Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Revolution Isnu break the

Socialist Organiser no. 526, 11 June 1992 · scan p. 12 · about 910 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 12 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 12

State powen argued Lenin (in this excerpt from histlampus pamphlet. State and Revolution a connot ustabe whittiedwawaywit bymbit Asale socialistenovementi grows rit will havento meet violent hitacks from therexisting states powen anda illiti isnto wvinmitawill have toi break them owvemof the capitalstastates The witlening, away ofthenstater the lisappeanance ofuspecid bhrepressioni standingeabove society isapps siblemondy after the minortyi nulia messeda capitalists hewerbeen overthrown.

After formulating his famous - proposition that "the state withers away" ", Engels at once explains specifically that this proposition is directed against both the opportunists and the anarchists. In doing this Engels puts in the forefront that conclusion drawn from the proposition concerning the withering away of the state which is directed against the opportunists.

One can wager that out of every 10,000 persons who have read or heard about the "withering away" of the state, 9,990 are completely unaware, or do not remember, that Engels directed his conclusions from this proposition not against the anarchists alone. And of the remaining ten, probably nine do not know the meaning of a "free people's state" or why an attack on this slogan means an attack on the opportunists. This is how history is written. This is how a great revolutionary teaching is imperceptibly falsified and adapted to prevailing philistinism. The conclusion directed against the anarchists has been repeated thousands of times, vulgarised, rammed into people's heads in the shallowest form and has acquired the strength of a prejudice; whereas the conclusion directed against the opportunists has been slurred over and "forgotten".

The "free people's state was a programmatic demand and a widely current slogan of the German Social-Democrats in the 1870s. This slogan is devoid of all political content except that it describes the concept of democracy in pompous philistine fashion. In so far as it hinted in a legally permissible manner at a democratic republic, Engels was prepared to "justify" its "temporary" use from an agitational point of view. But it was an opportunist slogan; for it expressed not only an embellishment of bourgeois democracy, but also failure to understand the socialist criticism of the state in general. We are in favour of a democratic republic as the best form of the state for the proletariat under capitalism; but we have no right to forget that wage slavery is the lot of the people even in the most democratic bourgeois republic. Furthermore, every state is a "special repressive force" against the oppressed class. Consequently, every state is not "free" and not a "people's state.' " Marx and Engels explained this repeatedly to their party comrades in the seventies.

This very same work of Engels'. from which everyone remembers the argument about the withering away of the state, contains an argument on the significance of violent revolution. With Engels, the historical analysis of its role becomes a veritable panegyric on violent revolution. This "no one remembers"; it is not good form in modern socialist parties to talk or even think about the significance of this idea, and it plays no part whatever in their daily propaganda and agitation among the masses. And yet, it is inseparably bound up with the "withering away" of the in the most democratic bourgeois republic."

state into one harmonious Here is Engels' argument:

"That force, however, plays yet another role [other than that of evil-doing] in history, a revolutionary role; that, in the words of Marx, it is the midwife of every old society pregnant with a new one, that it is the instrument by means of which social movement forces its way through and shatters the dead, fossilised political forms - of this there is not a word in Herr Duhring. It is only with sighs and groans that he admits the possibility that force will perhaps be necessary for the overthrow of the economy based on exploitation -alas because all use of force, forsooth, demoralises the person who uses it. And this in spite of the immense moral and spiritual advance which has been the result of every victorious revolution And this too in Germany, where a violent collision - which may after all be forced on the people - would at least have the advantage of wiping out the servility which has penetrated the national consciousness as a result of the humiliation of the Thirty Years' War. It is this preachers' mentality, dull, insipid and impotent, that claims the right to impose itself on the most revoform a single doctrine?

Usually the two are combined by means of eclecticism, by an unprincipled or sophistic selection made arbitrarily (or to, please the powers that be) of now one, now another argument, and in ninety-nine cases out of a hundred, if not more often, it is the idea of the "withering away" that is placed in the forefront. Dialectics "Force is the midwife of every old society pregnant with a new one. It is the instrument by means o which social movemen violent revolution lies at the root of the entire teaching of Marx and Engels. The betrayal of their teaching by the now predominant social-chauvinist and Kautskyite trends finds particularly striking expression in the neglect of such propaganda and agitation by both these trends.

The supercession of the bourgeois state by the proletarian state is impossible without a violent revolution. Doing away with the proletarian state, i.e., with the state in general, is impossible except through "withering away"

----- pull-quotes -----

"Wage slavery is the lot of the people even

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 526

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →