Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

The Yugoslav cock-pit

Socialist Organiser no. 529, 16 July 1992 · scan pp. 3–4 · about 1,280 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 3 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 3

The old Yugoslav state broke down because, over the last decade, aggressive Serb chauvinism provoked and alarmed the smaller peoples, Croats and others, of the Yugoslav Federation.

At the heart of the chaos into which Yugoslavia has now dissolved is the predatory expansion of the Serbian state, led by neo-Stalinists whose regime has a great deal of popular support. They utilise people such as the Serbs in the territory claimed by Croatia to serve a drive which is essentially a drive to create the largest possible "Greater Serbia" It is a primitive form of imperialism, whose real content is summed up in the phrase which expresses their policy for non-Serbs: "ethnic cleansing".

Nationalism and chauvinism inevitably breeds... nationalism and chauvinism.

The Croats were pushed and provoked by the Serbs. But when Croatia seceded from Yugoslavia, Bpard Gramam Bensh Vladimin Derer Terry Eagleton Jatin Haria Lifelony Black Sectiomsi Dorothy racedo Uper Marino John Metrov Jbhun Nichpison Peter Tatchell Members of the Advisory Committee are drawn from a broad cross section of the left who are opposed to the Labour Party's witch-hunt against Socialist Organiser. Views expressed in articles are the responsibility of the authors and not of the Advisory Editorial Board. large numbers of Serbs - substantial majorities in some parts of the territory of historic Croatia - were cut off from other Serbs and trapped as a helpless minority in an alien state. In the Croatian state set up under German patronage during World War Two, as many as half of the Serbs in Croatia - perhaps 3/4 of a million men, women and children -were massacred by Croat chauvinists, the Ustashe.

While Serb state leaders such as Slobodan Milosevic whose policies through the '80s led finally to the destruction of Yugoslavia were, as we have said, chauvinists, people motivated by the desire to aggrandise Serbia, the Serbs in independent Croatia did not have to be chauvinists to resolve to fight rather than submit to outright Croatian rule. They needed only to remember the not too distant past and look around them at the efforts being made to revive Ustashe banners, uniforms and catchcries in the new Croatia.

Thus while millions in Croatia - 10 stick to the one example - felt the understandable need for separation, they could not achieve independence without oppressing and threatening others. And not only in Yugoslavia. The whole of the Balkans is a crazy pavement of peoples and fragments of peoples interlocked and overlapping, and standing in the way of each others' full autonomyFrom this it followed that maintenance of a broad federal structure was the best possible way for the peoples of Yugoslavia to arrange their affairs. But the structures broke down; the central state apparatus became increasingly a tool of Serb domination, serving Serb expansion. Everything dissolved into the bloody chaos of many ethnic and national wars which is now raging.

Despite all the crimes of the Croatian chauvinists, the Croats' right to self-determination became the major issue between Croatia and Serbia; socialists have to uphold that right, championing the minority rights of the Serbs within Croatia but denying to Serbia any right to use those minorities as a pretext for trying to conquer as much of Croatia as they can.

The Serb chauvinists were as aggressive against Kosovo and Slovenia where there were no big problems of an oppressed Serbian minority as against Croatia.

"Within this situation there is a growing demand for Western UN, NATO -intervention to bring end to the fighting. h by no means certain that there will be Western military intervention. If there it is unlikely to bring peace or create a political framework within which the peoples of the forme Yugoslavia can coexist."

Yugoslavia today may offer a piccure of their own future to many other ethnically interlaced groups of people, including the occupants of large parts of the former Soviet Union.

Within this situation there is a growing demand for Western - UN, NATO - intervention to bring an end to the fighting. It is by no means certain that there will be Western military intervention. If there is, it is unlikely to bring peace or create a political framework within which the peoples of the former Yugoslavia can coexist. What military intervention would most likely amount to is action to stop Serbia expanding further, and to "freeze" the current carve-up of Bosnia. Already, antiSerb sanctions are being mounted.

Is the conflict turning into something like the build-up to another edition of last year's war against Iraq? The Iraqi occupation of Kuwait quickly became the occasion for a savage Western war against IraqShould socialists "Defend Serbia" from "Imperialist Aggression"?

If there is Western military intervention it will be a police action to avert chaos on the borders of the immensely powerful European community: it will be a limited police action. If the cluster of wars now going on are allowed to burn themselves out, they will go on for a long time, many thousands will die, hundreds of thousands and maybe millions will be "ethnically cleansed" into refugee camps, and "Greater Serbia" may become a lot greater than it is now.

As socialists and anti-imperialists, we have no confidence in the Western capitalist powers: we warn against relying on NATO or UN intervention; we advocate working-class independence. But in the name of what alternative would we denounce and condemn, and demand an immediate end to, a limited police action by the big powers?

On the ground that everything that "imperialist" Western European states do is ipso facto "imperialist" and wrong, even if it has desirable results? This is not Marxist or working class politics but absurd "oppositionism", nihilism.

On the ground that 'outside' intervention is always wrong? What meaning can such a 'principle' have in face of the bloody ethnic melée which is engulfing the peoples of Yugoslavia? Why has Serbia more "right' in Bosnia than a UN army acceptable to the majority of Bosnians would have? That reasoning is absurd.

On the ground that neo-Stalinist Serbia is a 'socialist' or 'workers" state? It is nothing of the sort. But even if it were, then that would not require of socialists that we back Serbian imperialism, with all its inevitable slaughters and "ethnic cleansings". . Such a position would be a reductio ad absurdum of a decades-old 'tradition' of kitsch Trotskyist "defencist" policies for the Stalinist states. It is sheer nonsense, on every level.

Or should we oppose a big power police action because we believe the destruction of Serb power, the prevention of the consolidation of the Greater Serb state is the real goal of Western "imperialist" intervention? For certain, the Western powers will only intervene militarily, with all the accompanying costs, dangers and precedents, to serve their own interests.

There are powers with imperialist ambitions to gain semi-colonies and spheres of influence in Yugoslavia and the whole area round the Black Sea.

Turkey has been establishing close relations with the Muslim and Turkic-language republics of the exUSSR. It probably hopes for influence in Macedonia, too: the prospect of an independent Macedonia, set loose by the breakup of Yugoslavia, has inflamed the ancient hostilities between Greece and Turkey.

Continued page 2 "The emancipation of ther working class is also thel emancipation oh all human beingswithout distinction of sex or race.

Karl Marx Sprint Urganisera POBon BRE Londom Sal 5 4NAI Newsalesk: 0nn 639 7965 Latesridateworareports: Monday, Editor: John O'Mahony Solishediby: VL Publicatipns Ltd, edenbridari Registered as a newspaper at the Postiofficen akticlerudo notgecessardy reflect the viewswof bocialist Urganisert andıare wn a personal capacity unless otherwise stated.

Scan page 4

ser N DEPTH AHIS

----- pull-quotes -----

D Bpc8201 London SE 0 4NAI anted tridant Press,

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 529

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →