[DarI Let kon Graphy of the gin century…]
Socialist Organiser1992 1992-06-11Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 11 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 11
DarI Let kon Graphy of the gin century Try be de Jary Scott's review of the first biogradical leader, Joe Cowen (Socialist Organiser 521) is quite correct to underline Cowen's importance for the Marxist movement in this country.
Cowen was never, formally, a Marxist.
Indeed, he was a Liberal. MP; But one who supported strikes, funded European Republican movements and, it would seem, made the bombs with which Orsini tried and failed to blow Napoleon up with in 1858.
Cowen represented a link between physical force Chartists and the Marxism of the Social Democratic Federation, whose Newcastle branch funded even after his politics became pro-imperialist in the mid-1880s.
Nigel Todd, the author of the biography, portrays Cowen as the greatest leader which British Marxism never had. Certainly, compared to the current crop of labour leaders, Cowen was an absolute inspiration. Yet his politics remained on the extreme left of bourgeois radicalism. He baulked at the idea of party political organisation in a Marxist sense. If anything, he might be seen as a forerunner to British anarchism, rather than British Marxism.
Despite Todd's excellent book, Cowen left extensive archives and there is plenty of room for further research and interpretations of Joe Cowen.
Charles Murray, Tottenham n denouncing the call for "Troops of Ireland Now" as "irresponsible, •Socialist Organiser is travelling the same road, impelled by social democracy and extreme Stalinophobia, as the Stalinist Official IRA.
Anti-imperialism is, for Socialist Organiser, an "ideological lie' that the left tells itself All qualitative distinctions vanısh. Effectively, you argue that there is no such thing as British imperialism. The British army is just one more armed force in a confused situation and since, as you say, "Britain has stopped sectarian civil war for the last 20 years", whatever caveats or reservations you may then employ, you end up giving 'critical' support to British imperialism.
Your 'alternative' to British rule is "The people of the Six Counties need a radical, democratic solution, not bloody stop gaps". What kind of perspective is this coming from people who claim to be Trotskyists?
Now we see where SO is coming from when it insists that "Permanent Revolution does not apply in Ireland." You mean that Stalin's theory of two-stage revolution' does apply there. The list of demands you give at the end of the article amount to liberalism - a belief that if Protestants and Catholics would only agree to be nice to each other, respect each other's rights etc. all would be well. 'Socialism' has to
----- pull-quotes -----
.. Dut wrong on Ireland