Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

The Tories, sex

Socialist Organiser no. 529, 16 July 1992 · scan pp. 8–10 · about 1,988 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 8

Vew Right: what does it stan he Tories, sex and the ing to systematically roll back Lifers demonstrate in favour of the Alton Bill. Despite their best efforts abortion The Tories, sex and family is taken from speech by Martin Durham at Workers* Liberty '92. Martin Durham is a lecturer Wolverhampton Poly.

n the late 1970s there was :

of publicity given to the ris America of what was call the New Right particularly tho sections known as the Ne Christian Right, like Mor Majority and Christian Voic Those organisations campaigni vigorously against liberalism al feminism.

They were particularly co cerned with issues like abortio sex education and homosexua ty. They played an importal part in the rise to power ‹ Ronald Reagan and hav remained active since then i trying to bring about the changs in American society that the were set up to achieve. The have been most visible recentl around the abortion issue.

In the same period in the lat '70s we saw the rise in Britain c a New Right and its influence o the higher echelons of the Tor Party - for instance, througl Margaret Thatcher, Keith Josep and Rhodes Boyson.

We saw the Thatcher govern ment come into existenc against the background of among other things, arguments about abortion, pornography homosexuality and women in the workplace.

The result was that a large number of socialists, feminists and liberal writers argued that in the late '70s and 1980s - just as in the USA - we have a New Right that is centrally concerned with carrying out a sexual counter-revolution, that what you were seeing in Britain was a Thatcher government engaged in a deliberate moral offensive, trying to roll back the 1960s on issues like abortion, pornography and homosexuality. Organisations like SPUC, Life and Mary Whitehouse's Viewers and Listeners Association were all part of the New Right's offensive. The argument I want to make is that none of this is true. There is not a New Right in Britain centrally concerned with a sexual counter-revolution. There has not been a Thatcher government moral offensive trying to systematically roll back the 1960s. There is not an involvement of SPUC, Life, the Viewers and Listeners Association or Family and Youth Concern in the New Right as part of a moral offensive.

Much of this fits the USA.

Although I think if we look at the USA we would find a lot of the coverage has been misleading. But none of this fits Britain.

If we look at the 1980s we find a New Right which is very different from the American New Right. The American New Right is only a part of the conservative movement. Even the New Right itself, although it made "prolife", "pro-family" issues part of the cutting edge, is only part of that edge. The US New Right were strongly concerned with other issues, particularly foreign policy and issues like the Contras. This is even more the case with the conservative movement in general which was strongly concerned with economics and social policy.

It may well be that we overstated how important sexual issues were to the American right. Certainly it is true that these issues were more important to them, and remain more important, than is the custom in right-wing politics. However it is true that the British New Right is very different from the American. Still, as late as 1992, no one can be bothered to study, for instance, the main New Right groups in this country. There is no article about the Joseph-Thatcher think-tank the Centre For Policy "There are also libertarian New Rightists. The best example in Britain would be Teresa Gorman, subject of a rather favourable profi in Tribune and in the past some good coverage in Marxism Today. Teresa Gorman and others have been examples of people who take liberal views on sexual issues."

Studies or about the free market think-tank the Institute of Economic Affairs. There is nothing about the Adam Smith Institute. There is not even anything produced about the Salisbury Review and their importance is overstated).

There is no available study of any of the New Right groups in this country. But if you examine the British New Right I suggest you will find they are overwhelmingly concerned with economic issues and social policy questions such as welfare state dependency.

The welfare dependency question has an impact on the family. But what you do not find in the main New Right groups - the Salisbury Review is an exception, but not the main New Right groups - is any concern with reversing abortion rights or sex education or opposing homosexuality. These groups do not find these issues important.

This is different to saying you can not find any of these issues in the New Right. In one of the second division groups of the New Right, the Freedom Association, we find not - as has been suggested - a moral offensive but instead that these issues are one of the concerns of some of the prominent people in the Freedom Association. Others in the Freedom Association regard this as a waste of time. There are also some libertarian New Rightists. The best example in Britain would be Teresa Gorman, subject of a rather favourable profile in Tribune and in the past some good coverage in Marxism Today. Teresa Gorman and others have been examples of people who take liberal views on sexual issues.

There are some individuals in say the Freedom Association, the Centre for Policy Studies and most importantly the Conservative Family Campaign, the last who explicitly compare themselves to the members of the US L UNBORN has not been restricted under t Moral Majority. At its peak the Family Campaign had 31 MPs in its ranks. These people are comparable to the Americans -deliberately so. But the bulk of the British New Right, rather than being libertarian or moralist are not concerned with the issues central to the American New Right.

