Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Resistance grows to Smith's agenda

Socialist Organiser no. 529, 16 July 1992 · scan p. 7 · Colin Foster · about 771 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 7 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 7

towards PeepincToryamber ohn Smith plans to shift the towards pale-pink Toryism.

His agenda after being elected as the new Labour Party leader on 18 July — as he is certain to be — is already mapped out.

The right of local Labour Parties to choose Labour candidates for parliament will be cut down. At the Labour Party conference this October, the platform will try to push through proposals to require a "trigger ballot" before any sitting Labour MP can be challenged, and TH POLL TA Labour's collaboration alternative to do the selection of candidates by "one member, one vote", disenfranchising local trade union affiliates.

The Labour Party conference will be turned into more of a media show - like the Tory Party conference, or the American party conventions - than a democratic gathering. This October, the Party leadership will try to take away the right of trade unions and local Labour Parties to send resolutions to Conference. Under their proposals, all resolutions will have to be sieved through "Standing Commissions", a new "National Policy Forum", the National poll part of the why Executive, and the Conference Arrangements Committee.

Power will be transferred from the open floor of Conference to the closed chambers of the Shadow Cabinet, the National Executive, and the new "Forum", in which MPs, MEPs, Labour councillers, and the National Executive will outnumber elected representatives from the trade unions and local Labour Parties.

John Smith and his friends also plan to change the method for electing the Labour Party leader. In Tribune (10 July), Smith's campaign manager Robin Cook outlines his ideas.

Local Labour Party members should vote by post, with the count done centrally rather than in each constituency. Levy-paying members of affiliated trade unions should also vote by post, and their votes too should be counted centrally, presumably weighted to be worth less than those of individual Party members. The votes of Labour MPs should then be added in to produce the final result.

This is a scheme for removing any input into the Labour Party from collective working-class deliberation and decision-making, and replacing it with postal plebiscites.

Those postal plebiscites will inevitably be shaped and heavily influenced by the capitalist media, while Labour Party and trade union meetings are left with no powers and little purpose. And, apart from that, the scheme would be ruinously expensive!

These proposals are to be considered by a "commission" set up by Labour's National Executive in May to review relations between the Party and the trade unions.

Fundamentally, John Smith, like Neil Kinnock, sees little use in an active Labour Party membership which may have its own ideas and its own priorities, and little advantage in direct and accountable links with trade unions which are likely to insist on trade union demands.

He wants a passive Party, where all the "campaigning" is done by press releases and media stunts.

On policy, the major new ideas of the Labour right wing are to accept Tory thinking in two further areas — "targetting" (that is, means-testing) of welfare benefits, and compulsory competitive for public services.

How stupid can the right wing be? They just want to press on down the same road that led to defeat in the General Election on 9 April — making Labour a pale understudy of the Tories, signalling to working-class voters that Labour is a shifty, opportunist outfit with no real alternative to offer and no ideas of its own.

Increasing numbers of Labour Party and trade union members see the futility of that course. Even if they vote for Smith on 18 July -and the way the leadership election was organised left little alternative - they will start to organise against Smith's policies.

The Labour Left conference called by the Campaign Group of MPs in Leeds on 20 June was over 500 strong, the biggest gathering of the Labour Left for many years. Little definite organisation came out of it, but it reflected a change in mood.

The leadership contest started out with John Smith and Bryan Gould competing to see who could be most right-wing, and ended with all the candidates protesting how much they valued Labour's trade union link and how radical their ideas were! That, too, reflects a shifting mood in the Party rank and file.

Local Labour Parties have been deciding their resolutions for the Party conference in October, and it is already clear that there will be several resolutions supporting the trade union link, defending Labour Party democracy, and demanding that Labour commit itself to free the trade unions from the Tories? legal hobbles.

----- pull-quotes -----

IF YOU HATE

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 529

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →