Fight for workers' liberty!
Socialist Organiser1992 1992-07-16Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 12 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 12
Roberts have a friend, a man in his sixties, who was in the Communist Party until the 1960s. He always remained convinced of the "socialism" of the Soviet Union. He was especially convinced by his elder and late brother, a very active member of the CP, a working class Dubliner who went to Moscow in the early 'thirties to receive his political education. A member of the Connolly Brigade, the Irish wing of the International Brigade, he laid his lite on the line in the Spanish Civil War. After the war, he remained an active trade unionist until his death My friend's political vision was shaped by the CP, by his brother, by Stalinism. As the Stalinist states unravelled, so did his political understanding of the world. At first he reacted with anger; not with himself or with the Stalinist regimes, but with those tearing the regimes down. On one occasion, he proclaimed that they deserved to be blighted with fascism, not appreciating how the subject peoples equated fascism and Stalinism. Then he fell into despondency.
The story of my friend and his brother encapsulates a great political and social tragedy spreading over decades. In the 1920s and 1930s, the millions of Communist workers, would-be revolutionaries, were miseducated and misled into terrible defeats. In the 1930s and 1940s, thousands of young people - often young college students - poured into the Communist Parties to fight fascism and militarism and had their idealism twisted, turned into something rotten.
"The political and social capital of generations who wanted to transform the world was expended in the service of stinking, rotten. Stalinist states. So the Alliance for Workers' Libert celebrates the collapse of the Stalinist states. It is a good thing."
The political and social capital of generations who wanted to transform the world was expended in the service of stinking, rotten, Stalinist states. So the Alliance for Workers' Liberty celebrates the collapse of the Stalinist states. It is a good thing. But, comrades, the legacy of Stalinism has exacted a terrible price. It has robbed the workers of Eastern Europe of the language, symbols and vision of socialism. Things which have one meaning for us have another meaning for our brothers and sisters in the East. The Red Flag is virtually and The Alliance for Workers' Liberty event, Ideas for Freedom, held in north London from 3-5 July was a great success. A large number of youth attended Ideas for Freedom which helped to make the sessions lively.
Mied or ellen bonductines number of debates.
Oneraborth ornes pillaterand books were sold and 10 comrades joined the AWL. The collection for the work of the AWL and our paper Saçiälin Ougavrsernna cash and a further t1,200 in pledges. understandably seen as the flag of fascism. The statues of Lenin are torn down - and rightly so - as the icons of the hated regimes.
The ideas of socialism have been corrupted and corroded throughout the world.
Whole sections of the different national labour movements - those sections which had illusions in the Stalinist states - have been depressed by their collapse.
And those movements have shifted further to the right, enabling Kinnock in this country to argue that socialism doesn't work, that capitalism can only be ameliorated.
It is not surprising that, in this situation, the bourgeoisie proclaims its victory and the death of socialism in an ideological onslaught, not on the Stalinists who are departing the scene but on those who have no political or moral responsibility for Stalinism and who still wish to fight for a better world. They hope to nail us to the floor, to prevent us ever again rising in challenge.
But the bourgeoisie proclaims its victory as marketisation smashes the living standards of the East European working class and as the rising tide of racism and chauvinism turns parts of the world into a slaughterhouse of peoples.
They proclaim their moral superiority while somebody dies of hunger every minute of every day; while the homeless children of Brazil are hunted and shot down; as the United States is shaken by the rioting of the oppressed and exploited; while 4 million languish unemployed in Britain and the homeless swell our streets.
This daily reality of class exploitation, of the market and of class struggle, points to the irreplaceable role and fundamental duty of the Alliance for Workers' Liberty: to reclaim and review the bedrock ideas of socialism from the decades of corruption; to develop a working class political programme which presents a critique of this world from the perspective of the exploited; a vision of the future world grounded in the productive potential of humanity and working class solidarity; and which identifies the steps necessary to bridge the gap between this world and our vision.
Building the Alliance for Workers' Liberty is not about "building the party' in the manner of the SWP, as if that is a magical chant which can change society. It is about giving life to this political programme, forging the political leadership the working class needs if it is to cease being the raw material of exploitation.
his we have begun to do. The Alliance for Workers' Liberty has been unique in challenging the dogmas and Stalinist influences on the left: on the national question - where the left sides with the 'good nationalism', we have restored the Marxist programme of national reconciliation and working class unity.
