Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Tweedledees and and Tweedledums in the leadership contest

Socialist Organiser no. 529, 16 July 1992 · scan p. 7 · about 807 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 7 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 7

John Smith has a solid rightwing pedigree, stretching back to his days as chair of Glasgow University Labour Club. A supporter first of the "Manifesto" group and then of the "Solidarity" group, his name has featured regularly on the right-wing slates for the Shadow Cabinet.

Solidly anti-Militant (in 1982, when the witch-hunt started, he was to the fore in calling for expulsions) and anti-abortion rights, his one political service of any value is to deflate the myth that there is something inherently progressive in being Scottish.

Smith's policy commitmentscontinuing membership of the ERM, a positive partnership with private industry, reform of the Common Agricultural Policy, etc., etc. — are hardly the stuff of whic bold socialist programmes are made.

The guiding lights of the manifesto are caution and evasion. Policies "need to be developed, issues "need to be looked at again" ideas "need to be examined in an open-minded way", "policy development must be subject to "a searching and wide ranging Where have we heard all this before? We heard it from the outgoing leadership for five solid yea prior to the defeat on 9 April: a Policy Review, a "modernisation" of policy, and a "revamping" of party organisation.

John Smith's "New Paths to Victory" turn out to be nothing more than the old paths to defe JOHN PRESCOTT With John, what you is what you get. He represents the core working class support that Labour has got to retain, and they identify with him," writes Joan Lestor MP in her rather guarded endorsemen! of John Prescott's candidature.

In many ways Prescott is a heavier-weight maritime version of Dennis Skinner, but with a list on the starboard side. He has been outspoken against anything to do with Europe (including the Channel Tunnel).

Prescott is standing Fixit who will sort out party organ isation on the basis of a three-poir "plan of urgent action"

Firstly, we must "understand fully why we lost" . After "full participation by Party members", , an interim report would go to Party conference.

Point two is to "build a mass membership Party". We must "make the Party more attractive, especially not hostile to women."

But some members of Prescott's campaign team, such as Sheffield MP Richard Caborn, are keener oi expelling party members than win ning new ones.

Point three in Mr Fixit's action plan is "internal democracy" - a thought not uppermost in the mind of John Prescott in recent years when he has supported all the suspensions, expulsions and imposed candidates.

His public emphasis on defending links between the Labour Party and trade unions also represents a departure from his "action plan" , in which he calls for one member, one vote" , and "a proper balance between decisions by individual members and decisions by representative democracy at conferenc including reform of the block BRYAN GOULD Bient in the onstion of ryan Gould has played a leadKinnock's New Model Labou Party. He has connived in every carve-up to undermine democracy and debate within the Labour Party.

But now Gould finds himself the victim of the same kind of stitch-up, and he is bleating about how "fixing has been substituted for voting" in the leadership contest.

In there is a lot about "empowerment of individuals and communities", "space for people to live their own lives" , "the right of people to develop their full potential in whichever way they choose", etc., etc., but no proposals beyond a re-hash of the various right wing policies adopted by Labour in recent years. If Gould's programme is "radical", then the now defunct SDP was revolutionary.

His proposals are so modest that he has to bemoan the fact that "every idea or policy initiative I have put forward has been taken up by one or other of my opponents".

MARGARET BECKETT n 1976 Margaret Beckett was reckoned a left-winger. Then shi took over from Joan Lestor as Junior Minister for Education -when Lestor had resigned in protest at cuts in education.

Now in the deputy leadership contest, Beckett is making a great play of her left-wing credentials -backing the miners' strike, opposing the expulsion of Militant in th mid-1980s, and keeping bership of CND.

Strangely, she has not mentioned her most notable left-wing speech: an outspoken attack on Neil Kinnock at a Tribune rally in 1981, when Kinnock refused to back Tony Benn for deputy leader:

Beckett backed Kinnock for party leader in 1983, and resigned from the Campaign Group in 1988 when they decided to challenge Kinnock for party leader. "There is a clear and continuing role for the left in the Labour Party," she recently told Tribune. But differences of opinion are now aired in a much more comradely fashion"

Suspensions, expulsions, bans on left wing newspapers, imposed parliamentary candidates and rigged leadership contests! Is that a "comradely fashion" to run a party?

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 529

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →