Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Tube bosses turn the screw

Socialist Organiser no. 528, 25 June 1992 · scan p. 15 · Tony Dale · about 2,354 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 15 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 15

Canteen workers need support By a Central Line guard ]RMT railworkers union she leadership of the on the London Underground have been grasping desperately at straws in an attempt to present their rotten deal with the Tube bosses as a victory.

One of the "straws" given headline space was the bosses' "commitment to negotiate through the agreed machineries and to use agreed procedures to resolve differences"

The RMT's District Council said at the time, "It means that any change that management may want... will be dealt with in the existing machinery of Official GMB dispute. Gardner Merchant cuts staff, hourly rate, and working hours. GPT cuts canteen subsidies. GMB says: No to cuts!" reads one of the placards outside the GPT piant (formerly Plesseys) in Liverpool.

Since a week last Friday (12th June) the 38 canteen workers employed by Gardner Merchant - which operates the canteen and vending-machine services at the GPT plant - have been on strike in protest at a series of savage cutbacks being proposed by their employer.

Gardner Merchant wants to slash rates of pay by El an hour and to cut working hours by Flack Martin Faces, aormer Marxism Today man whose selfsatisfaction seems unlimited, wrote another pompous piece in this weekend's Guardian.

Declaring 'Labour's intellectual and cultural resources exhausted', that Labour has 'never been a thinking party' , indeed it was 'unaccustomed to thinking' and has become the 'preserve of the second rate' , the 'overwhelming truth about Labour culture is that it is boring' he reveals to us this 'uncomfortable truth: a party unable to think, locked in a declining culture and possessed of a membership which eloquently expresses the problem. The scenario, I fear, is all too clear. Labour will slowly but porkers at Burnstall Ltd of Smethwick, West Midlands, are continuing their strike for union recognition, improved safety standards, and equai pa: for women workers.

23 out of 25 manual workers in the factory have joined the GMB, but the managing director has said he would rather close down the company than recognise the union.

Pay is bad enough for the male workers, but women earn £20 to £30 a week less. Take-home pay for a 57 hour week i as little as £120. The mainly Asian workforce is also deman ding the reinstatement of a white worker who was sacked just before the dispute began.

Messages of support and negotiations without imposition". Oh yes? How much this commitment was really worth - less than the paper it was written on — has now been revealed.

Management have presented RMT with a "final" set of pro posals for the new machinery. and served notice of termination on the old machinery. The RNC (Railway Negotiating Committee) which covers the sectional council system (i.e. full-time reps to represent different grades of workers) "no longer exists". With regard to sectional councillors, management will "allow their roles to continue until 11 August to conclude outstanding issues". after which "sectional councillors will have no role". Furke anything up to 20 hours per week, as well as reducing the size of the workforce.

Workers stand to lose around E50 a week - out of an average veekly pay packet ot £150, efore tax and other deductions. One worker stands to lose as much as £114 each week.

Whilst the canteen staff face the threat of poverty-level wages, Gardner Merchant and GPT try to pass the buck to each other over who is responsible for the cutbacks.

Pickets have been outside the factory gates every day since the start of the dispute, and have received strong support from GPT employees. As one of the pickets put it: *We want to thank GPT statt for all the support they are giving us. A lot of them express their support as they go in, and we hold a weekly collection. They are also continuing their boycott remorselessly decline...' Typically Jacques does not tell as what might be done about this, what fresh original thoughts he has had to advance the general good of humanity, socialism, democracy, peace, or anything else which takes his fancy.!

But that is not and never has been Jacques role: his real concern is not with refocussing or reorienting the labour movement but with bashing it. So has he been able to identify any positive signs for the labour movement? Well... yes and no: "] have pored through the documents (of the leadership debate) for something of interest and I found two things: that Labour should support compulsory competitive tendering and abandon blanket support for universal benefits. Fine, I happen to agree, but this is ten years too late and an example not of original thought in Labour circles but another belated Labour acknowledgement of Conservative originality"! donations to: Jo Quigley, GMB, 2 Birmingham Road, Halesowen, West Midlands. T paid workers at Alcan hree hundred hourlythermore, the rest of the RNC structure "no longer exists" either.

The "existing machinery" exists no more! In the meantime *specially convened joint working parties" entirely outside the machinery will continue to negotiate on the Underground's Company Plan.

RMT threw away a two-to-one majority for strike action, and Tube workers will now begin to reap the fruits of that decision.

It is pointless to try to raise the importance of this or that machinery of negotiation over and above the actual terms and conditions of Tube workers. However, it is clear that the new machinery is much worse than the old one. And what all of the vending machines."

Gardner Merchant's response to the strike has been to begin shipping in scabs. From day one of the dispute scabs were brought in to run the management canteen.

*The scabs are people from other sites where Gardner Merchant has the catering contract. They include people who have previously been sacked by the company, but are now being used to break our strike."

"What they don't realise is that if we win, it might benefit them. This is one of the better paid sites for canteen staff, so a victory for us, could lead to better rates of pay for them," said one of the pickets.

The strikers are demanding that all proposals for cutting pay rates are scrapped, and that discussions be held on the extent to which there should be any reductions in working hours.

The strike is a prime example Of course! A really creative Labour Party would - over ten years ago and before the Tories - have proposed a scheme (compulsory competitive tendering) to abolish or reduce occupational pension schemes, cut working class incomes, increase the hours of full-time workers, and cut the hours of part-timers, removing their entitlements to maternity leave, state benefits, and employment protection. That's a whizz of an intellectual idea - makes me wonder why Jacques never thought of it before the Tories Stop press The DoE have now announced 18 more functions to be added to the 12 already identified in their contracting-out programm for the next four years. 1400 jobs are now directly under threat. Further regional functions to be tested will be identified in the near future.

As the DoE only employs 600 people, this is a very serious a tack, making redundancies look inevitable. this demonstrates is management's arrogance.

Why are they so arrogant? RMT's leadership can try to mislead us all about "the victory" they won for us, but Tube workers - and manage ment - know full well who backed down and who stood firm.

The strength to defend and improve our conditions does not lie in the "skills" of our negotiators. It lies in our ability and willingness to take industrial action.

Tube workers cannot depend on union misleaders, right or left, ASLEF or RMT. If we are to defend ourselves in the period ahead, we will need to build on the best of the traditions of 1989. A rank and file of how new-style management practices represent an attack on workers' living standards, as the use of "contracting out" and "competitive tendering" in relation to areas such as canteen services, security and cleaning results in pay cuts tor the employees of the contractors.

When GPT contracted out security at its Liverpool plant, the result was pay cuts. Now pay cuts are being imposed in the contracted-out canteen service. Next in line for contracting out - and pay cuts - are cleaning staff at the plant.

A victory for the GMB members will therefore be an inspiration for all other workers, at GPT and elsewhere, facing cuts in pay and hours as a result of contracting-out.

Messages of support/financial donations/requests for speakers: contact GMB, 99 Edge Lane, Liverpool L7; phone 051 263 8261.

because he obviously thinks working class people need poker up the backside to make them work harder. Just to make sure no-one's doing too well, Labour should also have come up with means testing for state benefits — a really profound idea (or least ways Neville Chamberlain thought so).

If Jacques had consulted the Public Services Privatisation Research Unit he would have found that contracting-out has been a "quality disaster", But that wouldn't fit his political purpose. The lesson from all this? The fight against contracting out is an ideological, political one rather than a straight industrial battle. If we are to defeat the Tories plans for the mass contracting out of the public sector - and with it the recasting of society - then we must defeat those within the socialist and labour movement who effectively act as their agents. Whether Jacques is to any extent active within our movement I don't know, but he and his old Marxism Today coterie do still enjoy some influence: it must be broken. body uniting workers across unions and grades is what is needed to build Tube workers confidence to take action to defeat the Company Plan.

Depending on the union leaderships to do it for us will lead to disaster. Immediately she NALGO conferen ] took the historic deci sion to recommend merger with NUPE and CoHSE by a three-to-one margin. A ballot of the three unions' memberships on the proposals for the new union, Unison, will take place later this year.

The main opposition to the merger at conference came from the right wing, who yearned for the days when NALGO was a guild for local government officers. Over the years it has been transformed into a national union for white collar workers in councils, the NHS, and other public services.

The merger will be a big step forward to the creation of one big union unifying white-collar and blue-collar public sector workers.

The conference vote was the culmination of years of discussion. For that length of time, also, the left has been debating its attitude to the merger. In that debate Socialist Organiser adopted an unequivocal pro-merger position. The Campaign for a Democratic, Fighting Public Services Union has campaigned for the merger and for the maximum democratic guarantees.

Sections of the left have been confused and equivocal. It was only at the start of conference that the SWP and the SWPdominated Broad Left came out for the merger. Even at the conference, the Leeds and Birmingham NALGO branches supported proposals and made contributions which were effectively anti-merger.

The opposition to the merger became centred on the plans for central collection of subs in Unison. The right-wing antimergerites joined some left branches in re-raising the call for local collection. This amendment, if passed, would have scuppered the merger. Conference voted it down.

The rule book proposals rightly sparked the biggest revolt during the merger debate A rule book had been sent out a few days before conference, we-must demand that all unions ballot to stop the Plan. It should be obvious by now that management are intent on driving through the great bulk of the Plan. Only strike action can stop them! discontent over the rule book was by voting for a special conference. The Morning Star mobilised heavily for no amendments. The rule book amendment was lost only by a five-to-four majerity. It was a clear warning to the joint unio leaderships to make the rule book more acceptable.

The Campaign for a Democratic Fighting Public Service Union held a wellattended fringe meeting. Now the Campaign needs to organis an independent left-wing "Yes to Merger" campaign. Flames, petite dare rollowing their election targetted public-sector white-collar posts for privatisation.

NALGO's local government sector, meeting on Monday 15 June, voted for a special conference on the extension of compulsory competitive tendering. Conference also voted for a "series of national and regional events" as part ol the campaign against CCT.

These proposals were carried against the wishes of the National Executive, who only wanted a vague paper policy against CCT.

The employers' offensive against public services and public sector workers is resulting in a number of bitter disputes. Newham poll tax workers have been on strike against compulsory redundancies since January. More NALGO members are to join the strike.

The long-running Camden social workers' strike has ended, but with 26 sackings. The National Executive withdrew official support without an adequate return-towork agreement. Conference became dominated by the issue of whether three workers who returned to work before the end of the strike but were subsequently sacked should receive financial support. In a disgraceful debate, Militant and the National Executive combined to oppose the Camden strikers and persuaded conference to withdraw financial support from the three sacked workers.

In general the NALGO -conference seemed low-key and downbeat compared to past years. The number of *hard left" delegates was reduced. But overall the conference was radical and militant on the basic bread-and-butter issues.

NAIGO Action sold well at conference. The past vear has been a difficult one for N.AI.GO Action, caused by organisational and financial problems combined with a low level of struggle. The N.AI.GO Action meeting at conference agreed that NAL.GO Action should continue. In the run-up to merger, and against the backdrop of the Tories campaign against public services, the role of NALGO Action will be vital.

----- pull-quotes -----

THEECICT CONI By a civil servant

The Industrial Front

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 528

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →