["An attempt to build any sort of Leninist…]
Socialist Organiser1992 1992-07-16Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 10
"An attempt to build any sort of Leninist organisation is toy bolshevism' That was 1959, now everything has changed. Cliff: town and published Socialist Review, a small duplicated (later printed) monthly, which lasted until 1962. The group seems to have had little lite to it, and declined slowly through the '50s.
The decay was not just organisational. In 1950 the group subscribed to all the ideas of Leninism, differing from other Trotskyists only on their characterisation of the USSR. A decade later, they did not seem to know quite what they were.
Cliff, in his big pamphlet on Rosa Luxemburg, published in 1959, said that Lenin's ideas on organisation were not suitable for West European conditions. The group was a loose and variegated federation of individuals, with an incoherent and ill-defined but distinctive libertarian tinge to it, combined with a seeming commitment to the idea of an organic ripening towards socialism by the existing mass working class movement: the job of the revolutionary, said Cliff in Luxemburg, was to stay with organisations like the Labour Party all the way through until the socialist revolution.
An attempt to build any sort of Leninist organisation, said Cliff, even one like the SLL in 1959, which continued to work in the Labour Party, was just "toy-town Bolshevism". Polemical opposition to the Healyites' increasing emphasis on the "revolutionary party" lent momentum and emphasis to the Socialist Review group's evolution on this question. When, from 1960, the group began to grow, recruiting CND youth, what grew was this federalist, vaguely libertarian, vaguely social-democratic, explicitly anti-Leninist hodgepodge. In the middle 1960s Cliff would, when talking to Leninist critics, tell us that "IS is centrist" (i.e. half-revolutionary, half-reformist), though he himself, he insisted, was a Bolshevik. The others, such as Michael Kidron, had no "Fourth Internationalist The with of the www. come does sit in we lett workers background", but he, Clift, had, and that was why he remained a Bolshevik despite the group's "centrism"!
His writings said otherwise, and so did the group he (and his writings) had built; but he meant it, and it was important for the future. The mistake of his critics -and of some of his supporters -was to take seriously what he wrote polemically and somewhat speculatively, or to serve as ideological buttressing for what he wanted to do at a given moment, when in fact he would casually ditch or re-write such arguments when external pressure, new opportunities or sheer caprice led him to want the opposite. That would happen in *60s.
And yet, when all is said and A done, the Socialist Review/IS group seemed the most hopeful organisation on the left by the early or middle 1960s. The Healy organisation, the SLL, was still much bigger, but rigidly Stalinist in structure, more and more destructively sectarian, and held in an unbreakable grip by men - in the first place Healy -who were going mad politically (and not only politically). By contrast, Cliff's group was alive, ostentatiously committed to maintain the freedom and the duty of its members to think for themselves, and led by people, in the first place Tony Cliff, who had not yet let their minds become pickled and petrified by dogmatism and the fear-based pseudo-political religiosity which saturated the SLL and made the rank and file of the SLL helpless against the whims of the all-controlling popes and cardinals.
More: in the 1950s Cliff would probably have said that he was trying to recast, redevelop, and refocus the fundamental ideas of the Lenin-Trotsky tradition in the