I will go further. If we draw up a balance sheet of the Thatcher years it does not fit the notion of a moral majority offensive. What do we find? We see some rhetoric from Mrs Thatcher and leading ministers about the family.

Secondly, we find some moments of legislation. For instance the Thatcher government introduced Clause 28, which was intended to stop local council "promotion" of homosexuality. The Thatcher government introduced legislation on sex education which

Scan page 9

and the tamily SILENT HOLOCAUST The Thatc her years did not represent some sort of "Moral Majority in Power it should be taught context of family valvernment strengthened on obscenity, banning the things the igners wanted in all else was that a should have the at to withdraw ren from sex radiaz. The Thatc Major governme refused this des, bringing the televices under the Obscene -ons Act and putting the Broadcasting Standards Council, a watchdog to look for rudeness on television.

All these things can be rightly cited as examples of government concern with moral, pro-family issues. However, on the other side of the balance sheet, what Tole did the Thatcher government play on abortion? The answer is that abortion continued to be legal during the Thatcher years and when it came to the main attempt of the prolifers to reverse the legislation of the late 1960s, the key people in the government opposed that change. Abortion was not cut to 18 weeks. It was cut to 24 weeks with large exceptions.

Hardly any abortions occur over 24 weeks and the exceptions probably cover nearly every case. Abortion has not been restricted and Thatcher has not tried to restrict it.

If you read SPUC's newspaper "Human Concern" or Life's paper "Life News" or Mary Whitehouse's "Viewers and Listeners" or attend their national conferences you will find that these organisations include many who are Conservatives. It is true that many activists in these movements would prefer Conservative government to the party of "wickedness" , the Labour Party or the party of David Steel - introducer of the 1967 Abortion Act - the Liberals.

Nevertheless, the activists are extraordinarily embittered towards the Thatcher government which they regard as their enemy.

What else happened during the Thatcher years? The moral campaigners achieved some concessions on sex education. Now school governors decide if sex education is provided or not. Whatever is provided must be within the context of "family and moral values" . But the things the campaigners wanted above all else was that parents should have the right to withdraw children from sex education. The Thatcher and Major governments have refused this right.

Now the Major government has decided to make AIDS education compulsory. Although I have not seen the Department of Education document, according to the moral crusaders this document is not quite what they have in mind for 12 year olds. Phrases like "stop it" and "don't do it" are fairly absent from this document, some detail about how you might do things is present in this document.

The moral crusaders are extremely unhappy about the Major government's policies on AIDS education. They were furious with the Thatcher government for, among other things, funding the Terrence Higgins Trust and the Family Planning Association.

Finally, Victoria Gillick. Despite left-wing predictions that the Tory government were behind Gillick's campaign against under-16 contraception and would see it through to completion, she was blocked by the government, not least by Kenneth Clarke. Under-16 contraception is still available. If you read Victoria Gillick's two books you will find a strong detestation of Thatcher and Joseph who she regards as enemies of the family.

We can look at other examples. For instance, Mary Whitehouse was more favourable the Thatcher government than SPUC or Life. Mary Whitehouse takes the view that Margaret Thatcher really cared and did some good things. Her policy is not to frontally attack the Thatcher government, but to try to draw it on.

For SPUC, Life and the Conservative Family Campaign, the Thatcher government was a disaster and the Major government is even worse. Not least because Major is getting ready to lower Finally, in America many of Mary Whitehouse's viewers and listeners were disappointed the moral crusaders, above all the mainstream of the anti-abor- catastrophe to identify with a tion movement, keep clear of the pro-life position. Although they New Right. There are many will probably lose, there are a lot Democrats in the US who are of Republicans who are either anti-abortion - both voters and pro-choice or who do not want to a lesser degree members - to be identified as anti-abortion. and it would be unwise for the The result: the main US anti-abortion group is not identified with the New Right. "The Thatcher years did I think we would make a mistake if we assumed that the not represent some sort American moral crusaders were of "moral majority in in general tied up with the New power". On balance Right. But it is certainly true that in the US there are entanglepeople looked at the ments which we do not have British New Right here.

The Thatcher years did not repthrough an Americar Present some sort of "moral lens. majority in power". On balance people looked at the British New Right through an American lens.

We transposed what we thought main anti-abortion movement to was happening in the US on to identify with the Republicans. As Britain where things were very we will see at the 1992 Republi- different. The result was that we can Convention there are also a did not understand the New significant number of Republi- Right or the Thatcher governcans who think it is an electoral ment.

Scan page 10

nis

----- pull-quotes -----

SPECIAL ALTON BILL ISSUE Offe I5 news PRO-LIFE BI EXTRAORDI

WE WANT THE END THE OF THIr THIS

the Ch ej.

the age of consent for male homosexuals down to at least 18.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 529

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →