Backlash personified? Maybe no
Socialist Organiser1992 1992-06-18Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 6 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 6
WOMEN'S FYE Only determined listenevery one or Camil Paglia's words on the "Late Show" last week. This woman talks fast. She also enrages people; especially feminists and the so-called Politically Correct, who are the target of many of her attacks.
She's an American academ ic who's flavour of the mont with the media because she argues that all the great achievements of civilisation were the work of men.
Is she the backlash personi fied?
Her ego is certainly big"Who is the better role model for women," she asks "Gloria Steinem or Kate Millet, with their self-esteem problems, or me? I have no self-esteem problems!"
She ignores the fact that women have self-esteem problems not because they want to, but because they'r raised that way - in the fam ly and in society at large. Women are belittled, ignored, ridiculed, beaten Though Paglia trumpets male achievement in her book, "Sexual Personae", claims women are better. They're less violent, for example, less one-track, more in tune with nature because of their reproducti systems. But she's not a bic logical determinist. Gender not fate, she says. Women must strive to remove all social barriers to their advancement. (She doesn't say how.)
She claims that American feminism is stuck in an "ado lescent whining mode", blaming men for everything. Strong women should have no fear of strong men, she says, and anyway men are weak; women nant sex.
Confused? I was.
I agree with her that a "vic tim culture" is bad. Some American feminists, with their almost exclusive focus. on rape and pornography as the key elements of women oppression, do foster the ide of women-as-victims. Feminism here has been infected with that virus (though not lethally). We should focus instead on work, pay, childcare, and reproductive rights, areas where women can organise and fight back.
Paglia is against the nonsensical Politically Correct (PC) movement which wants to banish all Dead White European Males (DWEMs) from school curricula and replace them with a ragbag of examples from a range of cultures. It's not the widening of references that's bad about PC, but the refusal by its adherents to acknowledge that one thing could be better than another; it equates the Sistine Chapel with a homemade quilt.
In contrast, Paglia says study everything, from Judeo-Christianity, Gracco Roman paganism, to Buddhism, Hinduism, Islam and so on. But it must be the best from each tradition, she says. She has an idea of hierarchical feminism.
She has a point. Many of the PC proponents want to banish thinkers like Freud on Marx from the curriculum. Paglia rightly says people neer to say une whole sweep of history, not just the narrow confines of their own ethnic group.
She also loathes the influence of the French structuralists and post structuralists. I'm with her on tha one!
Much of what Paglia says sensible, while the "outrageous" stuff has probably been pumped up by the media and the right wing to hammer the feminists. In her desire to be famous and celebrated, Paglia has allowed the media to use her, and in using her, to distort and hype up her ideas to sell papers.
She may not be the backlash, but she's riding its wave.
Scan page 7
German steel workers from IG Metall during their strike in 1978. These workers have agreed to stand by their Brazilian comrades in their wage battle in July Dieser maiT Betrieb These workers Socialist Organiser No. 527 page 7 Dieser Betrieb
----- pull-quotes -----
"greatness", an idea lost, she claims, in egalitarian anti-