Greed for profit le Rio treaties toothi
Socialist Organiser1992 1992-06-18Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 8
Of the attendance of 117 presidents and prime ministers were an indication of the importance of the Earth Summit, then we should be able to feel fairly optimistic about the world's future. However, the attendance probably says more about the importance of looking like you're doing something!
The suspicion is confirmed when we see what has actually come out of the biggest gathering of the world's leaders ever. Let us remind ourselves of the issues that needed to be addressed.
There was the question of deforestation. Many of the developed countries have lost a large proportion of their original forests. Britain now has perhaps 5% of its forest cover left, a substantial proportion lost this century:
Even the little that is left is not safe - just recently the Government decided to force through the destruction of the ancient Oxleas Wood in south The US and Canada are busy logging their Pacific Coast forests. Better-known is the destruction of tropical forests in Third World countries, proceeding in some cases at a rate of up to 5% a year! Sometimes the forests are being replaced by plantations of just one type of tree, for production of pulp etc.
In all cases, there is a serious loss of plant and animal species George "Read My Lips: 'the Planet Can go to Hell'" Bush made 30 years as the forests are destroyed. There is also an increase in the amount of carbon dioxide in the atmosphere as the carbon locked up in the forests is released during borning or rotting.
Agreement on ways of preventing, limiting, or repairing the damage is vital, but none was forthcoming from the summit. India and Malaysia led Third World opposition to what was seen as interference in their exploitation of their resources. There was no Forest Convention, but instead a set of non-binding Forest Principles was agreed.
Then there was the question of biodiversity, the range of different forms of life.
This has been seriously damaged through the activities of humans, most notably in the last 30 years or so. Factory ships have overfished the seas; forests have been replaced by cattle pasture; animals have become rarer as their habitats are destroyed or split up.
At the same time, fortunes are being made from products deriving from plants and animals found in Third World countries. Anti-cancer drugs from the rosy periwinkle of Madagascar are the basis of a $160 million industry. Genetic stocks of those food crops which originate in the Third World (virtually all of them!) are patented by agricultural giants, so that poorer countries have to pay to use what were originally their own resources. "The most important medium term problem is that of climate change due the release of carbo dioxide and other 'greenhouse' gases. Rio saw the signing oi a treaty to combat the release of carbon dioxide, but one with absolutely no teeth at all."
he Treaty on Biodiversity aims to preserve wild areas with exceptionally high levels of diversity but also to encourage the "sustainable development of biological resources" Such a strategy has been adopted by drug company Merck and Costa Rica. Merck will prospect for plants with useful pharmaceutical properties while funding conservation and a national biological research centre.
But that is just one agreement. The treaty contains nothing to force countries to protect their own diversity of life, though it provides for the developed contries to help the less developed. That will cost money - and there is little promise of that in any statement by the richer countries.
The US refused to sign the Treaty on Biodiversity, and in theory could be refused access to the resources of signatory coun tries. Compliant governments and dubious commercial practices should help them get round that.
Probably the most important medium to long term problem is that of climate change due to the release of carbon dioxide and other 'greenhouse' gases. Rio saw the signing of a treaty to combat the release of carbon dioxide, but one with absolutely no teeth at all.
Climate scientists are almost unanimous in predicting some global warming, together with negative consequences, such as the raising of sea levels as ice caps melt or disruption of pat terns of rainfall.
"The key to all the agreements is cash. was estimated that an extra $40 billion per year - three or four Canary Wharve - in aid from the developed countries were required.
Pledges of new money amounting less than $1 billion a small fraction of one Canary Whart, were made!"
The former could lead to th oss of low-lying coastal land often the most populous, and even the forced abandonment of some islands, as the prime minister of Tuvalu told the summit. The latter could lead to agricultural disasters much worse than
Scan page 9
ats and saving species
----- pull-quotes -----
looks at the Earth Summit