"The Alliance for Workers Liberty has challenged Stalinist influences on the left: on the national question, the Stalinist roots of left anti-semitism, the nature of Stalinism... We have identified anew the We have identified the Stalinist roots of left anti-semitism. We have tried to force the left to re-examine the nature of Stalinism, challenging for example - without much success - Socialist Outlook to debate us, to reappraise their understanding of Stalinism.
And we have identified anew the centrality of workers' liberty, as opposed to statism, in our socialism.
The Alliance for Workers' Liberty is unique in its democracy and debate; in promoting internal discussion and providing space for its competitors and opponents in our papers and meetings. The Alliance for Workers' Liberty does not seek to wall its supporters off from the ideas of others - as Militant does - but to win them on the basis of our ideas, developing them as thinking Marxists capable of providing leadership in all struggles and at all levels.
We are not scholars. We wish to change the world in accordance with our ideas.
Thus the Alliance for Workers' Liberty brought together for the first time the anti-Stalinist socialists of East Germany, Hungary and Poland to discuss their common problems and tasks. From the start, we identified how Gorbachev's reforms would create space for the Soviet working class and so fought for British labour movement solidarity with the socialists and genuine trade unionists of Eastern Europe.
We have sought to remodel the British labour movement, never running away from its political wing in the manner of the SWP. Despite now being persecuted, we will not turn away from the Labour Party in the sectarian manner of the Militant. We will fight in the '90s, as in the '80s, for the political and organisational remodelling of the labour movement, a task even more urgent with a fourth Tory victory. Brocas had been greater Many of you ut, comrades, our work would have forces had been greater. Many of you here are not members of the Alliance for Workers' Liberty. I would appeal to you to join us.
In doing so, 1 would like to read to you the last part of Trotsky's "Testament", written shortly before his murder by a Stalinist agent: "Natasha has come up to the window from the courtyard and opened it wider so that the air may enter more freely into my room. I can see the bright green strip of grass beneath the wall, and the clear blue sky above the wall, and sunlight everywhere. Life is beautiful. Let the future generations cleanse it of all evil, oppression and violence, and enjoy it to the full".
Comrades, join the Alliance for Workers" Liberty and help us cleanse the world.
This speech was delivered at the close of the Alliance for Workers' Liberty rally at the end of Ideas for Freedom.
Scan page 13
Batman II is called "Batman Returns". It should be called "The coming of world, caricatured, with the soft bits and the official hypocrisies and Catwoman". Whereas Batman I showed us how "millionaire playboy democratic myths faded out. Power is muscle, hardware and money; Bruce Wayne" became Batman, Batman II shows us how Selina Kyle politics is theatre in which the powerful perform for a mindless, becomes Catwoman. Michelle Pfeiffer steals the show. sometimes fickle mob who, most of the time, buy what the powerful wan This is a Hollywood multi-million concoction. Its main "value" or The Penguin (Danny De Vito), looking like Humpty-Dumpty badly put The story is a mess of broken threads and loose ends, but this film back together again and dressed up to play the villain in a Victorian melodrama, stands for Mayor. The scene where he is presented to the It shows a closed-in nightmare world peopled by freaks and credulous citizens by the capitalist "prince' is a mix of agitprop theatre and dack creatures of the subconscious. Yet it is recognisably and Richard the Third. Crude caricature, but not more than caricature. attraction is soft-porn sado-masochism.
think, better than the first. them to believe.
Orga ccusations of unruly A behaviour and bowlers tampering with the ballwhat's going on? Yes, you've guessed it, England are having a cricket series.
In the first incident, the Pakistan bowler, Agib Javed was fined £150 and the captain, Javed Miandad, reprimanded for showing dissent. To me, it looked like six of one and half-a-dozen of the other. The bowler and umpire had obviously wound each other up but it wasn't that serious. evertheless, we were then bombarded with lectures about "respecting the umpire', 'disgraceful behaviour etc. The well-known commentator, Richie Benaud, complained that the fine was paltry and didn't go far enough.
I have seen worse things on a cricket pitch. There was an occasion when a captain stood shaking his finger at the umpire and had to be dragged away by a team-mate. The microphone picked up a few uncricketing words as well. Yet there weren't many calls for harsh punishment from the press. Indeed, when the team got back they got £1,000
----- pull-quotes -----
centrality of workers liberty. as opposed to statism, in our socialism."
t's not cricket