Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Tube strike cal Tube strike called off Outlook May

Socialist Organiser no. 529, 16 July 1992 · scan pp. 14–15 · Sean Matgamna · about 3,328 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 14 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 14

30: talks of the legitimate criticism from the left

The principal cul for this posi- mass meetings in the lead up to the on are the national time officials ballot they had told their members id the right wing malerk of the that they would ballot with the RMT.

Rv Sean Matnamna

Patrick Sikorski has been a very prominent elected full-time union official on the London Underground for some years now.

He is well known to be, or to have been, a supporter of the tendency that publishes Socialist Outlook. He still writes in the left press under his own name (in Briefing for April 1991, for example, where his trade union credentials and identity were given in full).

It is odd, therefore, to find the latest Socialist Outlook accusing us of having "fingered" Sikorski to the Underground bosses when in the course of criticising his activity in the union we identified him as an Outlook supporter.

In the highly improbable event that our articles inspired the Underground bosses to try to sack an elected union official, Sikorski would have had little difficulty, other things being equal, in denying and shrugging off our ascription of Outlook membership to him.

He would have found it a lot easier to shrug it off before Outlook, some five weeks after our articles appeared, came to his "defence" with the cry that he had been "fingered" - that is, in the word's usual meaning, that he had been accurately identified!

Their "defence" of Sikorski is something like an official acknowledgement by Outlook itself!

The Outlook article is clear evidence that it is not Sikorski's "security" which really concerns Outlook. If that was their concern, then they would not repeat and compound the fault - "fingering" Sikorski - which they ascribe to us, just in order to make a polemical point, or rather a polemical smear, against us. They would not use Sikorski's security as so much sand to fling in the eyes of Outlook readers, in order to distract attention from our criticism of Sikorski's activities and of Outlook's responsibility for them.

Sikorski is an elected union full-timer, not a rank-and-file militant. He should be publicly accountable to his members, and to the left. When Outlook tries to shield him from left-wing criticism on the grounds that to tag him for the hard left will get him the sack, the question arises: where has Outlook in its general industrial reporting told its readers that Underground workers live under such a reign of terror that even a full-time union official can be casually dismissed? They have not told Outlook readers about it because it is not true. The picture they present is hysterically exaggerated.

Rail and Underground militants do have to be careful. Since the late '80s, they can get sacked for writing articles criticising the company on issues like safety. But the Underground bosses are not going to try to sack a full-time union official - and one who toed a moderate line during the recent argument on striking against the Company Plan! -unless they want a full-scale showdown with the union; and if they want that, they will not be spurred forward or held back by what Socialist Organiser says.

Yes, our regular writer on the Underground chooses to sign himself *Central Line guard". Another of our comrades, an elected official outside London in a position similar to Sikorski's, regularly signs his articles in SO with his name.

This demagogic polemic is pure Outlook! They equate "security" for a rank and file tubeworker writing in SO -which also, incidentally, publishes an SO industrial bulletin on the Tube, while Outlook publishes no bulletin -with security for Sikorski, a very visible trade union official!

The clumsy, clodhopping, trippingover-their-own-feet performance is typical of Outlook, who here try to mount a Healyite-style smear operation. and for the typical Healvite reason of avoiding the issue.

Pete Williams Pete Williams THE NATIONAL Executive of the RMT has called off strike action against London Underground's Company Plan.

The settiement commits the management to negotiate any changes through the existing agreed machinery.

Management threats to cancerthe 1956 Machinery from June this year, and to impose a new one with or without the agreement of the seven UL unions, have been withdrawn The document contains an explicit instruction to all managers to adhere tic to the machinery otherwise they will Healy would have done it with fire and force, and Outlook does it in the style of a clumsy actor playing a set role he can not measure up to. Sand-in-theeye" dishonesty is common to both, however.

The article fills a page of Outlook with flak like the "fingering" nonsense, but the point of it is the Sikorski affair.

