Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Green Without Offence

Socialist Organiser no. 526, 11 June 1992 · scan pp. 13–14 · about 947 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 13 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 13

Hollywood movie ever. is 50 years old. There is something in it greater than Lorre, Greenstreet. Veidt it includes a And there is an invocation of a possi period which exposed anti-semitism, magnetically by a tremendously tal and editing. The mystery is why it still muted by talent - as heat transmutes committed film The villains really are yet unrealised hopes of that age fall scientists were as sloppy as the ones in "Medicine Man"

there wouldn't be a cure for anything. I spotted the lost magic ingredient of the film's cancer cure about halfway through, but it took forever for the dummies in the film to cotton on.

By Lick Ackers/ey Casablanca. perhaps the most popular and still going strong A fresh new print is being issued to mark the anniversary. The cast is won derful. of course Bogart, Bergman number of German relugees from Hitler tor example the nasty Nazi colonel was Conrad Veid:

In Britain, in the mid 30s. he had made one of the rare movies of ine Jew Suss based en the historical novel of the same name by Lion Felichtwanger who aiso wrote a book. "Moscow 1937 Justifying the Moscow Trals In 1940 the Nazis made a notorious anti-semitic him of the same name By contrast with the anti-fascists, the Swede Ingrid Bergman had eagerly gone to work in Nazi Germany, and had tried, even after the war started to keep open the option of going back ful cast and by competent direction "works"

Perhaps the explanation lies in this within its romantic conventions, it is a The film is pitched too low. It makes its plea for the preservation of the Amazon wilderness, but it does it so predictably that the audience has nodded off before they get to it.

The plot is ancient, whiskered. Gruff scientist in jungle finds miracle cure. He doesn't want girl assistant sent by distant drug company. She has to prove herself. Then their enterprise is threatened by hostile forces, which they fight together. End of story. Hollywood villains, the good guy reluctant but all the more convincing when he gets going the individual lives of the characters. compared to which their attairs are not worth a hill of beans Rick/Bogart says ble better world to be had for the fighting In short, the film shows the world of official "Allied" World War 2 propa ganda, hardened and made to gleam ented team. It is the same "official anti-fascist world which the British people took seniously enough in 1945 to pursue it by dismissing the respect ed Tory war leader Winston Churchill and electing, by a landslide, a Labour government pledged to radical change Maybe it is the film's power still to evoke that mood and take its audience into it for a while, away from our own commercial capitalist civilisation grub by and soulless but unashamed - that explains Casablanca's continuing appeal The collection of corny cliches trans carbon into syrthetic diamonds - into a prism for the ideas of an age still conveys to us some glimmer of the as has made the same film over and over again. Only the scenery changes.

Familiarity can have its charms. The film is safe, it doesn't offend anybody. But it ought to.

If it really is saying we should "The film is a muddle that meanders on it would sink without trace."

stop destroying the rainforests, then it should do so in a more aggressive way - by ending in a downbeat way, perhaps, rather than having no-longer-grumpy Campbell and now-acceptable Rae go off to a new start, smiles and hopes intact.

The film does try to tackle the ruin of the jungle by progress, but it doesn't have any ideas about where "progress" comes from, or whom it serves. The road that threatens the plants Campbell needs for his cancer research is never explained (why is it being built? where is it meant to lead?) -it's just there to be the bad guy.

The film has a lordly way ignoring anything deep "inconvenient"

Presumably the presence of friendly Brazilian Indians is meant to be another plea - save the forest, it's their home. No-one could want to hurt this tribe. They're full of smiles, their whole life is one long gambol in the sunshine, never interrupted by work, the getting of food, or anything that could disrupt paradise. They have something (what?) that western civilisation could learn from.

Hollywood always does this. It romanticises primitive people, it turns them into saints, so that its plea to save them can be justified. The corollary of this is sinisterthat flawed people don't deserve to live.

The Brazilian Indians, and the rainforest that they live in, is not worth saving because it's perfect, or because it matches some L.A. film director's idea of the (unspoiled) Garden of Eden. The Indians have a right to their land; precious rainforest and wilderness should not be destroyed merely to satisfy capitalist greed and waste.

If Hollywood could understand that, then films like "Medicine Man" would make better watching.

As it is, the film is a muddle that meanders on without knowing where it's going. Without Sean Connery as Campbell, it would sink without trace.

The way it's made, you realise some Americans do have a need for tribes like the ones in "Medicine Man". They're fast running out of people they can patronise. That's one endangered species they've always been keen to protect.

Scan page 14

lis

----- pull-quotes -----

Belinda Weaver reviews "Medicine Man"

Yet the film is a bale of old B-movie cliches, given life only by the wonder-

without knowing where it's going. Without Sean Connery as Campbell,

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 526

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →