Andrew Neil: Republican campaigner?
Socialist Organiser1992 1992-06-25Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 6 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 6
How the royals have fallen in esteem
HESS GANGI The most interesting (some would say, the only interesting) aspect of the continuing Diana/Charles/Royal marriage/suicide bid row is the mounting speculation about motives. Specifically, the motives of the Sunday Times and its publicity-hungry editor, Mr Andrew Neil.
Simple folk like me naturally assumed that Mr Neil had only one motive when he decided to shell out between £250,000 and £275,000 on exclusive serialisation rights to the Andrew Morton book: boosting the circulation and profits of his newspaper. We barked with knowing, derisive laughter as the oleaginous Mr Neil appeared on our TV screens in, variously, concerned mode (expressing sympathy for the plight of the poor, tormented Princess) and self-righteous mode (this is a matter of Public Interest, the Right to Know etc). Mr Neil is not a convincing performer and - it has to be said - the camera is not kind to him at the best of times.
But perhaps we underestimated this canny son of the Manse. For some time, the more bufferish sections of the Tory press (notably The Spectator and The Sunday Telegraph) have been making a point of referring to the alleged 'republican sympathies' of Mr Neil and his boss, Mr Murdoch. The Independent magazine's "Weasel' (the high-Tory Alexander Chancellor - very much part of the bufferish tendency), spelled it out this Saturday: "As time goes on, Mr Neil's denials that he is leading a republican campaign become more and more difficult to believe. The way he talks, and the way his paper has presented Mr Morton's revelations about the Princess of Wales, seem designed to diminish as much as possible the esteem in which the monarchy is held. It is high time he admitted it."
Now, this kind of outburst can, in part, be put down to a continuation by other means, of the splendid "Neil and Times Newspapers vs. Worsthorne and the Sunday Telegraph" case of 1990.
This highly-entertaining farce was sparked by a Sunday Telegraph editorial attacking Andrew Neil for his association with Ms Pamella Bordes, including the accusation that Neil inhabited "a sleazy demimonde". Neil, in reply, accused Peregrine Worsthorne (the author of the attack) of being part of a "Garrick Club Mafia" made up of gin-sodden reactionaries and snobs, out of tune with the thrusting, dynamic spirit of Mrs Thatcher's meritocratic Britain. contemporary Conservatism...
It was an inter-Tory conflict that (in Neil's words) boiled down to "New Britain vs. the Snobbery". Neil won his case, but received only derisory damages.
The sniping has continued ever since, with Neil using his "Atticus" column in the Sunday Times for regular attacks and the Garrick Club Mafia returning the fire from the Sunday Telegraph and Spectator.
The question of the -Tory rebels 1o onliat Thatcher chy probably encapsulates this dispute within contemporary Conservatism, but the idea that meritocrat Neil is on a conscious, deliberate republican campaign seemed a little far-fetched to me until this week's Sunday Times appeared. In it, the political commentator Robert Harris (admittedly, a maverick Labour supporter) condemns the Labour leadership for being "supine" on the monarchy and suggests that such threat to the future of the House of Windsor as exists comes not from the left but from the right"
He goes on to confess to "rather enjoying the discomfiture of the Spectator/Sunday Telegraph crowd as they bewail what is happening to the monarchy. At last something they love is being gnawed at by the beasts they helped unleash in 1979. For 13 years they found the right wing, rottweiler tabloids harmless enough, because they shared their prejudices about socialism and helped return Tory governments. Now they want them muzzled". Harris is his own man, and a good socialist. But that was the voice of Andrew Neil; for once in my life I agree with him.
----- pull-quotes -----
"The question of the monarchy probably encapsulates this dispute within