A tragedy, not a tearjerke
Socialist Organiser1992 1992-06-18Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 13 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 13
Film helpless refugees, many are children. «Turtle Beach" is rather clumsily done, and it doesn't always tranWeaver scend cliched ideas about character Beach" and plot, but it's more worthwhile than most other films in town, hurtle Beach" is a both because of its subject and Malaysian beach where because the feeling behind it came Vietnamese refugees, the through, despite everything. "boat people", are trying to land It's a sad movie, seen through the after days at sea. It is the late eyes of Judith Wilkes, a rather 1970s. Instead of finding sympathy driven Australian journalist who and help, the refugees struggle wants to expose the horrors the through the sea to be met by boat people are going through. Malaysian villagers, armed with If Judith were a man, she'd be knives and machetes, ready to cliche - the reporter who neglects hack, drown or bludgeon them, everything, including family, in the rather than let them come ashore. quest for the big story - but The massacres are repeated time because she's a woman, we can see and time again. The police arrive, that she's torn between her two but always just a little too late to sons, and wanting something for prevent the villagers exacting herself - a career she believes in.
She's committed. Though she their revenge on the weak and wants to tell the story (and make her name), she also wants to help, even if it means risking her life. She's aided in her investigations by Minou, an ex-Saigon bar girl now married to the Australian Commissioner for Refugees. Like Judith, Minou is separated from the children, who are still in Vietnam. She's desperate to get them out, paying thousands to black marketeers and spivs for information and assistance. Joan Chen as Minou carries the story. She's believable and pitiable. When you see her clinging to her hopes about her children, her determination to salvage their lives out of the chaos and wreck of post-war Vietnam, you see the fragility and desperation too. Like many refugees, Minou can live in the past, with their memories, or in the future, with her hopes; but she can't live for now. the present is a waiting room, a limbo, an indeterminate sentence.
The best and saddest scenes in the film are set in the refugee camps, where everyone, even the children, tries to catch the eye of people who can help them. As Judith walks through, appalled by the stink and the crowding the forlorn optimist, you see her crumple, and you know how she feels.
For Minou, it's even harder. Every face might be the face of one of her children. She can never relax.
What happens to Minou and her children makes Judith realise how fragile families can be, and how near she has come to losing her own children. When she rushes home, she isn't capitulating or conforming; she's simply become more human. She wants to find a way to work at what she cares about without shortchanging her kids.
There wasn't a dry eye in the audience by the end, but it wasn't a tearjerker. it was a tragedy. There are 16 million refugees in the world today, many living in even worse conditions than the boat people in Malaysia. The film showed the horror of that, the wrecked lives, the broken families, the emotional cost of punishing helpless, terrified people, of forcing people to live on top of each other in filthy camps.
A film that tries to make us care about that is worth a hundred Batmans and Lethal Weapons. School. They live in big houses, they drive their own expensive cars to school, they wear fashionable clothes, the sun always shines, and they all have clear, healthy - and white - skin. "The show is an ad for consumerism and status" , as American critic James Wolcott puts it. Producer Barney Diller adds: "This is about family values".
But this is not the 1950s (and if it were, the producers would probably be less frantically emphatic about the comfort and luxury of the students' families). This is the 1990s, and so the show has to deal with AIDS, drugs, racism, and so on.
Jamie Kellner, boss of the TV company that produces the show, puts it like this: "Without them (the issues], it would be a very unimportant show".
On the evidence of the one episode I have seen, Beverly Hill 90210 deals with such issues by trying to neutralise them and absorb them.
The episode was about racism and the uncontrolled violence of the private security forces which now have 75,000 employees in Los Angeles County. Even those issues provided only enough disturbance to keep a plot going for the 55 minutes of the show.
By the end, everybody is happy, and the syrup is running smoothly again. The Walsh family (who form the centre of the show) cancel their subscription to the private security firm. They all become the best of friends with the wealthy, urbane black family who have moved in their street. The black family's daughter has a working-class boyfriend back in the black getto, but he turns out to be "the one his mother never had to worry about", and she is reunited with him.
All is for the best in the best of all possible suburbs, and if we cannot quite forget there is a nastier world just a few miles away in South Central Los Angeles, at least we can put it to the back of our minds.
The show helped me understanı how bourgeois America can carry on sleepwalking towards barbarism.
----- pull-quotes -----
"The film showed the horror... the wrecked lives, the broken families, the emotional cost"
show ad for consumerism and status"