Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Where today's SWP comes fron A caricature of Leninism

Socialist Organiser no. 529, 16 July 1992 · scan p. 10 · about 703 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

This week the biggest group of the far left in Britain, the Socialist Workers Party holds its annual summer school, "Marxism '92".

As in previous years, "Marxism" will be dominated by a rigidly parrotted "party line". There will be little real debate, and none with revolutionary Marxist critics of the SWP like the Alliance for Workers' Liberty.

The SWP was not always this. This article by Sean Matgamna looks at the SWP's development over last 40 years, and argues that it has become a caricature of Leninist organisation. It was taken from the pamphlet "A trage of the left" (available form AWL, f2)

Thy is the Trotskyist left in Led into competing groups? At the root the divisions are a product of the repeated defeats and the continuing marginalisation of revolutionary socialism.

Small groups - and the biggest of the groups in Britain, the SWP, is still a small group - groups without implantation in the working class, have little power of cohesion when strong political divisions emerge. When members of a small organisation whose raison d'être is propaganda for certain ideas begin to disagree, especially on some emotioncharged issue, then there is little motive for the minority not to break away. Little or no disruption of work follows division; there is no coercion available to the majority except persuasion or moral pressure; in practice the majority is often keen to be shot of the minority; and the minority, given will and determination, can set up a new organisation making more congenial propaganda.

The existing groups are not parties, whatever they call themselves. They are nowhere near being able to play the role of parties vis-à-vis the working class or the existing bourgeois system. This is as true of the biggest groups as of the smallest. The groups are factions, not parties.

These are the structural reasons for the state of things on the left. There are, however, turning points in the history shaped by these basic conditions. The collapse in 1949-50 of the old RCP, a group into which almost all British Trotskyists had been united for some five years, produced what became the Militant, the SWP, and the Healy WRP.

The next such "turning point" can be dated exactly: 4 December 1971. On that day the International Socialism (IS) group (which later became the SWP) held a special conference at which, by a vote of roughly 60-40, a motion from the National Committee was carried "defusing" IS and an organised tendency inside IS, Workers' Fight, which had fused years earlier.

Almost in passing the conference outlawed all groupings in IS which had differences with the leadership across the board and not just on special issues. That is not how it was phrased, but that is what it meant, as those critics of the leadership who tried to stay in the organisation soon found out in the years following the "de-fusion" of Workers' Fight on 4 December 1971.

The conference decision produced immediately - we were expelled! - Workers' Fight Mark 2, forerunner of today's Alliance for Workers' Liberty and Socialist Organiser. In early 1973 a group which soon became the new RCP and RCG was expelled. In 1975, the IS regime set up on 4 December 1971 purged a sizeable chunk of the cadre and leadership of IS as it had been on 4 December 1971! That "IS Opposition" soon disintegrated, but many of its leaders are active today around Catalyst magazine and the socialist newspaper. 4 December 1971 was the point at which IS changed radically, and set off down the road to becoming what it is today, a caricature "toytown Bolshevik" party.

The group was a loose and variegated federation of individuals, with an incoherent and ill-defined but distinctive libertarian tinge to it, combined with a seeming commitment to the idea of an organic in skage, honey amend be sariotor posie on the gunse scare sis to Coupse the Cessit toes te ORTUNATELY Y senate stra av. This is whet rev olutionary socialists have argued for throughout the Setime of the Labour Party and what the Sociatist Workers Party stends tor, The minority of saison

----- pull-quotes -----

Where do We gOE from here? SCABS OUT ORKERS IN

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 529

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →