WHO IS AGAINST MAASTRECHT AND WHY Send entromena samantal There is also nationalist opposition, Commonwealth - i.e. the ex-Empire
Socialist Organiser1992 1992-06-18Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 11 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 11
and environmental standards in the name of Irish independence. - as a more progressive alternative would be harmed by pressure to get The same nationalist theme is common standards across the EC. strong in France, where both the Others fear that closer European fascist ational Front and the integration would mean more immi- Communist Party play on the threat stream left" alternative to the EC. grants coming into Denmark, and to "French sovereignty" represented The Marxist left in Britain initially more Danish money going in EC aid by closer European integration. to poorer EC countries like Greece, In Italy and the other smaller or ed, in the early 1960s - said that Many are simply hostile to the EC hostility to the EC, which has visibly nor Commonwealth, nor an isolated as a bureaucratic set-up which they helped them economically. blame, to one extent or another, for βIn Britain, the big majority of the bosses' Euro-integration with intertha mamnlavmont cute and ern- ruline class is keen to get Britain on national workers' unitv. not the bosses tremendously from the EC, pouring in investment for this wider market. The paradoxical resu ilt has been to make the EC today a i challenger to the US's suprema icy in the capitalist world.
Britain's trade with the EEC grew, to 31% of its total by 1972, and the UK, Denmark and Southern Ireland joined the EEC in 1972-3. Greece joined in 1981 and Spain and Portugal in 1986.
"Just to say No to Maastricht! Yes to a socialist Europe!' is to omit the equally necessary slogan: 'No to a nationalist Europi of competing nation-states!"."
Even from a capitalist point of view, however, the EC is a very limited form of international integration. Many barriers to trade within it still exist. All frontier controls on people and goods are due to come down, "from Limerick to Lesbos", by 1 January 1993, but Britain, for example, has said it will continue border checks on people.
A common monetary system is a long way off. Movement of capital is not fully free. "Cross frontier" mergers of companies have flopped; so have joint ventures like Airbus.
At each economic or political jolt, the EC is thrown into crisis and only long, wearisome negotiations between the different states can patch together a compromise to keep going.
From a socialist point of view, a lot worse can be said about the EC. It has all the vices of capitalism writ large. It faces the Third World as an imperialist consortium. The Common Agricultural Policy means not only high food prices in the EC for the sake of fat profits for big capitalist farmers, but also massive surpluses while millions starve and high tariff walls round the EC for agricultural producers in the Third World wishing to export to it.
The EC, however, is not a particular "bad policy" of capitalism which can be amputated from the system to provide better conditions for the working class to fight in. It is a reflection of the most fundamental economic trends of capitalism.
The economic integration of Western Europe began before the EC; the EC is only a set of arrangements to accommodate and accelerate it amount of calls for "Britain out" will turn the economic clock Some Danes fear that their Spain and Portugal.
nomic crises which have developed since 1972/3, when Denmark joined the EC.
In Germany, right wingers fear that a Euro-currency, influenced by comparatively poor and shaky EC economies, would be less stable than their cherished Deutschmark.
Left-wingers object that the treaty does not go far enough in European integration, because it leaves the European Parliament still feeble, with all key decisions still to be taken by haggling between the 12 governments.
In Ireland, the strongest opposition is from Catholic anti-abortionists, who fear that Maastricht's call for citizens to be able to move freely within Europe could mean that Irish women could back and abolish the huge scale of modern capitalist industry and its interconnections. If capitalism did not have the EC, then it would inevitably have another arrangement differing only in details - or the only alternative is that it would have a murderous battle between the big capitalist states of Western Europe over which of them would growth freely go abroad for abortions. poorer EC countries there is less the "inside track" in the EC. It was for that reason, as much as for the poll tax fiasco,. that they forced out Margaret Thatcher.
Thatcherite hostility to the ECapparently based on trying to make Britain a cheap-labour, free market offshore economy, free of the social welfare and workers' rights which encumber continental capitalism, and attractive to US and Japanese capital - does, however, command a significant minority of the ruling class, and a large section of the small-business class and of the Tory party.
The bulk of the Labour left has always been anti-EC on a nationalist basis, though its voice has become less certain as its alternatives have faded. In the early 1960s integrate the region in the form of making the other states it vassals. To call for countries to withdraw from the EC is as foolish and reactionary as calling for the great capitalist multinational corporations to be broken up into smaller units.
an international workthere was much talk of the to the EC. In the 1970s, a siege economy, surrounded by heavy import controls, was the "main- when British entry was first mootworkers should favour neither EC, capitalist Britain, but respond to the BARRASJ In the 1970s, when nationalist agitation against the EC reached a high point, almost all the Marxist groups scrapped their principles, went with the prevailing "left" wind, and shouted for "Britain Out!" Workers Fight, a forerunner of Socialist Organiser, was the only left paper to stick to its principles.
For some years now the antiEuronean far left has fallen into an embarrassed silence, but the Danisi referendum vote has spurred some of them to jump onto the nationalist bandwagon again.
Socialist Worker has returned to its line of before 1971, without any explanation of why it argued differently for 20 years, from 1971 onwards!
ing class fight against international capitalism.
We need the economic and social reconstruction of Europe in the interests of the working class - by way of building on the post war integration of the West European economy, seizing control of it rather than seeking to unscramble it.