Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Can Scotland United get a result? MON

Socialist Organiser no. 528, 25 June 1992 · scan p. 11 · about 872 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 11 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 11

By Harry - Congress (STUC) has endorsed he Scottish Trade Union Scotland United, the group set up after the election by George Galloway and his supporters to campaign for a "multi-option referendum" on the constitutional future of Scotland. But the campaign faces enormous problems.

In the wake of Labour's defeat, the democratic demand for a Scottish Assembly has been flatly refused by a newly confident John Major. In fact, the Tories gained seats in Scotland, reversing their decline against all expectations.

Scotland United now looks set to push for an unofficial referendum, perhaps organised by the Confederation of Scottish Local Authorities (COSLA).

Socialists must say clearly that this is the road to disaster. It is fuelled by myths and illusions fostered by the nationalists and their allies in the Myth one: "75% of our people voted against the Tories" (STUC)

No, plenty of Scottish voters voted tactically against Labour and for the Nationalists or the LiberalDemocrats - both bourgeois parties. It's true that 75% of Scotland voted for parties other than the Tories, but if that was a simple tactical vote against the Tories, they would not have gained seats! Wishful thinking about the existence of an anti-Tory bloc in Scotland ignores the huge bedrock strength of Labour in the Scottish working class.

Myth two: "75% of our people voted for some form of Scottish Parliament" (STUC)

No, in opinion polls constitutional change came well down on the list after unemployment, the Health Service, education and taxation. There are plenty of unionists in the ranks of the Liberal-Democrats and the Labour Party, and a few Tories who favour an assembly. In the housing schemes of the central belt, and the leafy suburbs of Edinburgh, it was the class issues that were decisive.

Myth three: "The politicians must put people before party - our Scottish Parliament would be about co-operation, compromise and consensus, not the moth-eaten Westminster variety" (STUC).

Co-operation, compromise and consensus with whom? Over what?

There is no unifying "national interest" in Scotland, especially after the democratic demand for an assembly has been satisfied. All this can mean is co-operation with bourgeois parties, with 'patriotic' Scottish bosses. It means compromise and sell-out in the class struggle. And what is the contrast with Westminster here?

If Westminster lacks consensus and compromise (which comes as news to me) it's only because the two big parties represent the interests of the bosses on the one hand, and of the labour movement, with all its faults, on the other.

Do we really want a Parliament that is more passive against capitalism than Westminster? There are two other ideas here - first, that 'our people' (whose people?) are innately more 'reasonable' or 'progressive' than the English electors - a deeply chauvinist argument. And, second, there is an implied grovelling to the Tory government: "Please, please give us a Scottish Parliament, secure us our careers, and we promise not to misbehave or to cause any trouble for your capitalist rule."

Myth four: On the level of strategy, Scotland United argue that 'parliamentary disruption' and an unofficial referendum are the way forward. In this they are backed by Scottish Militant Labour who call for a 'Socialist Scottish Assembly' as if it were on offer, and a COSLA referendum.

Parliamentary disruption, yes - but not the slightly comical sight of John McAllion crying out "I spy strangers", and a couple of bemused Canadian tourists being escorted out of the visitors' gallery.

Indeed we must argue for generalised and serious disruption in Parliament. But an unofficial COSLA referendum is a disaster waiting to happen.

Look at the facts: the District election turnout was thirty per cent. Labour voters who failed to turn out in May will not bother to vote on an issue whose result makes little or no difference anyway.

Scotland United would be lucky get a ten per cent turnout in a COSLA referendum. And, at that level, they would be lucky to win, since Tory unionists would seize the chance to deal a death blow to the demand for an assembly. It's a funny sort of publicity stunt that offers a big chance of victory to your opponents and a huge risk of making yourselves look idiots.

The antics of Scotland United are fuelled by an understandable wish to do something in the wake of the general election. One of its organisers told me that he had kept his head down for long enough, Labour couldn't win again, and that the Scottish question is the 'only show in town. But it isn't.

Privatisation of the railways, hospital opt-outs, the threats to jobs from the new round of local authority cutbacks - all these and more give us opportunities to fight back against the Tories. They should not be counterposed to the demand for a referendum as the SWP imagine, but neither should Scotland United kid anyone that it can displace Labour in Scotland - for the subtext of all this is another attempt at the ill fated Jim Sillars' Scottish Labour Party minus Jim Sillars this time, Sillars having fled politics for his fat, Middle Eastern business consultancy.

Scottish socialists need now, more than ever, to keep politically sober. Scotland United contributes nothing to that task.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 528

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →