young people.

In other words, you must separate legislation into sorts of legislation. I think the law about 16 year olds not being able to starve themselves is not "a law about being sixteen". This law about saving lives is a law about humans, about society and collective responsibilities. That it doesn't extend to people over 18 is more to do with the fac that, once you get to the age -sink or swim.

I don't know much about ethics but I'm sure this isn't just "bourgeois"! It would still be a live issue under socialism. We would be making rules that "imposed" on people in this fashion even then. Laws made now have a class character, but they are not completely inhuman, nor are they wholly based on the needs of the ruling class.

We need laws to help make the lives of 16 year olds freer and more enjoyable, regardless of the imposition" of not being allowed to kill yourself.

There is some piece of old folk wisdom that says: if you save someone's life, you are responsible for their well being ever afterwards. 1 would argue for saving people's lives and for redoublin the efforts we, as socialists, already make, to improve those lives in the here and noW.

Scan page 5

H AFRICA Socialist Organiser No. 530 page 5

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 530

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →