"The incredible arrogance of bogus radicals
Socialist Organiser1992 1992-07-16Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 11 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 11
group to give them more control.
new and unexpected conditions of a post-war world dominated by capitalist stabilisation and growth, and by Stalinist expansion in the more backward parts of the world.
In his analysis of the USSR and of East Europe and China, and in the early editions of the International Socialism magazine (after 1960), he had tried to tackle some of this work. What went wrong?
What went wrong ultimately was that he lost heart and lapsed back into the sort of caricature "Leninism" he then despised. What went wrong also was the quality of Cliff's theoretical work, and Cliff's hints-and-half-thoughts method of work. Cliff uses statistics and quotes like a Stalinist to back up a preconceived thesis or objective. Thus, when he decided "By 1967, when the youth upsurge was already under way, the Labour Party left had collapsed. IS pulled out of the Labour Party. raggedly. Cliff, who used ideas as buttresses and ings from people like the present writer. How or why he changed his mind remained a close secret. All the observer could know was that Cliff, the scourge of "toy town Bolshevism". , had switched tracks "back to Lenin".
Cliff's attempt in the 1950s and '60s to reanalyse reality led not to disciplined constructive development, or enhancement of the traditions or positions the Socialist Review group started out with in 1950, but to the group's decay and disintegration both politically and organisationally in the 1950s, and then, in the 1960s, to incoherent political and organisational zigzags. Cliff the "Bolshevik" found himself at the centre of a middle-class academic-student discussion club trained in anti-Leninism; then in 1968 he took a flying leap backwards, declared himself to be a Leninist again and set about restructuring the organisation on centralist lines.
The group had grown rapidly in the mid-'60s, recruiting vaguely libertarian youth. It started a turn to the working class in 1965 around a pamphlet on the Labour government's incomes policy written by Colin Barker and Tony Cliff. Then came the youth revolt, necessary rationalisation. He wrote articles for their paper (renamed Socialist Worker, having been Labour Worker since 1962) proving that Labour had never been socialist in the first place! As if that was ever the reason why Trotskyists were in it! Keir Hardie, he now discovered, was a fake.
The decisive change governing all the changes in the group, and probably spurring Cliffs re-thinking, was the astonishing political suicide of the Healy SLL, which had overshadowed IS and against which much of IS's antiBolshevism was directed. In the late 1960s the SLL started to go mad.
It responded to the big anti-Vietnam war demonstration in October 1968, at which there were over 100,000 people, with a leaflet which explained "Why the SLL is not marching". The march, it said, was a conspiracy set up by the capitalist press to boost the prestige of the march's organisers on the left at the expense of the great Marxist leaders of the SLL.
The Socialist Workers Party Militant's little adventure in the Walton by-election last year.
They issued an "open letter to the left", insisting that Militant's candidacy in Walton was now the main touchstone for left-wing politics: if you back Militant, then you are left; if you back the Labour Party then you are a traitor and a scab!
Much of the early part of last year's SWP summer school ("Marxism '91") was given over to denunciations of Socialist Organiser for backing the Labour Party. SO is no longer socialist bu *right-wingers no better than the Tories", many speakers said. As SWP junior guru, Alex Callinicos put it in a meeting on "imperialism" , after an SO speaker made a point: "How can you talk about imperialism when you back Labour in Walton?"
Instead of teaching people that the only way to defeat Kinnockism is to win the fight for socialism within the trade unions The possibilities for growth facing IS, already now having some hundreds of members, mainly young enthusiastic middle class people, were dazzling in these circumstances.
The barrier to growth was the loose, messy federalist organisation built by people educated by Cliff to equate any centralised small revolutionary group with "toy-town Bolshevism" and "substitutionism" . That now stood in Cliff's way. But not for long!
Early in 1968 Cliff and his close friends came out for "Leninism", and conducted a campaign that lasted for the rest of the year to "centralise" IS. It was an astonishing change.
The "de-fusion" conference of 4 December 1971 was the culmination of a long process of "tightening up" the IS group. The organisation was growing, the class struggle was burgeoning. A stroppy democratic organisation inhibited the leadership, and constricted its room to manoeuvre. So Cliff and his friends began to substitute themselves and the leading committee for the organisation.
Today the SWP has one central answer to more or less every question posed in politics: "build the Leninist revolutionary party" must seem strange to anyone familiar only with the present-day SWP to read documents from the 1960s criticising the Cliff tendency for its longstanding anti-Leninism.
and the Labour Party, the SWP demagogically exploits their lack of knowledge of the history of the labour movement.
The SWP twins with the Kinnockites as a double act: the SWP works to persuade socialists to give up on the only existing working class political mass movement, while the Kinnockites work to force them out.
There was a time when the SWP (then called International Socialists) aspired to be serious Marxists inside the real labour movement. An editorial (by Paul Foot) in Socialist Worker (then called Labour Worker) in January 1966 argued - under the head-_ line, "The incredible arrogance o bogus radicals" — against the decision of Richard Gott to stand in the upcoming Hull by-election as a protest against the Labour government's complicity with US action in the Vietnam war.
Going a bit over the top, it described Gott as a "scab" for risking letting in the Tory!
Yet those criticisms are central to any explanation of the evolution of the group after it declared itself Leninist. As the document proves, and as the subsequent his"They did not know what a Leninist party was then any more than they had known what it was in all the sect with Leninism and denounced Leninists as 'toytown Bolsheviks"."
tory also proves, in 1968 Cliff and company did not in fact set about building a Leninist party, but merely creating a centralised small political machine. They did not know what a Leninist party was then any more than they had known what it was in all the preceding years when they had identified Gerry Healy's sect with Leninism and denounced Leninists as "toytown Bolsheviks".
Today the SWP is a largely depoliticised political machine. "Build the party" , its central allpurpose slogan, is not politics. A party is merely an instrument of politics, it cannot be a substitute for politics.
----- pull-quotes -----
preceding years when they had identified Gerry Healy's