Turn and turn again
Socialist Organiser1992 1992-06-25Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 14 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 14
The question of Europe is back in the headines, and with each return Socialist Worker seems to reverse its line on Europe.
In the 1960s the SWP (then called the International Socialist Group) held a line that socialists should not focus on opposition to the EEC In Spring 1963, for example, John Palmer (then a SWP leader) argued, "In or out of the Common Market, the problems facing the British labour movement are likely to be much the same. Indeed the point is that the issues facing us are more similar to those facing European and American workers than at any time in the past 40 years"
This principled position degen erated as the tide of opinion against "Europe" grew among the labour and union bureaucrats, the Communist Party and much of the rank and file working class left.
In June 1971 SW switched to a nationalist position that effectively put British workers above foreign workers. (They also expelled the Workers Fight tendency, a forerunner of the AWL because it organised against the policy switch). They opted for the "little England" position of "No to the EEC".
In the 1975 referendum they campaigned frantically for "Britain Out!" The slogan of a Socialist United Europe appeared here and there but they never explained how tryin to break up or slow down the capitalist integration of Europe would help achieve that.
Last November, the SWP changed its mind once more, without explanation. After discussing what further European unity meant, Alex Callinicos declared: "But the alternative preached by that strange allian breaking the state power - that is, of Tory right wingers and Labour left wingers has equally little to offer."
Last week's SW (20 June) switches back again. It adopts a line rather similar to that of fony Benn and much of the Labour left in opposing the EC. *The EC is not in the interest of workers in Britain, Europe or the rest of the world. We are against it"
But an isolated capitalist Britain is no better than an integrated capitalist Europe! Capitalists in London are the same as capitalists in Brussels -indeed they jet between one city and another all the time.
Capital will forge international links, whatever we or the SWP say. The answer is to forge international links ourselves. Europe-wide workers' solidarity would have won the miners' strike. Far more useful than demanding "No to a bosses' Europe" is to demand "Yes to a workers" Europe!" We should respond by fighting for a levelling up of workers' rights across Europe, for a shorter working week, for a minimum wage. We should strengthen union links across Europe, and spread Europe-wide working class action in the face of Europe-wide attacks from the bosses.
SW knew all this before June 1971; and it rediscovered it just a few months ago! Evidently SW's editors can forget what they know at a moment's notice!
In 1971 SW's switch of policy provoked a major row. Not only Workers' Fight but also probably 40% of the SWP (IS) membership complained.
Today, however, SW can apparently change policy from week to week - on the EC now, as on the poll tax, the Iran-Iraq war, Ireland, and much else -with little or no comment, argument or explanation.
A revolutionary party is supposed to be "the memory of the class" . What use is a "revolutionary party" which can't even remember its own policies and arguments of a few months ago? be dragged down by the fascist
----- pull-quotes -----
EYE ON THE LEFT By Mick