What did we say about Sikorski? After RMT members on the Underground had voted two-to-one for strike action against the Company Plan:

"At the April District Council of the RMT Pat Sikorski, a prominent Outlook supporter, and full-time District Council secretary, argued strongly in favour of going back to management to ask for negotiations. He reasoned that socialists aren't opposed to negotiations... and that it would give us time to build for the strike™.

Socialist Outlook of 16 May, however, agued that "talks with employers became unavoidable" because management had sent a letter to all workers offering to negotiate within existing "Whatever Sikorski may have felt bound to do by District Council executive discipline, whatever the rights and wrongs of that, it can not justify Outlook endorsing the decision to go for negotiations and giving it a left gloss by militant talk of unofficial and illegal strike action after the mandate for an official and legal strike had been thrown away!"

machinery and to keep the Promotion Transfer and Redundancy agreement, including the principle of seniority.

The problem is that the District Council met on 28 April, while the letter was not issued until 7 May. In any case, the letter sets out a new PT&R agreement without seniority, and insists management will 'discuss implementation", not negotiation...

The next thing that happened is that management did offer negotiations, and no more, to which the RMT National Executive responded by dropping the strike.

At the May District Council, Patrick Sikorski argued that on a "mature assessment of the balance of forces" it had been correct to call off the strike (no mention is made of this in Socialist Outlook), and that we had in fact won a victory in the ballot for strike action...

Outlook of 30 May ends its article: "when management come back demanding more changes only unofficial action that breaks the law will be effective".

And who's going to be capable of organising that action: the District Council leadership, "who threw away a two-to-one majority that united all RMT grades, or rank and file tubeworkers united across unions and grades?" (SO 525, 4 Knapp-only following orders June).

Amidst all the flak, the substance of Outlook's reply is this - eight and a half lines of their four-column full page! I quote them in full.

[The SO articles] *are based on a falsehood: the accusation that Sikorski vigorously supported the calling off of the strike. No mention is made of the fact that at the crucial District Council meeting of 12 May Sikorski was one of the minority of four people who argued that the strike should go ahead". •Probably the key word in this passage is the word "vigorously". That, I think, is a coded way to convey the idea that Sikorski did what he did reluctantly, or under union discipline.

For the uninitiated, for those who will not read the article for encoded messages, their sole reply is in the assertion that on 12 May Sikorski argued that the strike should go ahead. But bourgeois justice has a useful formula in matters like this: you should tell "the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth". Even if what Outlook says about 12 May is true, is it the whole truth? No, it is not!

The "District Council" meeting on 12 May was not a full District Council meeting, but a meeting of the District Council executive. If Sikorski did argue as Outlook says he did on 12 May, it was in a small élite meeting. Outside that meeting he was either silent, or argued very differently.

By 28 May, at a full District Council meeting, Sikorski was arguing, and very vigorously, so I'm told, for calling off the strike. Other executive members spoke for the strike, so "discipline" can not be the full explanation for Sikorski's role.

What happened between 12 May and 28 May? Did Sikorski change his mind? The issues need to be discussed honestly and openly. Lying about what happened and why will help no-one, and educate no-one.

But whatever Sikorski may have felt bound to do by District Council executive discipline, and whatever the rights and wrongs of that, it can not justify Outlook endorsing the decision to go for negotiations and giving it a left gloss by militant talk of unofficial and illegal strike action after the mandate for an official and legal strike had been thrown And it is very strange to find the Outlook organisation coming out in political solidarity with Sikorski when that organisation has Alan Thornett in its central leadership - a man who has hitherto, for decades, denounced trade union bureaucrats - too one-sidedly, in my view - almost as if they are a fully-fledged alien class.

