Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Legal controls on the way?

Socialist Organiser no. 527, 18 June 1992 · scan p. 6 · about 568 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 6 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 6

"We had no idea we were privileged"

PRESS GANG You didn't have to be a genius to predict that the Sunday Times' serialisation of Andrew Morton's "Diana" book would spark off an orgy of royal "revelations" in the rest of the press. And you didn't have to be a genius to predict that that would stir up the old privacy/press freedom argument and the prospect of statutory press controls.

Eighteen months ago, the Calcutt committee delivered its damning report on press standards in Britain, but concluded that an "overwhelming case for introducing a statutory test of infringement of privacy has not so far been made out... Our grounds for deciding against include arguments of principle, practical concerns and the availability of other options for tackling the problems which we have identified." Instead, Calcutt proposed establishing a new mechanism for press selfregulation (the Press Complaints Commission) and three new criminal offences of journalistic trespass, which affect the acquisition of material, not its publication. Calcutt's decision against statutory controls was very much "on balance" and then-Home Secretary Douglas Hurd drove the message home by putting the press "on probation" for eighteen months.

Up until last week's Sunday Times-led outbreak of Di/Chas hysteria, the press appeared to have taken some heed of the warnings, and even the Sun and Star cleaned up their act somewhat. Now, with the eighteen month probation period about to expire, all hell has broken loose.

A group of front bench Labour MPs have drawn up a private member's bill to regulate "the freedom and responsibility of the press", which would pave the way for a statutory complaints body. Lord McGregor, the chair of the Press Complaints Commission, rushed out a statement condemning the "prurient reporting" of sections of the press and accusing journalists of "dabbling their fingers in the stuff of other people's souls" (a quote from Virginia Woolf, so I'm told). No sooner did the statement appear, however, than two of the editors who sit alongside Lord McGregor on the PPC (Brian Hitchen of the Star and Patsy Chapman of the News of the World) let it "It is impossible to conceive of any form of statutory control that would not, il practice, inhibit genuine investigative journalism"

be known that they dissented. The Express and the Sun attacked the statement in print. When David Mellor comes to review the state of the press and the role of the PPC next month, the pressure to introduce some form of statutory controls may well be almost irresistible.

But a few points need to be made at this stage - first and foremost that, distasteful and hypocritic as much of the preser royal reporting may be there is considerabl evidence that the lovel Princess Di did co-opera with the Morton book a has not exactly discourage a lot of the rest of th coverage.

Secondly, while socialists will sympathis with the motive of thos MPs who want to use th present furore to curb th Tory press (and perhap punish it for its electio coverage) it is impossible 1 conceive of any form o statutory control that woul not, in practice, inhibi genuine investigativ journalism and giv protection to the rich an influential th Parkinsons, Archers an Maxwells. The Britis press (and not just th tabloids) is a disgrace. Bo statutory controls brough in on the back of thi present "Diana" row wil only make matters worse.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 527

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →