The Maxwells and the discipline of the market
Socialist Organiser1992 1992-06-25Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 5 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 5
Reynolds
f you owe a bank £100, said the economist Maynard Keynes, then you have a problem. If you owe the bank a million pounds, then the bank has a problem.
Likewise, if you steal £9, then you have a problem; if you steal £900 million, then the people you steal from have a problem!
Robert Maxwell, who stole, on current estimates, about £448 million from his companies' pension funds, and £485 million from the companies themselves, is dead and has no more problems. His sons Kevin and lan were arrested last week, with their sidekick Larry Trachtenberg, on criminal charges of fraud, and also face civil proceedings in which the liquidators of Maxwell investment companies are claiming £850 million from them.
They have hired the most expensive lawyers, and they can almost certainly delay any final verdicts in these court cases for several years. At the end of it, they may go to jail - like Alan Bond, Ivan Boesky, Michael Millken, Ernest Saunders, and other capitalist heroes of the 1980s - but probably only for a short spell.
They may well be able to pull a trick like Roger Seelig, who had his court case in the Guinness scandal stopped because the judge reckoned that the stress and strain might make Seelig suicidal. (No magistrate stops a poll tax prosecution because of the strain on the non-payer, even though a number of people have killed themselves because of poll tax problems!)
Or like former Guinness boss Ernest Saunders, Who won early release from jail on the grounds that he had the irreversible and devastating Alzheimer's disease, then once free magically "recovered" and has now been awarded a £70,000-ayear pension from Guinness.
Or like Ivan Boesky, who "bought" a deal with US prosecutors by shopping Michael Milken and others, and emerged from a short spell in a "country club" jail still a multi-millionaire.
The workers who lost their jobs in Maxwell's feverish manipulations, or are losing them now as the Maxwell business empire crumbles, will have a much harder time. So, probably, will the Maxwell company pensioners, reliant now on short-term and uncertain handouts from the government to make good their pensions.
As the Financial Times put it in a big series last week on the Maxwell affair: "No-one stopped [Maxwell] committing one of the biggest business frauds of the century. One after the other, the lines of defence failed: directors, banks, trustees, pension regulators, and the Bank of England".
They could have added: financial journalists; and the Government itself. According to a former secret service official, Robin Robison, Maxwell was "bugged" by the secret service, and the tapes and transcripts provided adequate evidence of his scams.
Maxwell - and, it seems, his sons - got away with it because in capitalist boom times like the 1980s sufficiently bold and wellconnected swindlers almost always get away with it.
The "discipline" of the credit, which turn depends their power in thi market-place. As long as they can keep up a show of great wealth and big profits, they keep extending their credit* market, which bears down so heavily on the jobless, the worker who does exhausting overtime to raise a living wage, or the desperate family juggling bills and debts in order to stay fed and clothed and avoid eviction from their home, is much lighter for the rich.
Their power in the marketplace depends on their credit, which in turn depends on their power in the marketplace. As long as they can keep up a show of great wealth and big profits, they can keep extending their credit. Maxwell's companies could borrow tens of millions of pounds from the banks casually, with a phone call -the banks sometimes not bothering to collect the assets serving as security for the loan - while a worker, or even a small business, would have to sweat and haggle to raise a thousand pounds.
Bankers are not all stupid. Many of them must have suspected that Maxwell's finances were shady or crooked. But as long as the spiral of credit kept turning -as long as they got their repayments - why should they complain? A complaint would cut off lucrative business, and, by pushing down the price of the shares which the banks held as security for their loans, it would make it harder for them to get their money back.
In the sphere of high finance, the market does not enforce efficiency, costcutting, and straight dealing. Just the opposite: it encourages bluff, display, excess, swindling.
And yet the governments of Western Europe, in the Maastricht Treaty, are now committing themselves to making their central banks, and a future European Central Bank, independent of all political control.
Any government, they argue, will be inclined to manipulate the money supply and interest rates for electoral advantage, with bad economic results. Only "denationalisation under bankers' control" can create a properly disciplined economy.
The Maxwell affair gives us a measure of the worth of that discipline. Public ownership, with workers' and democratic control, is still the only way to stop the rich ripping off the poor! selection, not as the supreme artist of physical perfection but as a sort of bodger, fixing up a problem today with no thought to the consequences tomorrow.
He started with an intriguing coincidence: that both human and sparrow populations living in the cold North tend to have short squat bodies and limbs while those in the South are more slender with longer limbs. Thus the Inuit are more stocky than the Masai. Similarly with the sparrows of northern and southern Europe and North America.
Creationists believe that this reflects the thoughtful ness of God in conserving heat in the cold or for losing it in the hot.
18th century theologian, William Paley, saw the human body as exquisitely designed for its purpose. He argued that, just as the discovery of a welldesigned watch would imply the existence of a watchmaker, the existence of a perfectly adapted human body implied the existence of a Supreme Designer.
The problem for this view, at least in the case of the sparrow, is that sparrows were only introduced into America about 100 years ago from England. Since then they have spread throughout the con tinent and acquired the differences in shape already seen in Europe. How has this happened?
The answer is natural selection acting on the natural variation in the population of birds from England. Those with longer, slimmer bodies survived and bred better in the South and vice versa in the North. The need for a conscious designer has been dispensed with.
A sort of mirror image to the creationists' argument is the view that all species to keep going. The malaria parasite breeds inside red blood cells, bursting out simultaneously in their thousands to infect more. This leads to worse and worse crises and is often fatal. Even now, malaria is one of the greatest killers o children, killing millions.
A chance mutation in the gene for haemoglobin gave rise to red blood cells that collapsed into a sickle shape when invaded by a malaria parasite. This slowed down the growth o the parasites so much so that a child with one copy of the mutated gene had 90% protection from malaria.
Unfortunately, a child with two copies of the gene was very seriously disabled as its red blood cells would collapse all the time, leading to blockages of the capillaries, weakness and extreme pain.
Jones likens this response of natural selection to a challenge to clutching at a straw. Rather than superbly designed, the bodies of humans are rather Heath Robinson affairs. Other responses to diseases have led to problems like cystic fibrosis (the CF gene protects against death from dysentery) and Tay-Sachs Disease (the TS gene protects against tuberculosis).
Jones believes that human civilisation has significantly reduced the effect of natural selection on humans as infectious diseases have been largely limited as causes of death. He speculates that different pattern of fertility (smaller families, later parenthood, survival of premature babies) may have some effect on human evolutio The impact of AIDS in some parts of the world may lead to the survival and spread of mutations resistant to the virus. Perhaps they will have drawbacks similar to tho of the genes for sickle cel disease or cystic fibrosis,
Scan page 6
Organiser ¡RAFFIT
----- pull-quotes -----
"Their power market-place depends on th