There is more - and worse, far worse. The same issue of Outlook which indignantly and rather hysterically - and yet, when you probe, unconvincingly -refutes SO's account of Sikorski sharing responsibility for the District Council climb-down, also prints a letter from 17 members of the RMT. A few are politially with Outlook, others are Morning Star. It is, evidently, a solicited letter -and a very curious one. lostby 18 votes to 2. Had a ballot been mailed in that it haus an a much bigger Yes' vote than the 2 to majority registered after Labour's disastrous election defeat More importantly there would have been a chance of saving the Depot Foreman's grade, which has now gone. Due to the fatal delay, the workers involved were forced to sign new contracts while the balloting was still taking placi Cricial also was fast minute umaround by the tull time officials o tie engineering Conted LAHORS:

La they used refu sal by

Outlook May

aikswotl ranl SHO#U

LI MẤH DMESD werther mens or thew phe rondc Lancian fransman Abtect Oema IORG CUFFR4 pipis MURID RMT members other than nen accepting the Natrim Executive Cecsi0a "It has come to our notice". , write the 17, "that in Socialist Organiser the RMT London Transport District Council and its Secretary Pat Sikorski has come under sustained attack. This attack is disgraceful. We the undersigned members of the RMT consider it as red baiting, which aids management's ability to victimise those involved. It must stop at once. We fully support the record of the District Council".

Exactly what "it" is which they "consıder as red baiting" which will aid "management's ability to victimise those involved", is not clear. Plainly, however, they cannot be just talking about Sikorski, or about SO having linked Sikorski to Outlook. They themselves are brave enough to have their names appear in association with the defence of Outlook, so they are probably not people who go daily in fear of the sack for their politics. (And neither, of course, is Patrick Sikorski!

The key to understanding what is going on is the last sentence: the 17 "support the record of the District Council". Here we have something very strange.

On page 11 Outlook denounces us for saying that Sikorski shared responsibility for the recent misleadership by the District Council; on page 14 it publishes "Comrades, it is not red-baiting to criticise Sikorski.

help poison the labour movement, and line up with a foul line of trade union bureaucrats using demagogy and witch-hunting to stop the mouth of the left and the rank an file."

a solicited letter, signed by some of own people, endorsing the record that same District Council!

They have it both ways. It is not surprising that the 17 stand by the District Council's record: everyone signing the letter who has any connection with the London Underground is either on on the District Council executive or is an ex-officio member of it!

When Outlook raises the cry of "fingering", it is a comic turn by people who fall into the Healyite big boots they try to kick us with. The cry of "fingering" from them is just no-count lamebrain polemic. But when the local leadership of a trade union - or a big part of it, in their "personal capacity" — reply to criticism from the left of the way they treat the rank and file of the union with the charge of "red-baiting" , then we have left Outlook's world of inconsequential play-acting and arrived at an altogether more serious place.

To criticise the executive, they say in Outlook and at Outlook's invitation, is to attack the union. The executive majority is the union! trade union office-holders fending off trade union office-holders fending legitimate criticism from the left with the cry — if you criticise us you are helping the bosses! If you criticise us, you are red-baiters!

No, comrades of the RMT London Transport District Council, it is not red-baiting to criticise either you or Sikorski. If you respond to such criticisms in this way, you help poison the labour movement, and line up with a long and foul line of trade union bureaucrats using demagogy and witch-hunting to stop the mouths of the left and the rank and file. Here, Outlook links arms with people incumbent trade union officials -who will, if they continue in this vein, wind up stifling the left, as to a serious extent they recently stifled the rank and file. And who is to say that Outlook also will not be guilty of "red-baiting" and "aiding management" should it ever nerve itself to sharply criticise the District Council - or Patrick Sikorski?

The Morning Star people are the "good" Pers now, those who retain some connection with the labour movement, but we should not forget that they are also the people whose organisation has staffed big sectors of the trade union bureaucracy for many decades past.

The logic is clear. Sikorski does indefensible things - for whatever motive, maybe executive committee discipline -but Outlook defends him with factional solidarity (and factional hatred of us, his critics). They wind up defending or halfdefending the District Council when it is in the wrong: Outlook and the District Council leadership converge, swapping arguments and trading flak, including the "fingering" and "red-baiting' charges, which in the mouth of Outlook are a joke, but which become something altogether more serious coming from the trade union officials. Outlook solicits and publishes the letter - without comment, obviously feeling hard-pressed and glad of any support.

I put a question to Outlook. They should answer it plainly and clearly: are you for or against what the District Council did? Yes or no?

P.S. At a recent meeting of the Socialist Movement Trade Union Committee, Patrick Sikorski had to be verbally "restrained" by the chair - so I'm told - to the obvious embarrassment of other Outlook people present, when someone proposed a discussion of the Company Plan at their forthcoming conference. That episode is not at all out of keeping with the increasing recklessness and violence, and underlying hysteria, of Outlook's polemics.

Their polemics are Healyite. The latest is worse in that respect than the one I replied to recently. The last thing they want is to take up what we really say and really do and discuss it, or really reply to what we really say against them. 1 proved some weeks ago that Phil Hearse invented "quotations" and lied that they were from SO. They still have not a thing to say about that.

They prefer the Healy technique -scandal-mongering, heresy-hunting and denouncing as froma pulpit; the substitution of pseudo debate about trivia and concocted "issues" for real debate about the real differences; scandalous lack of scruples. Alan Thornett and what is left of his old friendship network never knew any better: this is always their "method"- under pressure. The old Mandelites see much of their political world collapse with the debacle of Stalinism and they feel it.

A new synthesis seems to be forming between the half-reconstructed exHealyite and the traumatised Mandelites. Healyite techniques seem to be the easy option as they once did for Healy and Lambert. That is where these ridiculous polemics come from, with their psudo-scandals and all too real refusal to engage with the real difterences.

Last time I dealt with Outlook I promised to come back to the subject in the next SO, and didn't. This time I

Scan page 15

By a DOE civil servant day. On Wednesday we will not political pressure must be kep y a clear majority, • NUCPS/CPSA member:

working in the Departments of Environment and Transport HQs, have voted for a one-day strike on Wednesday 15 July, in protest against the forcible relocation of staff to Docklands.

Although the turnout wasn't as great as we had hoped, both Unions feel confident that we will get a solid turnout on the day. On Wednesday we will ne only picket the HQ buildings, but we will hold a rally and a lobby of Parliament. The day of the strike coincides with Environment Question Time and we expect the governmen to make an announcement about the relocation.

Although we are at present running around making last minute preparations for the strike, at the back of everybody's minds is the question, what's next? Certainly the political pressure must be kepi up. The government's claim that the move is 'value for money' doesn't hold water. There are numerous empty government buildings in Central London, which could hous the HQ staff. If Labour had their wits about them, they could prove that the Ministers had been misleading Parliament, expose the moves as a backdoor method of financing the Tories' developer friends. However, even in this narrowest of tests of 'bourgeois democratic' political competence, Labour can't get its act together.

On the industrial action front, we have to honestly tell members that further and much greater action will be needed if the relocation is to prevented. At present, the national union officials are thinking about selective action with a possible work to rule, but all that will depend, as far as they are concerned, on the turnout on Wednesday. Therefore it is vital that we get as many people out as possible.

sought to defend "Parliamentary ollowing a 2-1 ballot majorty, Scottish Office NUCPS anc CPSA members struck last Fri day against the targeting of some 3,000 jobs for contracting-out. This is the first serious action against the Tories' plans to smash up civil service jobs, pay and conditions since the publication of "Competing for Quality". " It provides a good opportunity for arguing amongst rank and file members throughout the civil service and across the unions for national action to stop mass contracting-out rather than leaving individual sections to fight alone or - worse still - bid for Her contractina-out their own jobs.

It is clear that, in many areas of the civil service, members are still not aware that the old concept of a job for life' (in large measure true for mainstream white-collar workers) is now a thing of the past.

The different national unions ought to be organising frequent mass meetings to explain the Tories' plans to cut our jobs, shifting what remains to private contractors on dreadful conditions. In the predictable absence of such action, each departmental committee and branch should organise such meetings.

----- pull-quotes -----

If you respond to such criticisms in this way, you

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 529

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →