Sinn Fein drifts into a blind alley
Socialist Organiser1992 1992-06-25Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 11 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 11
Ano shit stema s Northern Ireland into a rigid stalemate yet again after the Anglo-Irish Agreement of 1985, Sinn Fein has become more decisively a narrow Catholic sectarian party. hasn't been a conscious process, indeed Gerry Adams is often at pains to stress the need to be aware of the fears of the Protestants. But Sinn Fein have come to represent not the historic republican goal of a united Irish people (Catholic, Protestant and Dissenter') but instead the immediate consciousness of the Catholics of the most depressed parts of the North Two years ago 1 happened to be in the New area during the local e cil elections and made a point of collecting all the party political material. The Sinn Fein material chose to dwell on one particular local issue. The bus services to nationalist area was poor, especially when compared to the services available in Protestant areas, they claimed; Sinn Fein, if elected, would do something about that.
The local council being attacked was not dominated by Unionists but by Sini Fein's nationalist rivals the SDLP. In the heat of an election battle amongst nationalist voters, Sinn Fein was accusing the SDLP of betraying nationalists, giving preferential treatment to Protestants. This is straightforward sectarian Catholic politics - it appeals to peoples' loyalty to their own 'religious" community; it presents politics as a way of advancing the interests of a particular community. There is no attempt to address the concerns of working people in general, as a class, Catholic and Protestant.
For Sinn Fein, political action is not about creatin an alliance of Protestants and Catholic workers in favour of a democratic alternative to partition. It is, instead, a competition between solely nationalist parties to create a majority amongst nationalists for a policy of armed struggle to force Britain to leave and the Protestants to see sense The West Belfast result the General Election -when Sinn Fein's Gerry Adams was defeated by SDLP → and Sinn Fein's reaction to it, give a graphic demonstration of the same problem.
The SDLP victory was seen as illegitimate because while they won the largest number of votes they didn't win the only important battle in the eyes of Sinn Fein - the battle for the nationalist vote. The SDLP's great sin was that Protestant voters from the Shankill voted for them to defeat Sinn Fein.
That shift in itself is worth considering for moment. There is no question of this Protestant SDLP vote being positive support. It was overwhelmingly a bid to remove Adams. But it is not something that has happened on this scale before. ment to The SDLP support a un ed Ireland. Their minimu interim settlement would involve power-sharing. They were central to the Power-sharing Assembly 1974. They are the chief backers of the Anglo-Iris! Agreement which brings IT Dublin involvement north.
Every one of these policies has been militantly, often violently, opposed the Protestants of West Belfast, above all in the general strike that destroyed powersharing 1974. That such Protestants decided to vote in the numbers they did, so that West Belfast will have an MP who will take up and use his seat, speaks volumes for the standing Sinn Fein amongst Protestants.
Sinn Fein's verbal guarantees mean nothing when combined with a campaign which can appear to have only one aim - the physical coercion of an entire community into a state to which they don't want to belong.
It's no good taking comfort from the idea that Protestants have always had this attitude to Sinn Fein, and it's all to be expected. The sizable Protestant vote for the SDLP is a shift.
Sinn Fein's strategy stands condemned as a failure not by some external British left standard but by the standards of any democratic Republicanism. It is daily making the likelihood of a united Irish Republic much more distant.
Any criticism of course raises more questions than can be briefly, glibly answered, but one conclusion, which Sinn Fein and their supporters on the British left need to heed, stands out.
The questions of what type of united Ireland could gain cross-commun support, what compromis es are necessary between the Six County communities, are not questions for another day, later, after withdrawal. They are the most urgent questions for any movement which aims to win British withdrawal and a democratic settlement.
If the West Belfast result could drive any of that home it would be a victory for those who want a united Ireland and a united Irish working class.
Scan page 12
ar DEPT
----- pull-quotes -----
¡EPOLITICALI FRONT
"Sinn Fein was accusing the SDLP of betraying nationalists, giving proferential treat-
Protestants. This straightorward sectarian Catholic