Honest, Catholic
Socialist Organiser1992 1992-06-18Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 14 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 14
While I hope that no one would disagree with Paddy Dollard (SO 525) in holding that Noel Browne was that very rare thing - an honest politician - 1 am afraid Noel deceived himself and your comrade in saying that his Health Scheme was based on that of the British Labour Government and that his views were then Bevanite.
In 1951 Noel founded a Party called the Progressive Democrats. The Secretary was David Thornley, who was a contemporary of mine in college.
I asked about policy. Noel said it hadn't yet been decided. I asked: (a) whether it was socialist? and (b) if not, whether socialists were allowed to join. Though I had been in the RCP, subscribed to Freedom, Socialist Leader, Socialist Outlook, etc., I was not then a member of any group, but called myself a Bevanite.
He replied (a) no, it was not and (b) well, perhaps a Gaitskellite socialist might be permitted.
I was involved sufficiently closely to see how Browne later developed into a socialist; but he had not so done when I left Dublin in 1956.
When I say that Browne did not then think of himself as a socialist, I should add that even David Thornley only regarded himself as a Progressive Conservative though by the time I left college he did define this as being "something like Socialist Review"
Browne and his associates in 1951 were insistent that their Bill was unlike Bevan's. It was modelled on the social teaching of Pope Leo. They had consulted the Vatican, which had approved the Bill, and, indeed, the Vatican had instructed Archbishop McQuaid to withdraw his opposition.
McQuaid got round this by starting the rumour that "pressure had been brought to bear on the bishops" (with the obvious implication that it was pressure from outside the church).
It was on this basis that, a little while later, Browne wound his group up and went into Fianna Fail, which then pushed through a reworded version of the Health Bill. Even when Fianna Fail failed to renominate him at the subsequent election, he was in favour of accepting it.
David nominated him without his consent, and campaigned for him sufficiently vigorously to get him elected. That was how his party was recreated, but it too was non-socialist, although it permitted socialist membership. The socialist members formed the 1913 Club as the socialist wing of the Browne party, but were later forced to leave.
Laurens Otter Salop